The Rebel Flesh
| X6.5 - “The Rebel Flesh” (1) | ||||
| Doctor Who Series 6, Episode 5, May 21, 2011 | ||||
| Featuring the Eleventh Doctor with Amy Pond and Rory Williams | ||||
| Written by Matthew Graham, directed by Julian Simpson, produced by Marcus Wilson. | ||||
| “The Doctor's Wife” | << | “The Rebel Flesh” | >> | “The Almost People” |
Which One is This?
The one with the melty people in jumpsuits.
Firsts and Lasts
Three Things to Notice About The Rebel Flesh
- .
- .
- .
The Continuity
The Doctor
Inventory
The Doctor loses his boots [presumably the same ones he acquired in X5.1, The Eleventh Hour] when they're melted by acid.
Ethics
Background
The Doctor has had previous occasion to say "I have to make it to the cockerel before all hell breaks loose."
The Supporting Cast
Amy Pond -
Rory Williams -
The TARDIS
The Non-Humans
The Flesh -
History
- Dating:
The Analysis
Where does this come from?
Things that Don’t Make Sense
Why have "programmable matter" that can emulate anything - and use it to make vulnerable human bodies that can still be melted by the acid? Why not create armoured exoskeletons or robots made from the same kind of acid-resistant ceramic as the pipes and the acid suits, eliminating the danger almost entirely? [The flesh may only be able to create organic molecules, which would allow for the jumpsuits if they're made from natural fibres (and have only plastic buttons and zippers), but not the protective suits. This is never mentioned, but is backed up by Jimmy's ganger not having his wedding ring round his neck.] And why programmable matter? You could just build a robot out of the same stuff, or automate the systems. But then, why have an acid farm in the first place? [The line about the Flesh being "the government's worst-kept secret" implies that it's somehow illegal or at least that it's use is heavily restricted; the acid farmers use it because the acid is so dangerous, but we never find out what's so important about acid to justify all this danger and expense.]
The Flesh is established as some kind of living organism, but no more so than "moss". It exists in a vat and is pumped into a sarcophagus-like receptacle when a new ganger is created. So how exactly is it programmed? The harnesses must transmit signals to it, but it's not connected to any similar technology, so it must somehow be able to pick up the signals directly. [It's starting to sound more like Nestene-infused plastic at this stage.] So how exactly does a power surge - a Frankenstein-like bolt of (solar) lightning, no less! - transmit a copy of the operators' personalities into the Flesh? It has failsafes built-in, but they don't work. And come to that, where do the new personalities of the gangers come from? If they're exact copies of the original crew, why - when they revert to their unstable half-forms - do they suddenly have their own, monstrous identities? [This might make sense if the Flesh already has its own consciousness and thus personality, as suggested - clumsily - by the Doctor's interactions with it, but then they should all be independent copies of that personality mixed with the crew, since it's pretty clear they're individuals, no some kind of hive mind or puppets controlled by the bulk of the Flesh.]
Critique
The Facts
Written by Matthew Graham. Directed by Julian Simpson. x million viewers, x million including HD.
Supporting cast: Mark Bonnar (Jimmy), Marshall Lancaster (Buzzer), Sarah Smart (Jennifer), Raquel Cassidy (Cleaves), Leon Vickers (Dicken), Frances Barber (Eye Patch Lady)
Oh, Isn't That...?
- Mark Bonnar - though best known to mainstream audiences as Bruno in Casualty, he's best known to so-desperate-they'lll-watch-anything genre television fans for starring in Paradox as DS Ben Holt.
- Marshall Lancaster - it's on the tip of your tongue, isn't it? I'll tell you: he's the one who wasn't from the future, wasn't Gene Hunt, and didn't have a moustache on Life on Mars and Ashes to Ashes. And he was great in those.
- Sarah Smart - probably most recognisable to Who fans as Virginia Braithwaite, the eldest daughter in At Home with the Braithwaites, which starred Amanda Redman as her mother Alison and a certain Peter Davison as her father, David.
- Raquel Cassidy - played Susan in the first two series of Teachers, and previously worked with Matt Smith in Party Animals as Home Office Junior Minister Jo Porter.
Working Titles:
The Teaser: Jennifer, Jimmy and Buzzer are checking one of the acid vats when Buzzer falls in. He continues to banter with his workmates as though nothing is wrong, even as his suit slowly fails and he melts away to nothing. Jennifer and Jimmy leave the room and in the corridor encounter Buzzer, unharmed.
The Lore
- .