Utopia: Difference between revisions

From About Time Again
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m (Added Jack category)
(Added Master category)
 
(19 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{EpisodeInfo
{{EpisodeInfo
|episode number = X3.10
|episode number = X3.11
|episode name = Utopia
|episode name = Utopia
|series = ''[[Doctor Who]]''
|series = ''[[Doctor Who]]''
|number = 3
|number = 3
|episode = 10
|episode = 11
|part = (1)
|doctor = the [[Tenth Doctor]]
|doctor = the [[Tenth Doctor]]
|companions = [[Martha Jones]] and [[Jack Harkness]]
|companions = [[Martha Jones]] and [[Jack Harkness]]
|writer = [[Russell T Davies]]
|writer = [[Russell T Davies]]
|director = [[]]
|director = [[Graeme Harper]]
|producer = [[]]
|producer = [[Phil Collinson]]
|broadcast date = June 9th, 2007
|broadcast date = June 16th, 2007
|production code = 3.10
|production code = 3.11
|previous episode = [[The Family of Blood]]
|previous episode = [[Blink]]
|next episode = [[Blink]]
|next episode = [[The Sound of Drums]]
}}
}}


=== Which One is This? ===
=== Which One is This? ===
It's The One With Derek Jacobi In It. Also a million fangirls swoon as John Barrowman and David Tennant finally share the screen.
It's The One With Derek Jacobi In It, and the Master comes back. Also a million fangirls swoon as John Barrowman and David Tennant finally share the screen, and in which we discover the end of the universe looks remarkably like Mad Max in a quarry.


=== Firsts and Lasts ===
=== Firsts and Lasts ===
It's the first three-parter of the new series, the first meeting between Jack and the Tenth Doctor, and the first time another Time Lord shows up post Time War. It's also the first time John Barrowman, or indeed anyone aside from the Doctor and main companion actors, gets his name in the title sequence credits.


Of course it's also the first appearance of the Master in the new series, played by Derek Jacobi and John Simm.


=== Things to Notice About ''{{PAGENAME}}'' ===  
=== Things to Notice About ''{{PAGENAME}}'' ===  
#  
# There's a lot going on here. Jack's return, the end of the universe (and the human race), not to mention a certain reappearance. Ah yes, the Master. He's always walked a fine line between being a cardboard villain, and a man very much aware that a lot of his behaviour can be interpreted as cardboard villainy. John Simm's first three lines remove any doubt whatsoever, and they're glorious.


== The Continuity ==
== The Continuity ==
=== The Doctor ===
=== The Doctor ===
He is never excited by Martha's revelation that Yana is a Time Lord, only horrified [he knows somehow that it must be the Master? He certainly doesn't waste much time on surprise when he learns that it ''is'' the Master, suggesting that he knows something of the latter's fate in the Time War]. "The End of Time Part 2" gives us some more context for this attitude, with the Doctor stating that the Time Lords (like the "human" Doctor of "Journey's End") have been changed by their time in battle, and not in a good way. Rather than welcoming their resurrection by the Master, he is once again horrified by the prospect of their return.


==== Inventory ====
==== Inventory ====
He attempts to use the sonic screwdriver to remote control the TARDIS, as in X1.13. ''[[The Parting of the Ways]]''. The Master is able to override this function from console.


==== Ethics ====
==== Ethics ====
Claims to have "run away" from Jack because he knows Jack is "wrong", a "fixed point in time" or "fact". [He seems to mean both in Cardiff at the start of the episode and when he left Jack behind on the GameStation in X1.13, ''[[The Parting of the Ways]]''.] He agrees with Jack's assessment that this makes him prejudiced. He apologises to the Master [for the Time War? For what happened in San Francisco in 1999? Or for something else?]


==== Background ====
==== Background ====
The Doctor and the Master may have history beyond their last onscreen meeting (in 27.1, ''[[Grace: 1999]]'').


