Rose
| X1.1 - “Rose” | ||||
| Doctor Who Series 1, Episode 1, 26th March 2005 | ||||
| Featuring the Ninth Doctor with Rose Tyler | ||||
| Written by Russell T Davies, directed by Keith Boak, produced by Phil Collinson. | ||||
| “Doctor Who (1996)” | << | “Rose” | >> | “The End of the World” |
Which One is This?
Rose and the rest of us meet the new Doctor, who of course is mysterious and eccentric. Oh, and there’s something about an invasion of shop dummies...
Firsts and Lasts
It’s the first episode of the first new Who in nine years, so (deep breath): The title sequence is new, with new graphics, music and logo. For the first time, the lead actors’ names are shown before the title of the programme. "Flavia's theme" is heard for the first time (as the Doctor holds Rose's hand and describes the Earth moving under his feet). We meet both the Ninth Doctor and Rose Tyler here, as well as Rose’s Mum Jackie, and her boyfriend Mickey. The new TARDIS exterior and interior make their debut. The Doctor’s new look sonic screwdriver is seen for the first time. Clive is the first contemporary human character in the series to research the Doctor. The Internet is used on screen for the first time. Rose is the first companion given a clear choice between her normal life and travelling with the Doctor, and also the first to be given a second chance when she initially says no.
In terms of the new series, it's the first episode not to have a pre-title teaser, and the last until Smith and Jones two years later. It's the first time we see the zoom-in from space to London shot (and we will be seeing it again: in X2.X The Christmas Invasion, X2.12 “Army of Ghosts”, X3.X The Runaway Bride and X3.1 “Smith and Jones”). It's the first time anyone mentions The Time War (see below).
It's the last time we see Earth of the year in which the series airs. [See Dating below, and also the essay What Time Is Now?]
Two Things to Notice About Rose
- Despite having Clive introduce the idea of the Doctor as intensely dangerous, his only truly serious moment is before confronting the Consciousness in the finale, when he tells Rose to forget him and strides towards the TARDIS. There’s little seriousness from him for the rest of the episode.
- Right from the beginning Rose is painted as a potential winner in "Who Wants to Be a Doctor Who Companion?" She's the first one to find out something about him before boarding the TARDIS, but what really takes the cake is that poor Mickey is given a realistic reaction to all the alien weirdness and horror, after which Rose ups and leaves him, and her Mum, with barely a second's second thought. Perhaps there is something to be said about the companion deliberately choosing to get on board, but does send mixed messages.
The Continuity
The Doctor
The Doctor knows about current Earth celebrities (one of whom is an alien), can read a book in the time it takes to flick through the pages, and isn’t good at card tricks. He may have regenerated only recently as he inspects his reflection as though for the first time, generally happy but critical of his ears. He has trouble empathising with humans, describing them as “dumb apes blundering about” and “stupid little people”, but clearly still has great affection for them and sees in them great potential.
Inventory
A new sonic screwdriver, which produces bright blue light as well as sonic vibrations, and is capable of interrupting the thought control signal animating an Auton, welding shut a metal door, and shorting out basic electronics. He also has an explosive device with an electronic timer, and a large test tube filled with dark blue “anti-plastic”.
Ethics
He’s not averse to getting physical with the Autons to stop them destroying all of humanity, but seems quite detached about the deaths of individuals, considering them of little importance; he fails to consider that Mickey is dead, or that Rose might be upset about it. While he’s prepared to kill the Consciousness to save the human race, he will only do so as a last resort, preferring negotiation if possible.
Background
Clive’s evidence shows that the Ninth Doctor was present during JFK’s final parade in Dallas in 1963; visited Southampton in 1912, where he advised a family not to travel on the Titanic; and was sketched by an unknown party standing in front of the eruption of Krakatoa on August 26th, 1888 (Clive claims the picture washed up on the coast of Sumatra the same night). The armies of Ghengis Khan once tried to board the TARDIS, but couldn’t get through the doors. See also The War.
