Dalek
| X1.6 - “Dalek” | ||||
| Doctor Who Series 1, Episode 6, 30 April, 2005 | ||||
| Featuring the Ninth Doctor with Rose Tyler | ||||
| Written by Rob Shearman, directed by Joe Ahearne, produced by Phil Collinson. | ||||
| “World War Three” | << | “Dalek” | >> | “The Long Game” |
Which One is This?
The last Dalek in the universe shows up in the collection of a billionaire American, and it's not happy.
Firsts and Lasts
Things to Notice About Dalek
The Continuity
The Doctor
Inventory
Ethics
Background
Rose
The TARDIS
History
The War
The Time Lords
The Arc Word
Bad Wolf: The call sign for Van Statten's personal helicopter is "Bad Wolf One", though it doesn't seem that the Doctor and Rose could possibly hear this. [See, naturally enough, "Who's Afraid of the Bad Wolf?"]
The Analysis
Where does this come from?
Jubilee.
Oh, you want more?
Alright then…
This might sound like cheating again, but this is another story that springs chiefly from Doctor Who, particularly the bits involving the Daleks. However, just as in Rose, this is a story that examines the difference between notional Doctor Who and the reality that was actually broadcast.
As their place in the cultural firmament has fossilised over four decades, the Daleks are the perfect example of how these differences have developed. When we think about what they're like (let alone what the general public thinks), we have a fairly two-dimensional Dalek in mind. Indeed it's telling that Dalek's chief fault is often identified as being the 'humanisation' of Terry Nation's cash cow. Nation himself, of course, has done much to foster the impression that such a portrayal is 'wrong', and it's interesting to speculate, given Nation's dislike of David Whitaker's Dalek episodes, whether he would have allowed Rob Shearman's script to be produced. My guess is that he probably wouldn't, and Nation's own blinkered view of Correct Dalek Behaviour is ironically part of the fuel that Shearman uses to drive his take on the creatures. .
Of course many commentators have noted the links between Jubilee and Dalek, but aside from some conceptual similarities, it is the themes of Jubilee rather than its plot specifics that really informs its successor. Both are particularly concerned with how we perceive certain cultural icons, and both address the ways in which the Daleks have been debased through familiarity and marketing. Both stories also draw a wider conclusion: just as the Nazis have become a handy term of internet abuse or comedy villains in 'Allo, 'Allo, Daleks have become the villains of Spike Milligan skits, Timelord music videos, and ads for Kit Kat.
Most damningly, Doctor Who was often just as guilty of dumbing down the Daleks, and, as noted above, the writer most responsible for turning them into cartoon exterminators was Nation himself. The Chase was the first story that took the Daleks less than seriously; there's strong evidence to suggest that he wrote very little of The Dalek's Masterplan; his Pertwee stories portray the Daleks as generic monsters; Genesis succeeds but at the cost of pushing them offstage and Destiny confirms a thousand viewers' misconceptions by recasting them as robots. The result is that, like the Nazis, the Daleks have become symbols at best and jokes at worst. Robbed of their contemporary context, they have become two-dimensional creatures, without resonance or meaningful characterisation. Quirks like the need for static electricity, the Human Factor Daleks of Evil or the masquerading 'servants' of Power are ironed out, and just as the Doctor tends to be thought of as an amalgam of Tom Baker and Jon Pertwee, so the Daleks have come to be identified as the bland ranters of the same period. (The post-notional (post-National?) era saw Eric Saward and Ben Aaronovitch deliver solid Dalek stories, but a combination of storytelling decisions and falling ratings meant that they had little effect on the Daleks' public reputation (as evidenced by Dalek's decision to recycle the 'fuck off they can climb stairs' gag)).
Thus, by the time it fell to Shearman to reintroduce them, it was clear that the Daleks could not be handled casually. Far from the vaguely naff monsters of yore, this story goes out of its way to present a lone Dalek as a genuinely terrifying creature. Part of this strategy is to make use of the horror tropes that have developed since the Daleks left our screens. Consequently, the first twenty minutes is strongly informed by The Silence of the Lambs, and in its depiction of characters trapped in an industrial installation and harried by an implacable foe, the episode is also heavily indebted (as with so much science fiction since the mid 1980s) to Aliens.
