World War Three
| X1.5 - “World War Three” (2) | ||||
| Doctor Who Series 1, Episode 5, 23 April, 2005 | ||||
| Featuring the Ninth Doctor with Rose Tyler | ||||
| Written by Russell T. Davies, directed by Keith Boak, produced by Phil Collinson. | ||||
| “Aliens of London” | << | “World War Three” | >> | “Dalek” |
Which One is This?
The Doctor saves the world from inside an iron box, though to be fair, Mickey has a little something to do with blowing up Number 10 and the farting fat fools currently inhabiting it. Sadly, we're talking about the Slitheen.
Firsts and Lasts
It's the first cliffhanger resolution for new Who, and it's not a bad one.
Things to Notice About World War Three
- This episode is one of the rare instances in which the Doctor bluffs a foe and they don't go for it; in hindsight, it seems a bit odd to be poking fun at a convention of the show this early, but on the other hand it makes for a brilliant gag and it's also a lovely bit of character work.
- There are plenty of other lovely character moments here, but perhaps the best comes right at the end, with this Doctor's only real moment of kindness to or connection with Mickey. It's a shame that this male bonding seems lost by the time we get to X1.11, Boom Town.
The Continuity
The Doctor
Inventory
Claims that the sonic screwdriver can "triplicate the flammability" of alcohol, but this is nonsense and only a bluff. He also has, or quickly creates, a computer virus which can erase evidence of him from the Internet [which must have run its course by X2.10, Love & Monsters, as Elton meets the rest of LINDA via the Internet, though it explains why they never find out as much as Clive had. On the other hand Mickey's metafictional web site never stops talking about the Doctor's exploits, so it's possible, though unlikely, that Mickey never unleashed the virus.]
Ethics
Isn't worried about killing the Slitheen considering it will mean saving all the humans on Earth. He is very worried about risking Rose's life though, and takes a little convincing that she's not as important as all of the human race. Clearly he's already very taken with her.
Background
The Doctor knows of Raxacoricofallipatorius, including the general biology of its inhabitants and even that they possess hyphenated surnames, but has not heard of the Slitheen. [He doesn't recognise the Slitheen by sight, so perhaps he has only read about them, rather than visited?] He’s also familiar with the near future of the UK, recognising Harriet Jones as a future Prime Minister and the architect of a “Golden Age”. [He also says she is elected for three successive terms, a future he presumably changes in X1.X, The Christmas Invasion.]
Rose
The Supporting Cast
Mickey
Jackie
The TARDIS
History
The War
The Time Lords
The Arc Word
Bad Wolf: The young kid from Aliens of London is made to clean the "BAD WOLF" graffiti from the TARDIS. Also the American newsreader's name is "Mal Loup", roughly French for "Bad Wolf", though this is not revealed on screen until her later appearance in X3.12, The Sound of Drums.
The Analysis
Where does this come from?
Doctor Who has always had an uneasy relationship with its British citizenship. Particularly in the Pertwee era, but even more pointedly by the time Tom Baker took over the role, stupid civil servants, corrupt businessmen and a xenophobic military were the leaders of Doctor Who's version of the UK. Although the Doctor maintained a degree of kinship with his adopted home, it was only rarely that this was allowed to spill over into overt nationalism, with the character drawn as an outsider who happens to have British friends rather than someone with genuine allegiances. "World War Three" is the first new series episode to really continue this tradition, and unlike "Aliens of London", which might just as easily have happened in Washington, it's very much a satire of the British way of thinking.
Basically the British have never quite got over the loss of their Empire. The First World War is a handy point from which to chart the beginning of their true decline, with the colonies wandering off to form their own national identity after helping the Brits fight their European war. The result is that the twentieth century saw Britain evolve into a nation painfully aware of its former greatness, and still desperate to retain what little influence it had in global affairs. Unfortunately the post-colonial gasps of British internationalism have rarely, if ever, been positive. The real gut-wound was their rout at Dunkirk, but the shameful foot-dragging over Indian independence, the failure to find peace in Northern Ireland, the debacle at Suez and the senile chest-beating over the Falklands made Britain seem increasingly pathetic. And, deep down, most of the Brits knew it. The people who made Doctor Who certainly did, and while the show was often parochial, one has only to compare the leading characters of classic Who and Star Trek to see the vast difference in television created by imperial and post-imperial nations.