Supporting Cast
Rose - Rose left school before completing her A-levels because of Jimmy Stones [a previous boyfriend?], and that ended badly. She lives in a flat with her Mum Jackie (who appears to be unemployed) and worked in the clothing department of Henrik’s, until the store was blown up by the Doctor. She has a friend named Suki. She competed in gymnastics at Jericho Street Junior School and showed some talent, winning bronze in the under-sevens competition. Given the chance, she wilfully leaves behind her Mum and her boyfriend to travel in the TARDIS.
Jackie - Rose's Mum. Jackie Tyler is ostensibly a hairdresser, though we never see or hear of her working, except around the Powell Estate. She is an outrageous flirt, and fancies the Doctor when she first spot him. (She's less keen on him later on.)
Mickey - Mickey Smith is Rose's boyfriend, and here is a stereotypical lazy lad: loves football, cares about but neglects his girlfriend, and talks tough but is a coward when it comes down to it. [We won't see him quite like this again, but then, that's hardly surprising given what happens... See X1.4, Aliens of London.]
The TARDIS
The TARDIS external doors are now also the internal doors, and the interior can be seen from the outside (and vice versa). The console room has changed radically, though the new console itself has a column similar to that seen in the previous version. The Doctor is able to pilot the TARDIS very accurately; he is also able to follow the psychic signal controlling an Auton back to its source by attaching a complex enough part of it to the console. When asked by Rose if the TARDIS flies, the Doctor explains “It disappears there and reappears here, you wouldn’t understand.” [Given Rose’s rememberance of Newsround documentaries in the next episode, he’s being rather ungenerous; she could certainly at least imagine such a thing.]
Planet Notes
The Nestene Consciousness is a single entity composed of living plastic [contradicting both Spearhead From Space and Terror of the Autons] whose food stocks (”protein planets”) were all destroyed in “the war”. The Doctor mentions he couldn’t save the Consciousness’s world, which may mean it’s home planet was also destroyed. It wants to colonise the Earth in order to consume it, and it’s ideal because of the toxins, oil, smoke and dioxins. It seems to have come physically to Earth and manifests as a bubbling pool of molten plastic, though it is not clear if this is a natural form or whether the consciousness has projected itself into plastic found on Earth. It allows the Doctor audience when he invokes “section 15 of the Shadow Proclamation”, and protests to him of “constitutional rights”. It recognises the Doctor as a Time Lord, and the TARDIS as terrifyingly superior techonology, and is destroyed (killed?) by the Doctor’s “anti-plastic” [perhaps a weapon from the War; see below].
History
Dating - It's clearly set around the time it aired; according to the "Have you seen this girl?" posters in X2.4, Aliens of London, Rose went missing on March 6, 2005, making that the day of the Nestene Consciousness' defeat.
By this time, some members of the human race have noticed that an individual named the Doctor keeps appearing throughout history. Clive has a web site devoted to the subject, and has collected evidence of Doctor sightings [according to the BBC’s version it’s taken over by Mickey after Clive’s death; see Aliens of London] . He has uncovered stories about the previous Auton invasion [or invasions, though almost certainly the first one as no shop dummies were involved in the second. Given his obsession, it seems odd that Clive hasn’t documented other Doctors, but then he does say to Rose “That’s your Doctor there, isn’t it?”, indicating he may be aware of more than one. Apart from the invasion attempt and Clive’s reference, there’s no indication that this Earth is any different from our one.]
The War
The Doctor fought in the war in which the Consciousness’ protein planets were destroyed, but was unable to save those planets, or “any of them”. [So the Consciousness was either on the other side or was an innocent casualty. While the Doctor’s willingness to give the Consciousness a chance might indicate the latter, it seems unlikely that all the Consciousness’ food planets could be destroyed by accident; and, of course, it’s terrified of the TARDIS and knows about Time Lords, so it must know how devastating Gallifreyan technology can be. Perhaps it was an ally of the Time Lords’ enemies rather than an active participant? That would explain the difference in the Doctor’s attitude between here and Dalek, though that it’s not a Dalek may of course be enough to explain that.]
The Time Lords
Time Lords are known to the Nestene Consciousness [unsurprising, since it worked with one (the Master) on its previous invasion attempt, though see The War.] The Doctor doesn’t mention them when explaining to Rose that he’s an alien.