=== Martha ===
=== Martha ===
Still coming second to Rose, in her own eyes if not the Doctor's. Doesn't mind Jack's (brief) attentions. She finds it no surprise Rose is a blonde. Recognises the Yana's fob watch and immediately makes the connection to the fact that it can mask a Time Lord.
=== Jack ===
=== The Master ===
Used a chameleon arch to transform himself into a human, "Professor" Yana, who was found as a naked child with his fob watch off the coast of The Silver Devastation [luckily it wasn't Jack or Ianto that found him, otherwise Yana might have had a very rude awakening]. As Yana, he is a brilliant scientist and genuinely philanthropic, perhaps suggesting that there has always been potential for good within the Master. Yana is plagued by the sound of drums in his head, which is somehow connected to his true identity [and likely his equivalent of John Smith's dreams of his life as the Doctor, though with much less detail].
==== Inventory ====
His Time Lord essence is stored inside a fob watch identical to the one used by the Doctor in X3.8, ''[[Human Nature]]''. [There's no evidence that the chameleon arch is a mass-produced device, so it's possible this is the ''same'' watch, used by the Master at some time before or after the Doctor possesses it.] As with the Doctor's essence, which spoke to Tim Latimer, the Master's essence speaks to Yana, echoing the laugh of his Tremas body and his appeal to Azal in 8.3, ''[[The Daemons]]''. He steals the Doctor's severed hand (from X2.0, ''[[The Christmas Invasion]]'') in the container Jack has kept it in, and also steals the Doctor's TARDIS, though he does not possess a key for it.


=== The TARDIS ===
=== The TARDIS ===
The interior doors can be locked from the inside such that a TARDIS key cannot open them. The mechanism looks and functions exactly like a normal Yale lock. There's no protection against the ship being piloted by someone else who knows how to operate it [further evidence, if any were really needed, to debunk that claim of the TARDIS controls being isomorphic--the Doctor was clearly lying through his teeth to Sutekh].


=== Planet Notes ===
=== Planet Notes ===
Malcassairo was once the home planet of Chantho's race, but they have all died out. It is now a stronghold for [some of?] the last surviving humans, who have detected transmissions from a beacon on the far edges of the Universe encouraging them to come to "Utopia". It is not revealed how or why any Professor Yana or any of the human refugees came to Malcassairo.


=== History ===
=== History ===


=== The War ===
=== The War ===
The Doctor is no longer the only Time Lord survivor of the Time War.


=== The Time Lords ===
=== The Time Lords ===
Line 49: Line 68:


=== Where does this come from? ===
=== Where does this come from? ===
''Blake's 7''. In particular, most of the crap ones written by Terry Nation and Allan Prior.
 
Oh, all right, we'll do it properly.


=== Things that Don’t Make Sense ===
=== Things that Don’t Make Sense ===
When the Doctor used the chameleon arch, he appeared physically the same, yet Yana claims to have been found off the coast of The Silver Devastation with his watch as a young child. No time frame is given for this; presumably Yana is as old as he looks, making it around 60 to 70 years before this episode. That's a long time to spend as a human without ever figuring out the watch, and a long time in which he would have been vulnerable. It may be that Yana's early life is an implanted memory, part of the personality generated for him as a cover story; certainly we never learn enough detail to suggest this is untenable.
How does the Face of Boe know about the Master, when he lived and died trillions of years before Yana showed up on the Silver Devastation? [Perhaps the Master used his chameleon arch there, and then somehow transported himself into the future. Alternatively, perhaps the Face of Boe is time-active in some way.] For that matter, why is he named Yana? [He may have been named by the Face, as part of his final message.]


== Critique ==
== Critique ==
Line 61: Line 87:
'''Working Titles:'''  
'''Working Titles:'''  


'''The Teaser:'''  
'''The Teaser:''' The TARDIS lands above the Rift in Cardiff, the Doctor explaining to Martha that they are refuelling. Jack runs towards the TARDIS, and the Doctor, seeing him on the scanner, takes off. Jack leaps for the TARDIS and the console showers sparks at the Doctor, who notes with alarm that they are accelerating through time to the end of the Universe - hurtling through the Vortex with Jack clinging to the outside...


