Rose: Difference between revisions

From About Time Again
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Formatting)
m (Rose moved to X1.1 Rose: Using episode numbers as well as names)
(No difference)

Revision as of 22:46, 12 April 2007

Series 1, Episode 1; one episode, 26th March 2005

Which One is This?

Rose and the rest of us meet the new Doctor, who of course is mysterious and eccentric. Oh, and there’s something about an invasion of shop dummies...

Firsts and Lasts

It’s the first episode of the first new Who in nine years, so (deep breath): The title sequence is new, with new graphics, music and logo. For the first time, the lead actors’ names are shown before the title of the programme. We meet both the Ninth Doctor and Rose Tyler here, as well as Rose’s Mum Jackie, and her boyfriend Mickey. The new TARDIS exterior and interior make their debut. The Doctor’s new look sonic screwdriver is seen for the first time. Clive is the first contemporary human character in the series to research the Doctor. The Internet is used on screen for the first time. Rose is the first companion given a clear choice between her normal life and travelling with the Doctor, and also the first to be given a second chance when she initially says no.

In terms of the new series, it's the first episode not to have a pre-title teaser, and the last until Smith and Jones two years later. It's the first time we see the zoom-in from space to London shot (and we'll be seeing that again, in X2.0 The Christmas Invasion and x2.12 Doomsday). It's the first time anyone mentions The Time War (see below).

Things to Notice About Rose

  1. The Doctor’s only truly serious moment before confronting the Consciousness in the finale, which occurs when he tells Rose to forget him and strides towards the TARDIS. There’s little seriousness from him for the rest of the episode.

The Continuity

The Doctor

The Doctor knows about current Earth celebrities (one of whom is an alien), can read a book in the time it takes to flick through the pages, and isn’t good at card tricks. He may have recently regenerated as he inspects his reflection as though for the first time, generally happy but critical of his ears. He has trouble empathising with humans, describing them as “dumb apes blundering about” and “stupid little people”, but clearly still has great affection for them and sees in them great potential.

Inventory

A new sonic screwdriver, which produces bright blue light as well as sonic vibrations, and is capable of interrupting the thought control signal animating an Auton, welding shut a metal door, and shorting out basic electronics. He also has an explosive device with an electronic timer, and a large test tube filled with dark blue “anti-plastic”.

Ethics

He’s not averse to getting physical with the Autons to stop them destroying all of humanity, but seems quite detached about the deaths of individuals, considering them of little importance; he fails to consider that Mickey is dead, or that Rose might be upset about it. While he’s prepared to kill the Consciousness to save the human race, he will only do so as a last resort, preferring negotiation if possible.

Background

Clive’s evidence shows that the Ninth Doctor was present during JFK’s final parade in Dallas in 1963; visited Southampton in 1912, where he advised a family not to travel on the Titanic; and was sketched by an unknown party standing in front of the eruption of Krakatoa on August 26th, 1888 (Clive claims the picture washed up on the coast of Sumatra the same night). The armies of Ghengis Khan once tried to board the TARDIS, but couldn’t get through the doors. See also The War.

Rose

Rose left school before completing her A-levels because of Jimmy Stones [a previous boyfriend?], and that ended badly. She lives in a flat with her Mum Jackie (who appears to be unemployed) and worked in the clothing department of Henrik’s, until the store was blown up by the Doctor. She has a friend named Suki. She competed in gymnastics at Jericho Street Junior School and showed some talent, winning bronze in the under-sevens competition. Given the chance, she wilfully leaves behind her Mum and her boyfriend to travel in the TARDIS.

The TARDIS

The TARDIS external doors are now also the internal doors, and the interior can be seen from the outside (and vice versa). The console room has changed radically, though the new console itself has a column similar to that seen in the previous version. The Doctor is able to pilot the TARDIS very accurately; he is also able to follow the psychic signal controlling an Auton back to its source by attaching a complex enough part of it to the console. When asked by Rose if the TARDIS flies, the Doctor explains “It disappears there and reappears here, you wouldn’t understand.” [Given Rose’s rememberance of Newsround documentaries in the next episode, he’s being rather ungenerous; she could certainly at least imagine such a thing.]

Planet Notes

The Nestene Consciousness is a single entity composed of living plastic [contradicting both Spearhead From Space and Terror of the Autons] whose food stocks (”protein planets”) were all destroyed in “the war”. The Doctor mentions he couldn’t save the Consciousness’s world, which may mean it’s home planet was also destroyed. It wants to colonise the Earth in order to consume it, and it’s ideal because of the toxins, oil, smoke and dioxins. It seems to have come physically to Earth and manifests as a bubbling pool of molten plastic, though it is not clear if this is a natural form or whether the consciousness has projected itself into plastic found on Earth. It allows the Doctor audience when he invokes “section 15 of the Shadow Proclamation”, and protests to him of “constitutional rights”. It recognises the Doctor as a Time Lord, and the TARDIS as terrifyingly superior techonology, and is destroyed (killed?) by the Doctor’s “anti-plastic” [perhaps a weapon from the War; see below].