The Analysis
Where does this come from?
It might sound like cheating, but Doctor Who.
Obviously.
More specifically it comes from what the public thinks Doctor Who was like, the notional Doctor Who, if you will. To wit, it has an eccentric character actor wielding a sonic screwdriver, it has a pretty girl being threatened by monsters, it reimagines The One With The Shop Window Dummies, and at the end the Doctor gives Rose a summary of his lifestyle that could have been written by Terrance Dicks. It’s clearly not just “spooky escapism”–it’s a bit too… pink for that. Still, there’s enough spookiness on show to live up to Doctor Who’s mythic reputation (and if the director weren’t such a pillock there would have been more–see the cack-handed wheelie bin attack. And the Killer Brides. And Auton Mickey’s vanquishing of some restaurant tables. And so on.), and the whole point of Davies’ script seems to be the need for escapism. The entire episode is pitched as exactly what Doctor Who means to the general public, and when Rose runs into the TARDIS in slow motion it’s blatant that she’s meant to represent the general viewer.
However there’s also a less-general notion of Doctor Who on display: that which the show’s fans have developed over the years. The relaunch of Doctor Who in 2005 seemed like graduation in many ways, with all of the writers involved having a fannish pedigree of some description. In some ways this was cause for celebration. Fans had been infiltrating the production team since Andrew Smith got a writer’s credit, and by the 1990s that infiltration was complete. When fans finally brought the Doctor back to prime time BBC1 it seemed like an apotheosis, a vindication of our faith in something we’d loved since childhood. In other ways, it was the point where fannish ideas began to feed back into the show with very little filtration. For the first time there was no outsider like Bidmead between Smith and the screen, no old pro like JNT between Platt and the public. Thus we get on-screen events that have already been road-tested in the pro-fan enclave. The Time War is an obvious example, despite playing a slightly different riff on the idea, but more significant (at this stage anyway) is the idea of the Doctor as a mythical, ambiguous harbinger of doom. There are hints of this during Cartmel’s tenure, but the idea was only really run with post-1989 because conservative voices like JNT couldn’t restrain them anymore. The result is a redefinition of the Doctor himself. Far from the ordinary guy who was smart enough to save planets, the Doctor was deconstructed, critiqued and probably most tellingly, made Important. He became more ambiguous, questioned his motivations more often, and generally behaved like Real Characters were supposed to in a post Dark Knight Returns environment.
The consequence was the idea of Doctor Who being a lot grander and more literary than cheap adventure TV could have ever made him. It was obvious in hindsight that fans should write stories like this, precisely because we’ve all seen the potential in Doctor Who rather than just the actuality. Now that we didn’t need to fill in the imaginative gaps between Robert Holmes’ imagination and the BBC’s budgets, we could do Doctor Who properly. We could do all those things that would make our peers take it seriously, and in the early 90s that basically meant we could make it darker. Just as Dark Knight Returns reclaims the “embarrassing” Adam West incarnation of Batman, the books (and, to a lesser extent, the audios) produced during the 1990s try to remould the figure of the Doctor. Titles like Time’s Champion and Ka Faraq Gatri were thrown around a lot, and grown-up notions like “character development” and “postmodernism” were artistically in fashion. It didn’t all work of course, and not everyone thought it was a good idea (and those critics formed a view of the New Adventures Doctor that was just as notional as the public’s race memory of the old show), but it did mean that our idea of the Doctor was made that much more complex.
The upshot of all this is that it’s no accident that Chris Eccleston’s first word is “Run!”, and that when Rose goes to find out the Doctor’s identity she receives a dark, mysterious explanation by a man explicitly coded to resemble an internet age Doctor Who fan. It’s what the public remembers the show being like (well, sort of), and it’s what the fans always thought the show should be (sort of).
It’s also influenced a lot by modern television. But then that was pretty obvious, wasn’t it?
