Silence in the Library
| X4.8 - “Silence in the Library” | ||||
| Doctor Who Series 4, Episode 8, May 31st, 2008 | ||||
| Featuring the Tenth Doctor with Donna Noble | ||||
| Written by Steven Moffat, directed by Graeme Harper, produced by Phil Collinson. | ||||
| “The Unicorn and the Wasp” | << | “Silence in the Library” | >> | “Forest of the Dead” |
Which One is This?
Firsts and Lasts
Two Things to Notice About Silence in the Library
- .
- .
The Continuity
The Doctor
Inventory
Ethics
Background
Foreground
In his personal future, but still in his tenth incarnation, the Doctor will meet River Song many more times, clearly forming quite an intense relationship. [Given her familiarity with his time travelling, it's surprising Professor Song takes so long to realise this is their first meeting, so perhaps the Doctor forgets this meeting or pretends he doesn't know who she is on their first meeting from her perspective.]
The Supporting Cast
Donna -
River Song - A future lover, or at least very close friend, of the Doctor. She has a notebook containing details of their encounters so she can orient herself to meeting him out of sequence [a great many times, since the book is pretty full]; its cover resembles the police box exterior of the TARDIS, so she's clearly seen it, though she gives no indication of whether she has travelled with the Doctor. [The implication seems to be that they ran into each other a few times by accident, and then more-or-less on purpose, though clearly their personal timelines are out of sequence.]
The TARDIS
The Non-Humans
Vashta Nerada -
Planet Notes
The Library -
History
- Dating: The Doctor visits The Library sometime in the 51st century.
The Library was sealed in mysterious circumstances a century earlier [so some interesting things do happen in the 50th century]. It was conceived and built by Lux's ancestors [so, since we can assume that human lifespans are probably around a century and generations perhaps represent 30 or 40 years rather than 25, this could have happened many centuries earlier].
The Analysis
Where does this come from?
Things that Don’t Make Sense
Critique
The Facts
Written by Steven Moffat. Directed by Euros Lyn. 5.4 million viewers. 36% audience share.
Supporting cast: Alex Kingston (Professor River Song), Colin Salmon (Doctor Moon), Eve Newton (The Girl), Mark Dexter (Dad), Sarah Niles (Node 1), Joshua Dallas (Node 2), Steve Pemberton (Strackman Lux), Talulah Riley (Miss Evangelista), Jessika Williams (Anita), O-T Fagbenle (Other Dave), Harry Peacock (Proper Dave)
Oh, Isn't That...?
- Alex Kingston was best known to audiences on both sides of the pond (ha!) for playing another Doctor, Elizabeth Corday, in ER. She left the show in some controversy when the producers did not renew her contract as they felt she was too old and her character thus uninteresting, though she later returned for a few episodes towards the series' end. As well as film roles in The Cook, The Thief, His Wife and Her Lover and the title part in 1996's Moll Flanders, she's done lots of good telly, playing Ellie in Hope Springs, Mrs. Bennett in Lost in Austen and Dr. Blanche Mottershead in the 21st century version of Upstairs Downstairs.
- Colin Salmon has had plenty of high-profile film work, including the ill-fated commander in the first Resident Evil film, and MI6 chief of staff Charles Robinson in the last three Pierce Brosnan Bond films. On telly he's been in Keen Eddie, Trial & Retribution, Hex, Single Ladies and - with Eleventh Doctor Matt Smith - Party Animals.
- Steve Pemberton is one third of the League of Gentlemen, alongside Who scribe and actor Mark Gatiss. Aside from their television series he also stars in Psychoville with the other League member, Reece Shearsmith. Among his many movie credits are Mr. Prosser in the film version of Hitchhiker's, Woody Allen's Match Point and Drumknott, Lord Verinari's assistant, in the Pratchett adaptation Going Postal.
- Talulah Riley isn't a big name yet, but you may have seen her in the incredibly bonkers batshit insane BBC3 pilot Phoo Action, or in either of the two modern St Trinian's films.
Working Titles:
The Teaser: The Girl describes her daydreams to a psychiatrist, Doctor Moon. Whenever she closes her eyes, she leaves her life behind and floats through a gigantic but deserted library. In the daydream, she hears a noise, concerning her father who assures Doctor Moon she's always been alone there before. Suddenly the doors to the room she is are flung open and in burst the Doctor and Donna. The Doctor bars the door with a book, then introduces himself, whereupon the Girl opens her eyes in surprise and concern.
Cliffhanger:
The Lore