Which brings us to "World War Three". Where "Aliens of London" was an episode that felt global both in its implications and its influences, "World War Three" keeps things local. It hardly needs to be pointed out that the episode represents the reaction to a symbolic 9/11, with the major consequence being Britain's government deciding to take part in a dodgy imperial misadventure. Many commentators have noted "World War Three's" obvious allegorical jabs about starting a war for fuel and using phantom weapons of mass destruction as the pretext, but Davies is also aiming at a less obvious target. The Blair government's appetite for war is a logical continuation of a country still grappling with a lingering post-imperial hangover--after all, being deputy sheriff can be seen as better than being nothing at all (an attitude clearly on Davies's mind, as he explicitly repudiates it in "The Christmas Invasion"). Thus despite the specifics of the 'forty-five second deployment' that make "World War Three" such a contemporary piece of satire, it is that peculiarly British desire to regain influence no matter what the moral cost that Davies really seems angry about.
The general silliness of the story's tone also masks just how savage Davies seems to be. Where previously the politicians in Doctor Who were either venal or buffoons, "World War Three" depicts them as gross monsters peering out through the dead skins of their victims. It's as if the satirical gloves have been taken off, with the fury that gives rise to the story necessitating a bigger calibre of weapon than the show has previously contemplated. In this light, blowing up Number 10 seems like the only possible punchline for a story so disgusted with the people that currently mislead the nation. Some have carped about Davies' pile-driver tactics, but while they have a point, it could be that asking, "where does this come from?" answers more questions than it usually does. Perhaps "World War Three" is the satirical equivalent of a Buddhist monk lighting himself on fire: it's extreme, but it's an act brought about by an extreme environment.
It's also an attack that seems to hope that its savagery can facilitate a cleansing. This is a story in which the hero declares that the most important thing to do is to stand up when nobody else will, and features a politician willing to die in order to do the right thing. More importantly, bearing in mind that the story's conclusion sees the lying warmongers blown up and the only honest politician among them (who is careful to point out that she voted against the invasion of Iraq) emerging from the fire to initiate Britain's Golden Age, it certainly looks like an attempt to wipe the moral slate clean. In short, "World War Three" is a celebration of idealism, lancing the boil that has taken a century to build up on the skin of the British psyche. At last, it seems to be saying, we have a government run by people that will do the right thing [well, until "The Christmas Invasion" at any rate].
Oh, and at the more popcorn-y end of the spectrum, the trying-to-solve-a-crisis-while-locked-inside-an-impregnable-room is obviously ripping off David Fincher's then-recent thriller Panic Room. Jodie Foster doesn't resort to a missile attack to sort out her problems though. Clearly Fincher is now kicking himself for his lack of imagination.
Things that Don’t Make Sense
The Doctor knows the secret password to a very sensitive web site - but he never supplies Mickey with a username. Even assuming Mickey is a good enough hacker to get past a great deal of encryption and other security to get at the password entry, the password itself, "buffalo", is ridiculously insecure, and surely must be changed often enough that the Doctor couldn't possibly know what it is as this specific moment. It seems a little gratuitous to mention it, but just in case you hadn't considered it, it's fundamentally stupid and certainly not "world's best practice" for such an important military computer to even be connected to the Internet, let alone to have a web interface built-in for the remote launch of missiles.
Critique
The Prosecution
The funny thing is… while "World War Three" was probably the point where the tide of fannish opinion really turned against Russell T. Davies (after some Slitheen-like menacing rumbles over "Aliens of London"), it's not half as bad as some would have you believe. The most annoying thing is that it's really the first Davies script that doesn't measure up to his boast that he brings 'proper drama' to the table, and while there are many nice little pieces of authorial marzipan, the episode ultimately rings hollow.
The real problem (and one that continues to afflict Davies' future work on the series) is that this looks like a script written at speed, and therefore the really clever touches have been exhausted in the previous episode. This is betrayed by the fact that this script just doesn't seem to have any real ideas. "Aliens of London" was hardly the world's most original science fiction idea (again something that continues to afflict Davies' work), but its approach to Doctor Who's format gave it a freshness that "World War Three" just can't match. The gaff is blown at the end of the previous episode and the subversive attitude is mostly jettisoned in favour of familiar situations. Even worse the widescreen attitude that Davies had maintained up until now is sharply compromised. There are genuine efforts to compensate, but this is an episode that just feels a bit half-hearted, as if unable to complete the sentence that "Aliens" so brilliantly begins. It's hardly something to get worked up about--at least Davies is thinking big in the first place--but it's the root problem of what really makes "World War Three" unsatisfying.