Things that Don’t Make Sense
Why does the Consciousness need a relay in Henrik’s department store when it can control some plastic without one, and all the plastic in the world [eventually; the signal takes time to build up strength] using just the London Eye transmitter? [Without a relay or transmitter of some kind, perhaps it is unable to co-ordinate multiple Autons etc. at once? This seems unlikely given it can attack the Doctor with two in its own lair, but then proximity may also be a factor.] Why do the Autons in Henrik’s kill Wilson, the chief electrician? [He got in the way when they were looking for the Doctor, just like Rose. Or perhaps the relay patched into the electric systems and they were protecting it from discovery.]
Given that it needed to infiltrate factories to create Autons and other usable plastic items in the previous invasions, how did it create the Autons seen here? [They’re leftovers from the first invasion which were never activated, though this assumes UNIT didn’t round up every dummy in London afterwards, and they’ve been updated with modern dummy heads. The Consciousness is able to not only animate but entirely change the shape of plastic objects here, though, so perhaps it has just modified existing dummies to suit its purpose. If that’s true, though, then why don’t the Autons seen before the invasion commences ever use, or even seem to have, guns? Perhaps the most plausible explanation is that this is the Doctor at the end of stopping the invasion - he’s already found their conspirators and shut down the factory, now he has to stop the Consciousness from using the already-deployed Autons.]
If the Consciousness can animate any plastic in the whole world without special treatment, why bother with the Autons at all? Why not just suffocate, stab or otherwise attack humanity with every nearby plastic object at its disposal, as the Doctor and Rose discuss? [Perhaps it needs workers to process the planet’s resources so it can feed on them, and given the infrastructure in place, human sized and shaped servants make the most sense. The Doctor may also be simplifying things for Rose.]
Perhaps most inexplicably, why don’t the Autons kill Jackie Tyler? They spend an awful lot of time pointing their guns at her without firing…and, for that matter, wrestling with the Doctor on the edge of the Nestene pit.
Critique
The Prosecution
It would be nice to pretend that Rose can be assessed with complete objectivity by a Doctor Who fan, but it really just isn’t the case. Most of us took at least five years to realise that Doctor Who was really dead in the first place, and some took even longer. I remember writing a particularly embarrassing letter to someone at the time expressing my excitement about The Dark Dimension, and recalling my emotions now, it’s almost ridiculously easy to see the exact moment that I became an adult–it’s when I buried Doctor Who and moved on.
And yet… I remember worrying about the onset of dark as my dad drove us to my aunt’s place in Canberra: I knew that the TV movie would be on soon, and if we didn’t make it in time then I would miss out. When we made it I brought all my great expectations to bear… and unlike so much of fandom, I still liked it. It wasn’t perfect of course, and with hindsight this kind of Doctor Who wasn’t sustainable simply on budgetary grounds. But despite all the TV movie’s many flaws that were obsessed over by the Monday morning experts, I still thought it was pretty nifty. Maybe because it was a reaction against the perceived silliness of late 80s Who, Phil Segal’s take seemed dark, stylish and adult. It had themes and motifs and most importantly a budget. So much of it felt like Doctor Who done properly, with some care, some money and a repudiation of the “anything will do” ethos that blighted so much of the original series. It felt like it was going somewhere.
Some of you are probably expecting I’m going to say that I’ve changed my opinion since then. Thankfully, I’m going to avoid that little cliché.
For all it’s perceived fannishness (which basically boils down to complaining about McGann’s opening monologue), the TV movie was also the last time Doctor Who would be made by someone who wasn’t an insider. Segal might have been a fan of the series, but he wasn’t a card-carrying anorak. In my opinion, it shows. As bound up in continuity as the TVM sometimes feels, it’s still a pretty straightforward story. More importantly it dodged the bullets of being in awe of the show’s own myth (and going by what we might have ended up with, this was no mean feat). It’s a show made with a certain distance between the makers and their product, the gap, you might say, between affection and fanaticism.
Fast forward to now. The creator of one of my favourite TV shows was overseeing the relaunch of my all-time favourite show, and best of all he was doing it with support. Gone were the days when the BBC had it in for Doctor Who. There was goodwill at last, the sort of goodwill that can only come from something that one loves in childhood. The goodwill that only a fan can muster.
