A Christmas Carol

From About Time Again
Jump to navigation Jump to search
X6.X - “A Christmas Carol”
Doctor Who Series 6, Episode X, December 25, 2010
Featuring the Eleventh Doctor with Amy Pond and Rory Williams
Written by Steven Moffat, directed by Toby Haynes, produced by Sanne Wohlenberg.
“The Big Bang” << “A Christmas Carol” >> “The Impossible Astronaut”

Which One is This?

The best and most Christmassy of Christmas specials. With a flying shark in.

Firsts and Lasts

Three Things to Notice About A Christmas Carol

  1. Amy isn't in it much, and even less so Rory, who only gets a handful of lines. This is particularly noticeable since Arthur Darvill finally gets his name in the credits.
  2. The whole episode is about rewriting someone's past to change their personality...which seems ethically dubious at best, and at worst impossible, even under the laissez-faire rules of the post-Time War Whoniverse. But what the hell, it's Christmas.
  3. The ways in which Moffat reinvents the three ghosts using time travel are inventive and delightful; the final ghost, of Christmas Future, is particularly clever.

The Continuity

The Doctor

Inventory

His new sonic screwdriver is again destroyed here, chewed up by a flying shark, with bits of it left inside its gullet. Its attempts to repair itself are useful to the plot several times, as it signals it's missing parts. He leaves the broken screwdriver in Karzan's possession for many years, and later uses it to amplify Abigail's singing. The psychic paper fails to work on the young Karzan as intended, since his claim to be qualified as a babysitter and safe with children is apparently "a lie too big"; the paper "shorts out", though it remains to be seen if this is a permanent state of affairs.

Ethics

He doesn't see anything wrong with rewriting someone's personal history to save a few thousand people, despite that person being one of the most important on his planet [surely there should be myriad unforseen side effects? Or, because this isn't a fixed point in time, does the rest of history not particularly care about Kazran Sardick?]

Background

He's never been to this planet before, or seen flying fish of this kind, and expresses his love of new planets as a result. He goes on several undocumented trips with Kazran and Abigail at Christmas Eve over the years, including trips to Sydney, Paris and Hollywood, though we see some of the latter trip, on which he accidentally gets engaged and then married to Marilyn Monroe. He later claims it wasn't a real chapel.

The Supporting Cast

Amy Pond - is wearing her police officer kiss-o-gram outfit, apparently as a bit of honeymoon fun. She has a walkie-talky like contraption clearly constructed by the Doctor, which allows her to communicate with him, and to send a distress signal.

Rory Williams - is wearing a Roman soldier costume. He and Amy's costumes match the ones they were wearing in a photo from a party which River found in Amy's house in X5.13, The Pandorica Opens. [So they're probably recreating a particularly memorable night from their past, rather than this being a very specific, long-term fetish.] Rory seems at least a little familiar with future technology, as he's operating control panels during Amy's holographic conference with Kazran.

The TARDIS

The Non-Humans

Fish - various species of fish which resemble the normal aquatic varieties are able to fly in the atmosphere of the planet, somehow manipulating electrical fields to do so. As well as species resembling small bony fish, there is a large predatory species which looks like the Great White Shark of Earth's seas.

Planet Notes

The unnamed planet has an unusual atmosphere in which tiny crystalline particles are suspended; these conduct electrical fields, allowing the fish to fly through it, and causing a danger to spacecraft attempting to land. The crystals resonate with harmonic sound, for example music.

History

  • Dating: no date is given, but from the state of the technology it may well be in the "default space-age future" period of the 51st century.

The Analysis

Where does this come from?

Things that Don’t Make Sense

Anything about the flying fish. But hey; it's Christmas.

Critique

The Facts

Written by Steven Moffat. Directed by Adam Smith. 8.13 million viewers, 8.6 million including HD.

Supporting cast: Katherine Jenkins (Abigail Pettigrew), Michael Gambon (Kazran/Elliot Sardick), Micah Balfour (Co-pilot), Pooky Quesnel (Captain), Leo Bill (Pilot), Laurence Belcher (Young Kazran), Bailey Pepper (Boy and Benjamin), Steve North (Old Benjamin), Laura Rogers (Isabella), Meg Wynn-Owen (Old Isabella), Danny Horn (Teenage Kazran), Nick Malinowski (Eric), Tim Plester (Servant)

Oh, Isn't That...?

  • Katherine Jenkins is an opera singer who has had several crossover hits with gospel and popular music, as well as leading roles in musical theatre. She's been in various reality television programmes (as a guest rather than a contestant), and has also popped up in Emmerdale.
  • Michael Gambon is most famous these days as the second actor to play Hogwarts headmaster Albus Dumbledore in the Harry Potter films, but television wise he was Philip Marlowe in the original The Singing Detective. His list of credits is as long as your arm, but recent significant ones include Fantastic Mr. Fox and The King's Speech.
  • Micah Balfour was a long-running cast member in The Bill from 2006 to its end in 2010. He played PC Benjamin Gayle.
  • Pooky Quesnel has a brilliant name, and you might have noticed it in the credits of Cardiac Arrest, Thief Takers, Cold Feet or EastEnders. She's also a screenwriter, having penned episodes of Doctors and Family Affairs.
  • Leo Bill might be familiar from the 2006 British film The Living and the Dead, in which he played the schizophrenic son of an aristocrat, played by Roger Lloyd Pack of Rise of the Cybermen/The Age of Steel.

Working Titles:

The Teaser: The bridge crew of the starliner scramble for control as the ship plummets through the atmosphere of an unnamed planet. A distress signal is issued, but not from the crew - it's come from the honeymoon suite, and Amy appears on the bridge, dressed in her kiss-o-gram uniform (from The Eleventh Hour), to find out if the Doctor has received it. Rory appears too, dressed as a Roman soldier (as was his Auton duplicate in The Pandorica Opens/The Big Bang), just in time to see the Doctor's message, "Come along Pond", scroll across the screen as the TARDIS arrives.

The Lore

  • Though clearly drawing inspiration from Dicken's tale of the same name, this episode has a loosely similar plot to one of Steven Moffat's earliest Doctor Who works, the short story "Decalog 3" from Virgin Publishing's collection Short Trips. In it, the Seventh Doctor needs a library book, and repeatedly changes the personal history of the librarian who refuses to give it to him.



Doctor Who Series Six/Two Episodes

A Christmas Carol · Space/Time · The Impossible Astronaut / Day of the Moon · The Curse of the Black Spot · The Doctor's Wife · The Rebel Flesh / The Almost People · A Good Man Goes to War
Let's Kill Hitler · Night Terrors · The Girl Who Waited · The God Complex · Closing Time · The Wedding of River Song