== The Lore ==
== The Lore ==
*  
* Fan speculation about the identity of Mr. Saxon consistently named him as the Master, not least because his name is an anagram of "Master No. Six". Speculation was fuelled by ''The Sun'' newspaper.




Line 71: Line 97:
{{WhoNavThree}}
{{WhoNavThree}}


[[Category: Doctor Who]] [[Category: Doctor Who Series Three]] [[Category: Tenth Doctor]] [[Category: Martha]] [[Category: Future]]
[[Category: Doctor Who]] [[Category: Doctor Who Series Three]] [[Category: Tenth Doctor]] [[Category: Martha]] [[Category: Jack]] [[Category: The Master]] [[Category: Future]]
[[Category: Jack]]

Latest revision as of 06:05, 21 May 2017

X3.11 - “Utopia” (1)
Doctor Who Series 3, Episode 11, June 16th, 2007
Featuring the Tenth Doctor with Martha Jones and Jack Harkness
Written by Russell T Davies, directed by Graeme Harper, produced by Phil Collinson.
“Blink” << “Utopia” >> “The Sound of Drums”

Which One is This?

It's The One With Derek Jacobi In It, and the Master comes back. Also a million fangirls swoon as John Barrowman and David Tennant finally share the screen, and in which we discover the end of the universe looks remarkably like Mad Max in a quarry.

Firsts and Lasts

It's the first three-parter of the new series, the first meeting between Jack and the Tenth Doctor, and the first time another Time Lord shows up post Time War. It's also the first time John Barrowman, or indeed anyone aside from the Doctor and main companion actors, gets his name in the title sequence credits.

Of course it's also the first appearance of the Master in the new series, played by Derek Jacobi and John Simm.

Things to Notice About Utopia

  1. There's a lot going on here. Jack's return, the end of the universe (and the human race), not to mention a certain reappearance. Ah yes, the Master. He's always walked a fine line between being a cardboard villain, and a man very much aware that a lot of his behaviour can be interpreted as cardboard villainy. John Simm's first three lines remove any doubt whatsoever, and they're glorious.

The Continuity

The Doctor

He is never excited by Martha's revelation that Yana is a Time Lord, only horrified [he knows somehow that it must be the Master? He certainly doesn't waste much time on surprise when he learns that it is the Master, suggesting that he knows something of the latter's fate in the Time War]. "The End of Time Part 2" gives us some more context for this attitude, with the Doctor stating that the Time Lords (like the "human" Doctor of "Journey's End") have been changed by their time in battle, and not in a good way. Rather than welcoming their resurrection by the Master, he is once again horrified by the prospect of their return.

Inventory

He attempts to use the sonic screwdriver to remote control the TARDIS, as in X1.13. The Parting of the Ways. The Master is able to override this function from console.

Ethics

Claims to have "run away" from Jack because he knows Jack is "wrong", a "fixed point in time" or "fact". [He seems to mean both in Cardiff at the start of the episode and when he left Jack behind on the GameStation in X1.13, The Parting of the Ways.] He agrees with Jack's assessment that this makes him prejudiced. He apologises to the Master [for the Time War? For what happened in San Francisco in 1999? Or for something else?]

Background

The Doctor and the Master may have history beyond their last onscreen meeting (in 27.1, Grace: 1999).

Martha

Still coming second to Rose, in her own eyes if not the Doctor's. Doesn't mind Jack's (brief) attentions. She finds it no surprise Rose is a blonde. Recognises the Yana's fob watch and immediately makes the connection to the fact that it can mask a Time Lord.

