Time Crash: Difference between revisions

From About Time Again
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
Line 80: Line 80:
{{WhoNavThree}}
{{WhoNavThree}}


[[Category: Doctor Who]] [[Category: Doctor Who Series Three]] [[Category: Tenth Doctor]] [[Category: Fifth Doctor]] [[Category: Multi-Doctor]]
[[Category: Doctor Who]] [[Category: Doctor Who Series Three]] [[Category: Tenth Doctor]] [[Category: Fifth Doctor]] [[Category: Multi-Doctor]] [[Category: Timey-Wimey]]

Latest revision as of 13:44, 29 December 2010

X3.13a - “Time Crash”
Doctor Who Series 3, Episode 13a, November 16th, 2007
Featuring the Tenth Doctor with the Fifth Doctor
Written by Steven Moffat, directed by Graeme Harper, produced by Phil Collinson.
“Last of the Time Lords” << “Time Crash” >> “Voyage of the Damned”

Which One is This?

David Tennant gets to share the screen with the Doctor who made him want the role in the first place, in a love letter to Peter Davison written by Steven Moffat. Fanwank? Maybe. But it's beautiful.

Firsts and Lasts

The obvious one is it's the first mix of old and new Doctors, and the new series' first multi-Doctor adventure. Less obviously it's the new series first companionless story, and the first broadcast adventure explicitly set during another story.

Things to Notice About Time Crash

The Continuity

The Doctor(s)

Five doesn't recognise his future self [an after-effect of the Time War?], or even notice that he's ended up in a future version of his TARDIS, happily twiddling away with the controls and commenting on the change of decor as an afterthought. [Perhaps from his perspective Ten has appeared in his TARDIS; until he comments on the change of decor, he may even still perceive the console room as his own.] He only accepts Ten as a future incarnation through argument, rather than a moment of recognition. He seems to think it more likely that Ten is a fan. He knows about LINDA (see X2.10, Love and Monsters).

The Tenth Doctor is ecstatic to encounter his past self, especially this incarnation, whom he describes as "his Doctor". He "loved being" Five, and his current personality is in some ways based on the fifth one; he specifically mentions his trainers, the way his voice goes up in pitch when shouting, and wearing glasses he doesn't need to make himself look smart. He casually mentions adventures from his past, enquiring about the timeframe from which the fifth Doctor has come. He sees no problem with describing future events to his past self, mentioning his recent encounter with the Master.

Inventory

Five is carrying his half-moon spectacles, which Ten refers to as his "brainy specs". Notably he turns down the offer of Ten's sonic screwdriver. [Meaning he's probably pre-19.4, The Visitation - given his sadness over the original model's loss, he'd surely react more to the new one otherwise. This in turn means he almost certainly learns about his short-term future, most significantly that he will soon encounter the Cybermen. Note that Ten's comment about kettles and string isn't out of place, since even before its loss, Five used the screwdriver considerably less than his previous incarnation.]

Ethics

Background

The TARDIS

The TARDIS here collides with an earlier version of itself.

History

We've no idea where or when the TARDIS is when the collision occurs (it's depicted as still being in the vortex), but presumably it's close to the time and place of Voyage of the Damned.

The Analysis

Where does this come from?

It comes straight from the fannish heart of Steven Moffat and David Tennant. Really, it's as simple as that - both are tremendous fans of Davison, the man playing the part when each of them was seriously enjoying Doctor Who, and this is a fannish dream come true. After all, what could possibly top playing the new Doctor or writing for him, except doing it opposite your favourite Doctor from your youth?

Things that Don’t Make Sense

It's a comedy, so let's not take it too seriously, but it is considered "canon" so it would be remiss of us not to point out that the whole thing hinges on an ontological paradox: the Doctor doesn't come up with a method for averting the disaster, he just remembers his future self doing it, so the idea comes from nowhere. Given this, it makes even less sense than usual that the Doctor doesn't expect this meeting, though to be fair the fifth Doctor has no context for when it'll happen; his memory wouldn't include what happened before or after the encounter.

The whole "black hole cancelled out by a supernova" is nonsense, too, but who cares?

Critique

The Facts

Written by Steven Moffat. Directed by Graeme Harper.

Supporting cast: None.

Working Titles:

The Teaser: Martha leaves the Doctor in a recap from the end of Last of the Time Lords, and the Doctor takes off. A strange shudder rocks the TARDIS, and the Doctor is thrown to the floor; he recovers and circles the console, checking controls. He passes someone else doing the same thing, each excusing himself, and then they turn in shock. The fifth and tenth Doctors take turns saying "What?"

Cliffhanger: None.

The Lore

  • Davies had been set against the idea of a multi-Doctor story, but Moffat (and presumably Tennant), a tremendous Davison fan, persuaded him to do it for the Children in Need special. Davies was supposedly so happy with the result that he is considering a "proper" multi-Doctor story as part of the series. Depending on whether you count "The Next Doctor", he did/didn't go on to make this a reality.


Doctor Who Series Three Episodes

The Runaway Bride · Smith and Jones · The Shakespeare Code · Gridlock · Daleks in Manhattan / Evolution of the Daleks
The Lazarus Experiment · 42 · Human Nature / The Family of Blood · Blink · Utopia / The Sound of Drums / Last of the Time Lords / Time Crash