However, the trickier part of the reintroduction is to debunk the notional Dalek myths. The result is that this Dalek mows its way through a high tech private army, cutting down various Dalek clichés along the way--climbing stairs , proving the effectiveness of its sucker arm, and demonstrating strategic aptitude. At a stroke the Daleks' reputation is reclaimed, and all this without having to completely redesign the creatures' appearance.
Of course this Dalek-on-steroids behaviour isn't a terribly new development--the Daleks were a force to be reckoned with as soon as TV Century 21 Comics gave them adventures without a television-sized budget. But to the general public, with their dim memories of watching Daleks being beaten up by spear-waving savages, it reasserts the Daleks as a potent symbol. Like David Cronenberg's reformatting of the silly premise of the original The Fly, one of the chief tasks faced by modern imagineers is to make it easier for a new audience to suspend their disbelief. Thus the approach taken to the Daleks' revival (and indeed the Doctor's as well) can be understood in the light of the constant stream of "juice up an old brand name in order to market it to a new generation" remakes.
However, although updating the silhouette can be achieved simply by throwing cash at the problem, the trickier task is to return the Daleks' characterisation to their more sophisticated origins. Again this is often an inevitable part of the juiced-up-remake process. Think of all the times you've heard the producers of such revivals wanting to make something "relevant to today" or "returning the concept to its roots". The example that really kickstarted it all saw Tim Burton reclaiming Batman from his campy position in the public consciousness, and this is usually credited to his desire to pay homage to Batman's 'darker' 1930s template while also investing him with the cynical psychology de rigeur for 1980s superheroes.
This creative trend towards revisionism has more than one father, but the most significant is the postmodernist movement and its fascination with deconstructing old ideas. Just as historians can no longer peddle notions like Red Indians attacking white settlers unprovoked, the idea that Dalek behaviour and personality can be more than a matter of villainy arrives on the agenda. The old certainties are cast into doubt, and the goodies and baddies don't seem to be wearing the right coloured hats anymore.
Naturally, genre media has been doing this for quite a while. As the people who grew up watching the usual classics found jobs in the media, the reappraisal of sacred cows was inevitable. Politics that would have been unthinkable in the 50s and 60s are now far closer to the mainstream, and artistic movements that were taking hold in their youth are now the fodder of prime time TV. The modern Star Trek has become the poster child of this impulse to reconsider an accepted point of view, and as the Klingons, Romulans and Borg were humanised, new kinds of stories began to suggest themselves.
Although some might deride this for its 'political correctness' (and to be fair the trend does seem to parallel the rise of that phrase into the public consciousness), it is also one of the clearest indications that modern SF is made by people that don't consider the genre inherently childish. The result is a Dalek with the most delineated characterisation in Doctor Who's long history, and it's hard to see that as a bad thing. Far from the usual clear line between Them and Us, this is a situation where the usual positions are reversed: it is the Dalek that is chained to a wall and tormented by everyone, up to and including the Doctor himself. It is also no accident that in the wake of postmodernist deconstruction that this Dalek should be imprisoned and tortured by Americans. This is Doctor Who's ultimate Enemy, but a modern viewer would be hard pressed to watch it without also thinking of the abuse of prisoners in Abu Ghraib; the implacable enemy humanised and made pathetic by people who are normally coded as 'good'. Like the Nazis, who are always at their most dangerous when they are simply labelled evil and freakish, Dalek feels most unsettling when the barriers between our enemy and our friends get uncomfortably blurry. It might upset some people (usually those with an unhealthy attachment to golliwogs), but they've been grumpy since The Silurians anyway, so they don't really count.
Things that Don’t Make Sense
Critique
The Prosecution
Just as Rose is to An Unearthly Child, Dalek is to The Daleks: they're the point in the show's history where the sound check is out of the way and the rock n' roll can really begin. The preceding five episodes of Eccleston-era Doctor Who have their charms, but there was a nagging feeling that not everything was in synch. In contrast, while Dalek has its deficiencies, it's the first time that the new incarnation of the show really clicked into place. Jettisoning the tonal uncertainty that had blighted its predecessors, Dalek is lean and self-assured--the first episode that really knows what kind of show it wants to be.
