A Town Called Mercy
| X7.3 - “A Town Called Mercy” | ||||
| Doctor Who Series 7, Episode 3, September 15, 2012 | ||||
| Featuring the Eleventh Doctor with Amy Pond and Rory Williams | ||||
| Written by Toby Whithouse, directed by Saul Metzstein, produced by Marcus Wilson. | ||||
| “Dinosaurs on a Spaceship” | << | “A Town Called Mercy” | >> | “The Power of Three” |
Which One is This?
The sci-fi western with the guy from Farscape in it.
Firsts and Lasts
It's the first time the Eleventh Doctor points a gun at someone, and the last time the Doctor uses a pistol (his last time was in X4.16, The End of Time). It's also the last time the Doctor wears a Stetson (X6.1, The Impossible Astronaut, X6.11, Closing Time), and the last time someone shoots his hat off (X5.12, The Pandorica Opens, X6.1, The Impossible Astronaut). It's also the last time he is deputised in the Old West, the first time having been way back in 3.8, The Gunfighters.
Three Things to Notice About A Town Called Mercy
- .
- .
- .
The Continuity
The Doctor
Keeps a Christmas list (as mentioned in X6.2, Dinosaurs on a Spaceship.) Now claims he is 1200 years old, which if accurate means it's 97 (for him) since his "death" in X6.13, The Wedding of River Song. He "speaks horse" [or at least claims to].
Inventory
The sonic screwdriver is used to shatter glass and distract the Gunslinger.
Ethics
The Doctor discovers the truth about Kahler-Jek and seems to seriously consider handing him over to the Gunslinger, reflecting that whenever he has been merciful and tried to understand villains like the Master or the Daleks in the past, they have returned to kill again. He goes so far as to pull a gun on Jek, but Amy talks him out of using it, or handing him over. After much toing and froing, the Doctor eventually decides to allow Jek to escape, but Jek, ashamed of his crimes, kills himself to avoid putting anyone else in danger from the Gunslinger's wrath.
Background
The Doctor feels remorse for all the people killed by the Master, the Daleks and other foes because he showed his enemies mercy. He claims to know "what really happened" to the dogs and monkeys sent into space during Earth's early years of spaceflight. He has heard of the Kahler and knows their reputation for technological advancement, [though he seems not to have met any in person before].
The Supporting Cast
Amy Pond - disagrees with the Doctor about handing over Jex, even after he has taken her hostage, saying it's not their place to march people to their execution, and talks him out of it. Jex recognises that she is a mother because of her gentleness and kindness [quite opposite to the usually fiercely protective mothering we've seen from Amy in the past].
Rory Williams - agrees with the Doctor's initial assessment that Jex should pay for his crimes and be handed over to the Gunslinger, despite his work saving the townsfolk from cholera. [This seems out of character for the usually very peaceful Rory, especially when dealing with a fellow medical professional, though it could be that Jek's shocking lack of ethics for a doctor are what provoke his reaction.]
The TARDIS
Misses Mexico by 200 miles.
The Non-Humans
The Kahler - well-known throughout the galaxy for their technological prowess. They appear almost entirely human, but have [natural?] tattoo-like markings on their faces. These are unique and allow them to be identified. They all use "Kahler" as a prefix for their names [or at least, the ones mentioned here do; it may also indicate some kind of rank or caste]. During a war, Kahler-Jek was a scientist who, along with others including Kahler-Mas, created powerful cyborg soldiers from unwilling subjects. One, Kahler-Tek, had broken free enough of his programming to come after the scientists who altered him, killing them in revenge. Kahler-Jex is considered a war criminal for his actions. [It's unclear if the war was between the Kahler and another species, or between factions of the Kahler people, but it seems clear from Jex and Tek's opinions that the cyborg experiments were against Kahler law.] Kahler-Jex is able to use his medical knowledge to cure human diseases like cholera [suggesting that the similarities between human and Kahler physiology are more than skin-deep; it's possible the Kahler are a future offshoot of humanity and that Jex and the others are also time travellers, though nothing in the dialogue suggests this].
History
- Dating: Some time in 1870, Mercy, [Nevada. The state is never mentioned in dialogue, but a wanted poster in the Sherrif's office is signed by the Governor of Nevada, and it's the right distance from Mexico.]
The Analysis
Where does this come from?
Things that Don’t Make Sense
Critique
The Facts
Written by Toby Whithouse. Directed by Saul Metzstein. 8.42 million viewers.
Supporting cast: Ben Browder (Isaac); Adrian Scarborough (Kahler-Jex); Dominic Kemp (Kahler-Mas); Rob Cavazos (Walter); Joanne McQuinn (Sadie); Andrew Brooke (The Gunslinger); Garrick Hagon (Abraham); Byrd Wilkins (The Preacher); Sean Benedict (Dockery)
Oh, Isn't That...?
- Ben Browder - star of the American-Australian (rather good) sci-fi-with-muppets series Farscape, in which he played the human astronaut John Crichton; he also joined the cast of Stargate SG-1 for it's final two series, and the sequel telemovies that followed, where he was reunited with his Farscape co-star Claudia Black.
- Adrian Scarborough - seen all over British television, especially in comedies like Gavin & Stacey, Let Them Eat Cake, Psychoville and Miranda. His best-known characters is probably the butler Mr. Pitchard in the 2010 remake of Upstairs, Downstairs, which also stars River Song herself, Alex Kingston. He has also been in several films, including The Madness of King George, The King's Speech and Gosford Park, and is an award-winning stage actor.
- Andrew Brooke - it's not likely you'll recognise him under all that makeup, but Brooke has been in loads of television, most notably starring as co-worker Ashley in the Channel 4 sitcom PhoneShop from 2009 to 2011.
- Garrick Hagon - he was the rebel leader Ky in 9.4, The Mutants back in 1972, but honestly he's more famous for a little film made in 1977 from which most of his prominent scenes were cut: he played Luke Skywalker's moustachioed mate Biggs Darklighter. You can see all his major scenes in the Blu-Ray release from 2011. He was also Simon Gerrard in the long-running BBC radio serial The Archers, and is a prolific voice actor and audiobook reader.
Working Titles:
The Teaser: A woman narrates a story about "a man who fell from the stars and was weighed down by the things he had seen". We follow the Gunslinger as he tracks down Kahler-Jas, telling him to make peace with his gods. Jas asks if he is the last one; the Gunslinger replies there is one more: "the Doctor".
The Lore
- .