Elsewhere there is a failure to really think the dramatic beats through as rigorously as possible. For a start, virtually every piece of jeopardy that Davies contrives for his heroes is overcome with annoying plot cheats. From the resolution of the cliffhanger (granted the Doctor has dodged many a bullet over the years because of his alien nature, but if you're going to talk the talk about proper drama then you need to walk the walk as well), the Doctor's escape from the soldiers via the lift, the revelation that the cabinet room has impregnable doors that the Doctor can easily access, and most stupidly Rose's discovery of a missile-proof cupboard… all these solutions feel creakily contrived. It's easy to see how they might seem attractive in that they're surprising, but there's also a sense that Davies keeps backing into corners and pulling out magic beans to get back out again. The sonic screwdriver has been similarly criticised by no less than Christopher H. Bidmead, and it's probably the clearest ongoing example of just how much the new series emphasises pace over intelligence. All the rushing about does mean that this iteration of Doctor Who is rarely as paralysing as the old series could be, but it does mean that Davies' claims of 'proper drama' need to be thrown back in his face a bit more by his script editors.
Such deficiencies are only thrown into sharper relief by the fact that the "narrows it down" scene feels far more like textbook Doctor Who. It still falls apart if you poke it a bit (the crucial deduction is something the viewer could never come to on their own, and again, while the Doctor's knowledge of aliens has often come in handy in the past, his conclusion of Raxacoricofallapatorius is bathetic gobbledegook), but the playing of the scene and the central dramatic imperative of prisoners transcending their limitations to remain heroic lifts it above the norm. It's let down somewhat by the fact that Davies' decision to trap the Doctor in a room (and thereby setting himself a dramatic constraint that could have been really interesting if the intellectual angle had been more enthusiastically pursued) is again undermined by the ease with which he ultimately saves the day, but he is at least to be commended for trying.
Other ideas are less compromised. The spark of subversion that enlivened "Aliens" reappears when the Doctor interrogates the Slitheen about their fiendish plan. The usual assumptions, both about the Slitheen being the name of a race rather than a family (neatly undercutting the show's usual xenophobia), their desire to sell Earth for fuel rather than invade it (which, while derivative of "The Dominators", is still reasonably novel), and their mysterious signal turning out to be an advertisement are all steering the show in original directions. Davies' dialogue continues to sparkle, with the Doctor's asides during his confrontation with the Slitheen walking just the right side of sending the situation up. Again we can make out the elusive tone that Davies is so obviously striving for, but when the director and his own laziness undermine his efforts it only becomes all the more frustrating. For instance the plonking satire of the "massive weapons of destruction" is neither funny nor biting, and the mass of Slitheen hammily enthusing over the red phone only serves to remind the audience just how annoying these villains really are. And that's before you see them trying to run around, with Keith Boak delivering a rare double of shit latex and shit CGI.
In the final analysis it's jeopardy that "World War Three" really lacks, the darker tones that would counteract all the kid's TV stuff. The Slitheen should be terrifying monsters but they're really just wobbly and repetitive. The Doctor's supposed dilemma about "saving the world but losing Rose" sounds good in the trailer, but is perfunctory in the final product. The 'proper drama' of Jackie questioning the Doctor's lifestyle and her feelings of bereavement when Rose leaves again at the end of the ep should be affecting, but they're hand-waved aside just that little bit too easily. The swagger that makes Davies' version of Doctor Who seem so exciting begins to look like arrogance here; the arrogance of one of Britain's best dramatists literally farting out a script. "World War Three" is far better than most people would have you believe… but it's also the first time the new series is really guilty of an egregious waste of potential.
The Defence
The Facts
Written by Russell T. Davies. Directed by Keith Boak. Peak of 8.0 million viewers, y% audience share.
Supporting cast:
Working Titles:
The Teaser: The assembled heads of UNIT are all electrocuted to death via their security badges, but the Doctor is made of tougher stuff and manages to stand up and jam his arcing badge into the translator collar worn by one of the Slitheen, electrocuting him and his cronies.
Cliffhanger: None.
The Lore