The fact that it achieves all this is striking if one bears in mind just how easily Dalek could have been laughable. It seems blasphemous to think of it in these terms, but the Daleks are essentially a one-hit wonder creation, and as the historical background that birthed them receded into the distance they seemed increasingly irrelevant. By the early 1970s they were already leached of resonance and innovation, and although Davros gives them a shot in the arm, the character is an explicit recognition that the creatures are no longer workable in their own right. Thus the Daleks appeared less and less in the stories that bore their name, and only rarely did they seem really necessary. Barring the occasional moment in Remembrance, Evil of the Daleks was the last time there was a genuine attempt to treat them as characters rather than monsters, and the result is that varying the Dalek palette often seems misguided or out of character.
Consequently, Rob Shearman's episode was the new series biggest gamble precisely because the conflicted Dalek could have been ludicrous. Daleks aren't great characters, so runs the received wisdom. They're boring to look at when they're talking, and their voices are monotonous when delivering more than just the basic catchphrases. Couple this with a Dalek behaving so "out of character" and Shearman's episode could have been pure comedy.
However as is usually the case with received wisdom, it's a pile of wank. While it's true that the risks were high, so were the potential rewards. The real danger was that Davies and Shearman would play safe. Christopher Eccleston was much criticised for his hope that the new Doctor Who would play outside its usual parameters, but Dalek is the first sign of just how effective that strategy could be. The interesting thing is, despite all the complaints about Seven-of-Nine-ing the Dalek, just how far a little innovation can go. Removing the Dalek from its usual story context of being the heavy (to begin with in any case) is hardly the most revolutionary thing Shearman could have done, but it instantly casts new light through old windows. Rather than simply mobilising the image to appeal to nostalgia, this gambit bounces off our traditional expectations in unexpected ways. Something powerful is made weak and we're forced to examine just how we feel about this reversal. It's an old idea, and like most attempts at 'making strange' it can be silly (most horror films are walking the same line--it's one of the main reasons why they tend to date so badly), but when it works, as it does here, it justifies resurrecting a monster that stopped being relevant in 1965.
The new series' strong sense of imagery is also at its most potent here. Previous episodes felt either too derivative (Gatiss' zombies and Davies' Autons) or gimcrack (most of the delegates on Platform One and the Slitheen). While it would be unfair to say that there was nothing memorable before Shearman fired up his word processor, a combination of trite imagery, poor direction, silly designs and lumpy set pieces meant that Doctor Who seemed a show of percentages rather than successes. Dalek blows that apart, delivering scenes that instantly impress with their feel for the iconic. The reveal of the Dalek as its lights pulse out it's first word, the nature of its imprisonment, the Doctor's unalloyed glee as tortures the creature… this is the stuff that makes the hairs on the back of the neck stand up. Of course Shearman has an advantage in that he is mobilising images that are already freighted with iconic potential, but it's the way he uses them that counts. Davies' Autons are also striving to evoke that kind of childhood fear that everyone associates with Doctor Who, but a combination of sketchy writing and a lack of directorial conviction scupper his efforts. At bottom, he's not doing anything new with the Autons, and that's part of why "Dalek" seems so much more satisfying.
There are quibbles to be sure, but they’re hardly worth mentioning. Van Statten is an intensely annoying character, and he is played with a lack of subtlety that has undermined so much of the new series. There is also some overly cute dialogue that feels like a writer tap-dancing faster than he needs to, but the performance of Eccleston (finally kicking out the jams), Piper, and yes, Nick Briggs more than compensate. In sum, this is a marvellous advertisement for the talents of director Joe Ahearne, as his arrival marks an upswing in the series as a whole. He might not be as flamboyant as James Hawes or as steady as Euros Lyn, but there's a sense here that a new benchmark is being set. From this point, everyone working on the show will have to try that little bit harder, to find that conviction that is the true magic ingredient that makes Doctor Who work.
The Defence
The Facts
Written by Rob Shearman. Directed by Joe Ahearne. Peak of 8.6 million viewers, y% audience share.
Supporting cast:
Working Titles:
The Teaser: The Doctor and Rose emerge from the TARDIS to find themselves in a near future museum filled with alien curios - including a Slitheen's arm, and the head of a Cyberman. The Doctor, full of nostalgia, touches a case and sets off an alarm - and they are immediately surrounded by a squad of heavily armed guards.
Cliffhangers: None.
The Lore