Human Nature

From About Time Again
Jump to navigation Jump to search
X3.8 - “Human Nature” (1)
Doctor Who Series 3, Episode 8, May 26th, 2007
Featuring the Tenth Doctor with Martha Jones
Written by Paul Cornell, directed by Charles Palmer, produced by Susie Liggat.
“42” << “Human Nature” >> “The Family of Blood”

Which One is This?

John Smith has dreams of being an adventurer in time and space, and his maid Martha seems to take it all a bit too seriously.

Firsts and Lasts

This is the first full adaptation of a Doctor Who story from another medium into a television episode, and the first of a novel. (Dalek and Rise of the Cybermen were inspired by audio stories, but really only use a few ideas from the source material.) The Doctor (albeit as John Smith) kisses a non-companion character for the first time. It's the first use of traditional flashback (as opposed to the video diary compilation of X2.10, Love & Monsters) in the new series which involves new material rather than clips from previous episodes.

Things to Notice About Human Nature

The Continuity

The Doctor

Has clearly thought about turning himself into a human. As John Smith, he's a phenomenally good bowler, and a decent sketch artist.

Inventory

A fob watch, which engraved designs on the cover resembling Gallifreyan writing, stores the Doctor's “essence”. The watch is equipped with a perception filter (X1.11, “Boomtown”, T1.1, “Everything Changes” etc), which stops John Smith from noticing or remembering it for long. The Doctor’s essence leaks out and speaks to Tim when he touches the watch. On board the TARDIS is the Chameleon Arch, a device which can (very painfully) change every cell in his body, and can be programmed to transform the Doctor into a human, complete with false memories and personality. [He speaks about it as though he's had it a long time, and has considered using it before. It seems to be Time Lord technology; possibly it was designed to simulate or control the effects of regeneration, since the Doctor also describes that process as “changing every single cell” in Children in Need 2005, and here says he’s “set it to human”.] His other paraphernalia are left in Martha's care, stored in his usual clothes on board the TARDIS.

John Smith has his “Journal of Impossible Thoughts”, in which he scribbles notes and pictures from the dreams he has of being the Doctor. These include pictures of Daleks, the Slitheen, the clockwork robots of The Girl in the Fireplace, the Ood, Rose (though her face is indistinct) and several of his previous incarnations [they're all in the journal but only the Seventh, Eighth, First, Fifth and Sixth are visible on screen].

Ethics

As John Smith, the Doctor sees no problem with training boys to be soldiers or in issuing beatings to boys who protest. However he also sees the potential in Tim Latimer and understands that he hides his talents to avoid bullying from the other boys, but advises him that he shouldn't hide such gifts away.

Background

Seems to have encountered the Family before, or at least to be familiar with their species (assuming more of them exist) and technology.

Martha

Works as a maid at the school where John Smith works, having been hired on his recommendation. She seems to be living in the TARDIS. Shrugs off racist abuse with relative ease, but struggles to behave like a servant or conceal her concern (or other feelings) for “Mr Smith”.

The TARDIS

Chooses a location for the Doctor to hide in. [The Discontinuity Guide has the cute theory that this accounts for the very similar set of circumstances to the Seventh Doctor’s stint as a human, as it remembers that working out and so seeks something very similar (but different).]

Planet Notes

The Family of Blood have [naturally?] very short lifespans; the Doctor’s plan is to hide for three months, by which time they should have died [though see Things That Don’t Make Sense]. They are able to take varying forms, possessing the bodies of their victims permanently, effectively killing the subject, but it’s uncertain whether they possess “natural” forms. When taking on human form, they envelop the victim as a green mist which emerges from a glowing sphere. When they use psychic powers, to communicate or access their victims’ memories, their faces glow with a green light. Their species is never named.

History

John Smith is working as a schoolteacher at Farringham School for Boys in takes place in 1913, so there's much foreshadowing of World War I.

The War

The Time Lords

Are known to - and, post-War, remembered by - the Family, who are seeking the Doctor because they specifically need a Time Lord. [It is unclear if they know he is the last one.]

The Analysis

Where does this come from?

No prizes for guessing the New Adventure Human Nature, but that's not all.

Things that Don’t Make Sense

The Doctor’s plan is to wait until the Family die - but the whole problem is that they have a time machine! Even if he does accurately work out how long they have left (even though they never meet face-to-face!), how can he possibly know how much time passes for them while he waits on Earth disguised as a human for three months? They find him after only two, and it’s not at all clear how long they’ve been looking for him. [One possible interpretation is that he has worked out that if they haven’t found him after he’s been disguised for three months then they’re never going to, but there’s no information given in the episode to explain why he might think that.]

Critique

See The Prosecution and The Defence

The Facts

Written by Paul Cornell. Directed by Charles Palmer. X million viewers.

Supporting cast:

Working Titles:

The Teaser: Martha and the Doctor run into the TARDIS, beams of green light firing after them. The Doctor quickly realises that the unseen enemy can follow them wherever they go in time and space, but since they haven't seen his or Martha's faces, he can potentially hide. He tells Martha to trust him, and holds up a watch and begins to tell her why it's important- -as John Smith wakes in his bed. His maid Martha enters with his breakfast, and he tells her about his dream, but she assures him that it is not the future and that he is completely human.

The Lore

  • This episode contains many references to the program's past, the most notable being Smith's descriptions of the Doctor's life, which sound like many of the notes written during the initial development of the programme, and Smith's parents Sydney and Verity, named after Sydney Newman and Verity Lambert.


Doctor Who Series Three Episodes

The Runaway Bride · Smith and Jones · The Shakespeare Code · Gridlock · Daleks in Manhattan / Evolution of the Daleks
The Lazarus Experiment · 42 · Human Nature / The Family of Blood · Blink · Utopia / The Sound of Drums / Last of the Time Lords / Time Crash