History

By this time, some members of the human race have noticed that an individual named the Doctor keeps appearing throughout history. Clive has a web site devoted to the subject, and has collected evidence of Doctor sightings [according to the BBC’s version it’s taken over by Mickey after Clive’s death; see Aliens of London] . He has uncovered stories about the previous Auton invasion [or invasions, though almost certainly the first one as no shop dummies were involved in the second. Given his obsession, it seems odd that Clive hasn’t documented other Doctors, but then he does say to Rose “That’s your Doctor there, isn’t it?”, indicating he may be aware of more than one. Apart from the invasion attempt and Clive’s reference, there’s no indication that this Earth is any different from our one.]

The War

The Doctor fought in the war in which the Consciousness’ protein planets were destroyed, but was unable to save those planets, or “any of them”. [So the Consciousness was either on the other side or was an innocent casualty. While the Doctor’s willingness to give the Consciousness a chance might indicate the latter, it seems unlikely that all the Consciousness’ food planets could be destroyed by accident; and, of course, it’s terrified of the TARDIS and knows about Time Lords, so it must know how devastating Gallifreyan technology can be. Perhaps it was an ally of the Time Lords’ enemies rather than an active participant? That would explain the difference in the Doctor’s attitude between here and Dalek, though that it’s not a Dalek may of course be enough to explain that.]

The Time Lords

Time Lords are known to the Nestene Consciousness [unsurprising, since it worked with one (the Master) on its previous invasion attempt, though see The War.] The Doctor doesn’t mention them when explaining to Rose that he’s an alien.

The Analysis

Where does this come from?

See article.

Things that Don’t Make Sense

Why does the Consciousness need a relay in Henrik’s department store when it can control some plastic without one, and all the plastic in the world [eventually; the signal takes time to build up strength] using just the London Eye transmitter? [Without a relay or transmitter of some kind, perhaps it is unable to co-ordinate multiple Autons etc. at once? This seems unlikely given it can attack the Doctor with two in its own lair, but then proximity may also be a factor.] Why do the Autons in Henrik’s kill Wilson, the chief electrician? [He got in the way when they were looking for the Doctor, just like Rose. Or perhaps the relay patched into the electric systems and they were protecting it from discovery.]

Given that it needed to infiltrate factories to create Autons and other usable plastic items in the previous invasions, how did it create the Autons seen here? [They’re leftovers from the first invasion which were never activated, though this assumes UNIT didn’t round up every dummy in London afterwards, and they’ve been updated with modern dummy heads. The Consciousness is able to not only animate but entirely change the shape of plastic objects here, though, so perhaps it has just modified existing dummies to suit its purpose. If that’s true, though, then why don’t the Autons seen before the invasion commences ever use, or even seem to have, guns? Perhaps the most plausible explanation is that this is the Doctor at the end of stopping the invasion - he’s already found their conspirators and shut down the factory, now he has to stop the Consciousness from using the already-deployed Autons.]

If the Consciousness can animate any plastic in the whole world without special treatment, why bother with the Autons at all? Why not just suffocate, stab or otherwise attack humanity with every nearby plastic object at its disposal, as the Doctor and Rose discuss? [Perhaps it needs workers to process the planet’s resources so it can feed on them, and given the infrastructure in place, human sized and shaped servants make the most sense. The Doctor may also be simplifying things for Rose.]

Perhaps most inexplicably, why don’t the Autons kill Jackie Tyler? They spend an awful lot of time pointing their guns at her without firing…and, for that matter, wrestling with the Doctor on the edge of the Nestene pit.

Critique

See The Prosecution and The Defence

The Facts

Written by Russell T Davies. Directed by Keith Boak. Peak of 10.5 million viewers, 44.3% audience share.

Supporting cast: Camille Coduri (Jackie Tyler), Noel Clarke (Mickey Smith), Mark Benton (Clive), Ellie Garnett (Caroline), Adam McCoy (Clive’s Son), Alan Ruscoe, Paul Kasey, David Sant, Elizabeth Fost and Helen Otway (Autons), Nicholas Briggs (Nestene Voice)

Working Titles: None known.

The Teaser: There isn’t one.

Cliffhangers: None.

The Lore

  • A “slashprint” (a supposedly unfinished copy, but the only detectable difference was the original Delia Derbyshire theme) was leaked by an employee of one of the Canadian television networks bidding for the show, around two weeks before the UK broadcast. Rumours ran rife that this was planned as a marketing ploy by the BBC, but they deny it, and later legal action resulted in the culprit losing his job.
  • During the first transmission, sound bled over from Strictly Come Dancing several times during the first five minutes, completely ruining some tense moments for Rose in the basement of the department building.
  • BBC web designers made a “real” version of Clive’s web site, available at http://www.whoisdoctorwho.co.uk. The original page was almost identical to the one seen in the series, but it was updated after broadcast with news of the “killer plastic dolls” by a friend who had taken over from Clive. Subsequent updates include mention of mysterious voices being heard the same night as the invasion - referring to the sound bleed mentioned above. Readers were able to submit Doctor sightings and their experiences of the invasion.
  • In the week after the episode screened to almost universally positive reviews, the BBC announced that it had commissioned a second series and a special Christmas episode, and soon after that Christopher Eccleston would not be returning. Various reasons were cited included fear of being typecast and the gruelling schedule, but it was later revealed that the BBC had not contacted Eccleston before responding to press queries, and that his departure was meant to have been kept secret. See What Really Happened With Christopher Eccleston?