Because, yes, Russell T. Davies was an unashamed, card-carrying anorak. We didn’t have to wonder, as we did during the Amblin/Segal years, whether he would get it. We knew he would because he was one of us. And anyone who was capable of TV as sublime as Queer as Folk should be able to produce wonderful Doctor Who. Basically, Russell T Davies being the showrunner on the revival was a Who fan’s dream come true.
So, as I was saying… a Doctor Who fan really can’t assess Rose objectively. The first episode of the new series was always going to be weighed down by a crippling load of fanboy expectations; not just because it was the return of Doctor Who, but also because it was by a guy capable of making brilliant TV. Now that I’m old enough to know the difference, it is probably not the fact that new Doctor Who seems different to the old that disappoints me. No, the real problem is that it’s not as good as Queer as Folk, not as bold as The Second Coming, and not as self-assured as either.
The toughest nut to crack is getting the right tone. Everyone has an idea of what constitutes Proper Doctor Who, but whether that can be translated into the world of 21st century TV is tricky at best. Certainly it’s the thing that Davies has really struggled to nail, and he certainly doesn’t manage it by the end of “Rose”. Part of the problem is that Rose always feels like it’s striving to be the relaunch of Proper Doctor Who. It deploys a tick-list of iconic moments as quick as it can, and even the little moments seem to be written in italics. Everything feels very calculated, trying too hard to impress and even the joie de vivre that characterises the best Doctor Who feels deliberately scripted. It’s trying oh-so-hard to be it’s own thing, but it can’t help revelling in the fact that this is the Relaunch of Doctor Who. This enthusiasm results in a story that is Doctor Who in quotation marks; a greatest hits selection.
Of course there’s nothing inherently wrong with that. As mentioned above, the TV movie was also littered with nods to the past and that didn’t hit me between the eyes in the same way. The difference, it seems to me, is that Rose feels a lot less like it has its own identity. The TV movie, for all its faults, felt like something with ambition. Not just in the fannish sense of overturning sacred cows like the Doctor’s half-humanity, but in its scope and in its themes. It was about life and death, time and love, change and decay. Rose, by contrast, is mostly about the Doctor. There’s no question that it’s about other things as well, but despite being packed to the gills with incident and information, there’s still a nagging sense of things being insubstantial. The sense of myth can fill this in a little; we can see the shadow of Tom Baker behind Christopher Eccleston’s forced eccentricity for instance, and that can suggest more than is really there. Ultimately, however, this deference to the myth of Doctor Who simply feels talismanic rather than producing something genuinely meaningful. It feels like people dressing up in their dad’s clothes, and while that can be fun, it’s a far better idea to dress in your own.
This myth also seems to have rubbed off in more annoying ways. The idea that Doctor Who is a camp or silly show seems to have affected the new series’ tone, and while frivolity is fine in moderation, it does mean that big, expensive set pieces like the final Auton assault are rendered laughable. Keith Boak’s direction certainly doesn’t help, with the emphasis on “modern” TV grammar (the sped up footage, the montage sequences, the emphasis on the domestic that seems so at odds with the classic series) seeming overly self-conscious, as if to emphasise that This Is A Relaunch. The result is something that sacrifices gravitas in its bid to appear relevant in today’s TV environment, and while Doctor Who has frequently worked well when it is tongue in cheek, it has rarely worked at all when it’s silly.
On a similar note, the really crushing thing is the poor realisation of many of the special effects. Having been embarrassed for years by Who’s wonky production values, it almost feels like a betrayal when the new series’ much-ballyhooed updates seem just as artificial. The wheelie bin attack is of course the worst example, not just because of the cartoony CGI, but also because of the cartoony tone. On paper it must have sounded simultaneously barmy and scary, and that sounds exactly like Doctor Who. On screen, however, it just looks like someone having to murder themselves with a poor special effect… and that’s no better than Terror of the Autons. I’m sure the scene could have been made to work; even restaging it so that the bin knocks Mickey over and eats him like a python swallowing a rabbit would probably make the image seem more nightmarish. Instead, the direction is flat, the effects unconvincing (the plastic sticking to Mickey’s hand is just about acceptable, but then the bin starts doing something that can only be described as a shimmy), and the sequence becomes embarrassing. No one would argue that living up to Doctor Who's legendary scariness was going to be easy (and to be fair the creaking Autons that surround Rose in the basement work really well), but when a key set-piece like this is so wide of the mark, frankly it beggars belief.
