Daleks in Manhattan
| X3.4 - “Daleks in Manhattan” (1) | ||||
| Doctor Who Series 3, Episode 4, April 21st, 2007 | ||||
| Featuring the Tenth Doctor with Martha Jones | ||||
| Written by Helen Raynor, directed by James Strong, produced by Phil Collinson. | ||||
| “Gridlock” | << | “Daleks in Manhattan” | >> | “Evolution of the Daleks” |
Which One is This?
Er...the one that could justifiably be titled "Sec's in the City"? And their plan is...well, rather less reasonable than the superficially similar one that led to their demise in Evil of the Daleks.
Firsts and Lasts
It's the first time the new series has done location filming, though this largely serves just to make the New York skyline inaccurate for the stated year.
Things to Notice About Daleks in Manhattan
- This episode has some of the best Dalek dialogue ever - the members of the Cult of Skaro argue with each other, make sacrifices, and consider themselves to be in dire straits. Unfortunately, their arguing falls short of an actual critical analysis of Dalek Sec's plan.
The Continuity
The Doctor
He resents the Daleks for continuing to survive while causing him to lose so much. [He presumably blames them for Rose's exile to the parallel universe, as well as for the loss of Gallifrey and the Time Lords.] Using only basic equipment, plus the sonic screwdriver, he's able to "read" the DNA of a creature and thereby deduce its planet of origin [though considering how important it must be to him, it takes him a long time to remember that this genetic code matches Skaro].
Inventory
The sonic screwdriver gets lashed up with some 1930s wireless components to analyze the mutant blob. He also has a stethoscope.
Ethics
Is first up the ladder when escaping the pig-slaves, though this may be a case of practicality as he has to unseal the man-hole with screw driver. [Perhaps if Rose were still with him he'd have sent her up first, and instructed her how to open the manhole.]
Background
Martha
The TARDIS
Planet Notes
History
The War
The Time Lords
The Analysis
Where does this come from?
See article.
Things that Don’t Make Sense
There are many historical inaccuracies, including several anachronistic buildings, advanced progress on the Empire State itself [probably a result of Dalek interference], the modern-day upgrades to the Statue of Liberty and the existence of Hooverville a year too early...but we'll forgive those.
Why are the Daleks making "pig-slaves"? There's no evidence to suggest they're physically superior to normal humans, and they're certainly not as smart. They seem loyal enough once their minds are altered (Laszlo mentions he escaped before they got to his mind), but with crime no doubt rampant in 1930s New York and money so hard to come by, surely a mob of brutish criminals would do just as well - and not draw the kind of attention the pig-slaves do? Anyway, since Dalek Sec is telepathic, surely he can condition stupid humans to obey the Daleks - he hasn't had much trouble with Mr Diagoras.
The "evolution" here is clearly inspired more by Dr. Moreau than by Darwin, but even if we accept the blending of species as an improvement, the biggest thing that doesn't make sense is the Final Experiment. Okay: humans survive throughout history, as the Daleks know, so perhaps they do have some advantage that Daleks do not. (See Evil of the Daleks for more on the supposed "Human Factor".) But what makes the Daleks think that it's biological? And how can Dalek Sec's human-dalek hybrid form possible have an advantage that surpasses the unstoppable travel machines that the modern Daleks inhabit?
Critique
See The Prosecution and The Defence
The Facts
Written by Helen Raynor.
Supporting cast:
Working Titles:
The Teaser: Laszlo meets Tallulah in her dressing room before she goes on stage, then wanders outside when he hears a noise, only to be snatched by something horrible in the darkness: a half-man, half-pig.
The Lore