Jack

The Master

Used a chameleon arch to transform himself into a human, "Professor" Yana, who was found as a naked child with his fob watch off the coast of The Silver Devastation [luckily it wasn't Jack or Ianto that found him, otherwise Yana might have had a very rude awakening]. As Yana, he is a brilliant scientist and genuinely philanthropic, perhaps suggesting that there has always been potential for good within the Master. Yana is plagued by the sound of drums in his head, which is somehow connected to his true identity [and likely his equivalent of John Smith's dreams of his life as the Doctor, though with much less detail].

Inventory

His Time Lord essence is stored inside a fob watch identical to the one used by the Doctor in X3.8, Human Nature. [There's no evidence that the chameleon arch is a mass-produced device, so it's possible this is the same watch, used by the Master at some time before or after the Doctor possesses it.] As with the Doctor's essence, which spoke to Tim Latimer, the Master's essence speaks to Yana, echoing the laugh of his Tremas body and his appeal to Azal in 8.3, The Daemons. He steals the Doctor's severed hand (from X2.0, The Christmas Invasion) in the container Jack has kept it in, and also steals the Doctor's TARDIS, though he does not possess a key for it.

The TARDIS

The interior doors can be locked from the inside such that a TARDIS key cannot open them. The mechanism looks and functions exactly like a normal Yale lock. There's no protection against the ship being piloted by someone else who knows how to operate it [further evidence, if any were really needed, to debunk that claim of the TARDIS controls being isomorphic--the Doctor was clearly lying through his teeth to Sutekh].

Planet Notes

Malcassairo was once the home planet of Chantho's race, but they have all died out. It is now a stronghold for [some of?] the last surviving humans, who have detected transmissions from a beacon on the far edges of the Universe encouraging them to come to "Utopia". It is not revealed how or why any Professor Yana or any of the human refugees came to Malcassairo.

History

The War

The Doctor is no longer the only Time Lord survivor of the Time War.

The Time Lords

The Analysis

Where does this come from?

Blake's 7. In particular, most of the crap ones written by Terry Nation and Allan Prior.

Oh, all right, we'll do it properly.

Things that Don’t Make Sense

When the Doctor used the chameleon arch, he appeared physically the same, yet Yana claims to have been found off the coast of The Silver Devastation with his watch as a young child. No time frame is given for this; presumably Yana is as old as he looks, making it around 60 to 70 years before this episode. That's a long time to spend as a human without ever figuring out the watch, and a long time in which he would have been vulnerable. It may be that Yana's early life is an implanted memory, part of the personality generated for him as a cover story; certainly we never learn enough detail to suggest this is untenable.

How does the Face of Boe know about the Master, when he lived and died trillions of years before Yana showed up on the Silver Devastation? [Perhaps the Master used his chameleon arch there, and then somehow transported himself into the future. Alternatively, perhaps the Face of Boe is time-active in some way.] For that matter, why is he named Yana? [He may have been named by the Face, as part of his final message.]

Critique

The Facts

Written by Russell T Davies.

Supporting cast:

Working Titles:

The Teaser: The TARDIS lands above the Rift in Cardiff, the Doctor explaining to Martha that they are refuelling. Jack runs towards the TARDIS, and the Doctor, seeing him on the scanner, takes off. Jack leaps for the TARDIS and the console showers sparks at the Doctor, who notes with alarm that they are accelerating through time to the end of the Universe - hurtling through the Vortex with Jack clinging to the outside...

The Lore

  • Fan speculation about the identity of Mr. Saxon consistently named him as the Master, not least because his name is an anagram of "Master No. Six". Speculation was fuelled by The Sun newspaper.


Doctor Who Series Three Episodes

The Runaway Bride · Smith and Jones · The Shakespeare Code · Gridlock · Daleks in Manhattan / Evolution of the Daleks
The Lazarus Experiment · 42 · Human Nature / The Family of Blood · Blink · Utopia / The Sound of Drums / Last of the Time Lords / Time Crash