The Girl in the Fireplace
| X2.4 - “The Girl in the Fireplace” | ||||
| Doctor Who Series 2, Episode 4, 6 May, 2006 | ||||
| Featuring the Tenth Doctor with Rose Tyler and Mickey Smith | ||||
| Written by Steven Moffat, directed by Euros Lyn, produced by Phil Collinson. | ||||
| “School Reunion” | << | “The Girl in the Fireplace” | >> | “Rise of the Cybermen” |
Which One is This?
Mickey, Rose and the Doctor visit a spaceship in the far future which has a horse in it and time windows that let the Doctor jaunt back to pre-revolutionary France for a bit of action.
Firsts and Lasts
Mickey finally gets a proper go as a companion, travelling in the TARDIS for the first time. It's therefore a shame that he gets so little screen time and so little to do, what with this also being the first episode to heavily centre on the new Doctor.
Things to Notice About The Girl in the Fireplace
The Continuity
The Doctor
Still loves bananas in this incarnation, and loves to dance (make of that what you will).
Inventory
Ethics
Seemingly quite happy to leave Mickey and Rose stranded with the TARDIS if it means saving Reinette [he's either blinded by love or considers the possible implications for Earth history to be too horrible; Pompadour was very influential, after all, and besides there's the possibility of a paradox if she doesn't live long enough to be famous by that name, because the ship would never be named after her.]
Background
The Doctor has met Cleopatra, whom he knows well enough to call "Cleo" (according to Mickey).
Rose
Clearly jealous of the Doctor's other girlfriends, and not shy about talking to Mickey about it. Has gotten over her irritation and possible jealousy over Mickey joining the crew [though this is apparently because Steven Moffat wrote this without having read the end of School Reunion, rather than because of a deliberate character choice], and is enjoying mucking about with him on the spaceship.
Mickey
Excited that he lands in a spaceship on his "first go" in the TARDIS [so this takes place immediately after X3.3, School Reunion]. Almost immediately adopts the role of the cheeky
The TARDIS
Seems to be set on random this week, as the Doctor doesn't know where or when he is until he looks at the spaceship.
History
The War
The Time Lords
The Arc Word
Torchwood: No reference this week...though only, according to the audio commentary, because Davies didn't ask Moffat to put one in.
The Lonely God: Reinette refers to the Doctor as her "lonely angel".
The Analysis
Where does this come from?
Things that Don’t Make Sense
Surprisingly little this week. Though quite how the time windows work is a bit dodgy; why does time pass at different rates on each side? When and how do they shift time frames? And why do the clockwork robots build so many of them, unless they connect to different moments during Reinette's life, rather than just different physical locations? Again, the Doctor is immensely stupid: he knows that he can't go back into someone's personal timeline [though see X3.1, Smith and Jones], but rather than just getting in the TARDIS to go and pick up Reinette he blunders through one of the time windows which he knows advance through time at an unpredictable rate. At least they have a sense for the dramatic. Another thing though - the windows seem to "know" when someone from the ship has passed through them, because time passes at the same rate on each side during the Doctor's trips, only fast forwarding for pre-Revolutionary France when he's not there.
Critique
The Facts
Written by Steven Moffat. Directed by Euros Lyn. Peak of 7.9 million viewers, 36.6% audience share.
Supporting cast:
Working Titles: Madame de Pompadour, Every Tick of My Heart, Reinette and the Lonely Angel.
The Teaser: Madame de Pompadour looks out her window at the stars as violent commotion occurs in her home. Despite being told to leave, she kneels by the fire, speaking into it and calling for the Doctor.
The Lore
- Sophia Myles keeps her eyes open in the scene where the Doctor reads Reinette's mind, and according to David Tennant this completely surprised him when he saw it, since he thought she'd have hers closed too. It's a sweet moment, because around the time Tennant and Myles were together, though their media profile as a celebrity couple was surprisingly low.
- In an audio commentary Moffat says that he believes there must be a "dreadful secret" about the Doctor's name, otherwise he'd tell it to at least one of his closest companions. Hence Reinette's line about the Doctor's name being a secret, though Sophia Myles revealed that she didn't know the Doctor's name wasn't actually "Doctor Who".