Thin Ice

From About Time Again
Jump to navigation Jump to search
X10.3 - “Thin Ice”
Doctor Who Series 10, Episode 3, April 29, 2017
Featuring the Twelfth Doctor with Bill Potts and Nardole
Written by Sarah Dollard, directed by Bill Anderson, produced by Nikki Wilson.
“Smile” << “Thin Ice” >> “Knock Knock”

Which One is This?

The one with a sea monster under the frozen Thames where the Doctor punches a racist guy in the face.

Firsts and Lasts

Three Things to Notice About Thin Ice

  1. .
  2. .
  3. .

The Continuity

The Doctor

Says that the past is whitewashed, specifically mentioning that Jesus is not white as he is often depicted in Western art. Has no trouble getting along with children, feeding them and reading them Struwwelpeter to distract them from the death of their friend. Is skilled at forgery, altering a deed to make Perry, one of the street children, heir to the Sutcliffe estate. Tells Bill that every day of your life you make decisions which might effect the entire future, implying that travelling into the past places no additional weight on one's actions. Jokes that Bill had a friend named Pete whom she has forgotten because he erased himself from history.

Inventory

Sonic screwdriver - used more-or-less as a torch, and also to attract the fish which catch humans for "Tiny". Tied up with string and activated, pointed at the ice, to attract the fish to the tent containing the explosives, so they would sink before exploding, freeing Tiny from her chains. The Doctor used the string to retrieve the screwdriver from the Thames. He also has 19th century money, two top hats, a 19th century outfit, and a book of children's stories which includes Struwwelpeter.

Ethics

Has lost count of the number of deaths he has seen, and [it's implied] the number of deaths he's caused. He says he "moved on", as many more would have died if he hadn't. Again says he is a "servant to humanity" in a situation where humans, not aliens, are causing the trouble he wants to solve [as in X8.7, Kill the Moon], and asks Bill what to do about the creature under the ice. Says that the value of a species is measured by how much it values the most "unimportant" lives. Punches Sutcliffe when he is overtly racist, and sadly considers this proof Sutcliffe is not an alien.

Background

Says he's been to this Frost Fair more than once before (including a trip with River Song for her birthday, according to her in A Good Man Goes to War). He says the only "real wrestling" is in zero gravity with tentacles and magic spells.

The Supporting Cast

Bill Potts - is concerned about racism in 1800s London, and surprised that it's not nearly as white as shown on television. Says she is "low-key in love with" the TARDIS because it has dresses and likes looking for trouble. Once she feels safe is excited to try "everything", but baulks at some of the weirder meats on sale, and later is grossed out that the pies she enjoyed were made out of the possibly alien fish. Is upset when Spider dies, having never seen anyone die before, and directs her anger at the Doctor.

Nardole - repeatedly reminds the Doctor about his oath, and when asked to leave the Doctor alone, checks on the Vault by himself. Mutters that he wished the Doctor had never reassembled him [confirming he is mostly robot]. He is shocked to hear knocking from inside the Vault, but knows that someone is in there, and tells them he won't be letting them out unless Doctor specifically requests it.

The TARDIS

The Doctor again says you don't steer the TARDIS, but negotiate with it, and descibes her as a "bad girl, always looking for trouble". From the console room, the wardrobe is "first door on the left, second right, under the stairs, past the bins, fifth door on the left", and contains dresses.

The Non-Humans

"Tiny" - an enormous sea serpent able to create cold, possibly alien but possibly terrestrial. She [as the Doctor genders her] is responsible for several of the freezes of the Thames, having been chained in the river for several human generations. It feeds on humans, one at a time, which it locates with the help of a school of football-sized non-carnivorous fish which have evolved to resemble angler fish. [The Doctor asks what the fish get out of the arrangement, but the question is never answered.] "Tiny" The creature's excrement can be shaped into bricks that burn far hotter and longer than coal, and can even burn underwater. When freed "Tiny" exits the Thames, presumably to find somewhere colder to live.

History

  • Dating: London, on the final day of the last frost fair: February 4, 1814; St Luke's University, 2017.

The Analysis

Where does this come from?

Things that Don’t Make Sense

Critique

The Facts

Written by Sarah Dollard. Directed by Bill Anderson. ? million viewers (overnight).

Supporting cast: Nicholas Burns (Sutcliffe), Asiatu Koroma (Kitty), Peter Singh (Pie-Man), Simon Ludders (Overseer), Tomi May (Dowell), Austin Taylor (Spider), Ellie Shenker (Dot), Kishaina Thiruselvan (Harriet), Badger Skelton (Perry)

Oh, Isn't That...?

  • Nicholas Burns is better known as Martin Wheedon in Benidorm, Alex (aka "The Hotness") in ITV2 superhero sit-com No Heroics", and as the titular character in Chris Morris' comedy Nathan Barley, among other credits.
  • Simon Ludders will be recognised by those with kids from his long-time role as Renfield in Young Dracula, though he has also appeared in many other children's programs, including recurring or starring roles in Scoop and Gigglebiz. He was also in the first season of Broadchurch as concerned citizen Trevor Smith, and appeared previously in X2.1, New Earth, as a patient in the Sisters of Plentitude's hospital.

Working Titles:

The Teaser:

The Lore

  • .



Doctor Who Series Ten Episodes

The Return of Doctor Mysterio · The Pilot · Smile · Thin Ice · Knock Knock · Oxygen · Extremis · The Pyramid at the End of the World
The Lie of the Land · The Empress of Mars · The Eaters of Light · World Enough and Time · The Doctor Falls · Twice Upon A Time