Rose, then, is a curate’s egg. As a reintroduction to an old favourite it does a lot of things right (although interestingly, it does basically the same things the TV movie was derided for) while also proving that Doctor Who is a lot trickier to get right than the format might suggest. What redeems it is the sense of love for the material, the enthusiasm for what the Doctor represents, and perhaps that’s why Billie Piper emerges with the most kudos. Subtle, appealing and effortlessly treading the line between light and darkness, she is precisely what Doctor Who in the twenty-first century should be. As she elects to go off to pastures new there is the promise that we are in good hands, that at the very least, Davies has something to work with. Rose can take the piss out of the Doctor and she can take him seriously, but whatever she’s doing, she’s real. With her around we don’t need icons anymore, and the Doctor and his show can go somewhere new.
And we’ve been waiting for that for a very long time.
The Defence
Rose is, frankly, an impressive debut, with a cracking pace and excellent performances from both leads, though at this stage Piper shines brighter as Eccleston doesn’t have a firm character to work with. Not nearly as different from previous Who as all the hype suggested (see Where Does This Come From? for more), though there are strong and accurate parallels with Season 24, not least the plot which matters far less than the companion (and the audience) meeting a new Doctor. The episode feels a bit padded towards the end (why does it take so long for the Autons to kill Jackie?), but overall everything builds well, and even if you know all about the Doctor and the Consciousness, there’s a satisfaction in seeing someone else piece it all together. The Doctor doesn’t seem to take anything seriously until it’s almost too late, which was what led Tom’s silliest episodes to their doom, but Clive is a treat. While obviously a nod to obsessive fans (and, of course, Who Killed Kennedy, the first work to seriously consider what kind of footprint the Doctor may have left in human history; it's something we’ll see taken a step further in X2.10, Love & Monsters and, arguably, Torchwood), but he lends the story the deadly seriousness it otherwise lacks and his final appearance is poignant. It’s a solid start with great promise for the new series.
The Facts
Written by Russell T Davies. Directed by Keith Boak. Peak of 10.5 million viewers, 44.3% audience share.
Supporting cast: Camille Coduri (Jackie Tyler), Noel Clarke (Mickey Smith), Mark Benton (Clive), Ellie Garnett (Caroline), Adam McCoy (Clive’s Son), Alan Ruscoe, Paul Kasey, David Sant, Elizabeth Fost and Helen Otway (Autons), Nicholas Briggs (Nestene Voice)
Working Titles: None known.
The Teaser: There isn’t one.
Cliffhangers: None.
The Lore
- A “slashprint” (a supposedly unfinished copy, but the only detectable difference was the original Delia Derbyshire theme) was leaked by an employee of one of the Canadian television networks bidding for the show, around two weeks before the UK broadcast. Rumours ran rife that this was planned as a marketing ploy by the BBC, but they deny it, and later legal action resulted in the culprit losing his job.
- During the first transmission, sound bled over from Strictly Come Dancing several times during the first five minutes, completely ruining some tense moments for Rose in the basement of the department building.
- BBC web designers made a “real” version of Clive’s web site, available at http://www.whoisdoctorwho.co.uk. The original page was almost identical to the one seen in the series, but it was updated after broadcast with news of the “killer plastic dolls” by a friend who had taken over from Clive. Subsequent updates include mention of mysterious voices being heard the same night as the invasion - referring to the sound bleed mentioned above. Readers were able to submit Doctor sightings and their experiences of the invasion.
- In the week after the episode screened to almost universally positive reviews, the BBC announced that it had commissioned a second series and a special Christmas episode, and soon after that Christopher Eccleston would not be returning. Various reasons were cited included fear of being typecast and the gruelling schedule, but it was later revealed that the BBC had not contacted Eccleston before responding to press queries, and that his departure was meant to have been kept secret. See What Really Happened With Christopher Eccleston?