Father's Day
| X1.8 - “Father's Day” | ||||
| Doctor Who Series 1, Episode 8, 14 May, 2005 | ||||
| Featuring the Ninth Doctor with Rose Tyler | ||||
| Written by Paul Cornell, directed by Joe Ahearne, produced by Phil Collinson. | ||||
| “The Long Game” | << | “Father's Day” | >> | “The Empty Child” |
Which One is This?
It's the one where Rose breaks rule number one of time travel, "don't kill your parents", only in reverse.
Firsts and Lasts
It's the first time the Doctor or one of his companions explicitly create a paradox, and also the first time it's explicitly stated that the Time Lords used to police this sort of thing. Thus it's also the first time we find out that the Universe without Time Lords is not necessarily a better place, even if it is also a Universe without Daleks. It's also the first time the Doctor has died but then has his death "undone" - though of course not the first time the series has done this with its main cast (see The Telemovie).
Things to Notice About Father's Day
- Father and child stories choke me up like nobody's business, but even so, here it's painfully obvious very early on what Pete will have to do, and also that he'll work it out for himself. The word "painfully" is used on purpose, because it really is heart wrenching stuff.
- Like nearly every time paradox ever written, this story doesn't really make logical sense. But then, that's the point - it's a paradox. And it certainly makes a whole lot more sense than nearly anything else made with the same basic story.
The Continuity
The Doctor
Inventory
Ethics
Background
Rose
The TARDIS
History
The War
The Time Lords
The Arc Word
Bad Wolf: A poster advertising a rave on the wall behind Rose and the Doctor near the scene of Pete's fatal accident has "BAD WOLF" scrawled on it.
The Analysis
Where does this come from?
We've already begun to forget what it was like, but once upon a time Doctor Who was pretty much an ex-series. The BBC never quite said whether it was officially dead or not, and we now know that even they weren't terribly sure when or if they proposed to bring it back. However, for all intents and purposes, where Doctor Who had been, there was now a vacuum.
Fans abhor a vacuum.
For a lot of reasons, Virgin's New Adventures novels were something that couldn't have happened while Doctor Who was still on television. John Nathan-Turner had resisted the idea of original novels being produced concurrent with the series, and it's clear that Peter Darvill Evans wouldn't have been completely satisfied either. Once the show slipped into its long coma however, Virgin could proceed. They weren't the first to pick up the threads left by the show's cancellation (Marvel had been publishing an ongoing comic strip since 1979), and they weren't the first to employ self-confessed fan writers (Andrew Smith and Marc Platt having written "Full Circle" and "Ghost Light" respectively). Nor were they the first media-SF books to continue from where its parent series had left off. Pocket had been publishing original Star Trek novels since 1981, and Heir to the Empire rekindled the Star Wars brand a month before Timewyrm: Genesys hit the shelves. What the New Adventures did have, however, was moxie, and in Darvill-Evans an effective show-runner. Declaring themselves the “official continuation” of the TV series' legacy, and producing stories “too broad and deep” for television, the New Adventures had a mission statement and eventually an identifiable style.
That style was, among other things, recognisably fannish, with many of the authors openly admitting that they saw the New Adventures as a corrective for the perceived shortcomings of the TV show. At the more parochial end of the creative spectrum, this meant that continuity glitches could be smoothed over and budget-busting locations and action suddenly became feasible. More ambitiously, the show's basically Manichean philosophy was critiqued, various isms (feminism, post-colonialism, postmodernism) were thrown at the basic story archetypes to see what happened, and most notably the emotional experiences of the regular characters moved into the foreground. Is any of this sounding familiar?
Of course none of this was exactly revolutionary (much of it was simple extrapolation of what had been happening under Andrew Cartmel's regime), but it took the New Adventures to turn it into a brand. The Doctor and his companion could be genuinely affected by what they experienced, and could be at odds far more profoundly and at far greater length than the TV series ever contemplated. The redefinition of Ace, the last televisal companion, was probably the most obvious example of this. Having lost the love of her life because of the Doctor's betrayal, she left his side to become a soldier. When she returned she'd undergone a Dark Knight-style reinterpretation, and her relationship with the Doctor never really recovered. Doctor Who had depicted fractious relationships before, but this was a quantum leap forward for supposedly “soapy” emotional content. The result was that the New Adventures became known (fairly or unfairly) for the level of angst they inflicted on the regulars, and the man who set the benchmark for this was Paul Cornell.
Cornell has mellowed considerably since the early 90s, but at the time he was an extremely outspoken critic of Doctor Who script edited by Eric Saward. Put crudely, the main objection can be boiled down to that of the 90s-style New Man reacting to the macho excesses of the 1980s. Consequently, in the New Adventures the female characters were given ample room to develop (and were frequently portrayed as the more rounded personalities), the fluffier elements of Doctor Who (such as its humour and whimsy) were championed, and the male characters all got in touch with their feminine side (the Brigadier, that great bastion of repressed military masculinity on the telly, is recharacterised as a spiritually rejuvenated Zen warrior). Not all of Cornell's contemporaries followed his lead, but enough of them did to create the stereotype of a “typical” NA, and it's this voice that Davies asked Cornell to bring to “Father's Day”. Fans of the novels will also notice more specific nods to Cornell's previous work. Timewyrm: Revelation in particular features a church besieged by time-active monsters, not to mention a baby that plays a significant part in the plot. Furthermore Cornell has acknowledged the debt the story owes to “Mawdryn Undead” (the exploration of temporal/paradoxical interference, the sacrifice of an innocent to resolve the story) and the Reapers' nature and appearance are similar-ish to the Chronovores in “The Time Monster”.
Leaving the orbit of Doctor Who, there's also an undeniable debt to Star Trek. Cornell has acknowledged the influence of Peter David's Trek novels on his early career (particularly Imzadi, and we'll be talking about that again when we get to “Human Nature”), and it's clear that “City on the Edge of Forever” also casts a long shadow. The most popular episode of classic Trek, “City” also saw the lead characters time travelling to a period in the contemporary audience's relatively recent past, in this case Depression Era America. Shortly after arriving Kirk falls in love with a woman named Edith Keeler, but just as Rose does with Pete, he must allow Keeler to die in order to safeguard the “correct” version of history. Played as grand tragedy in which love is trumped by the greater good, “City” is an unapologetic tearjerker with many, many generic offspring. Some of these may have also formed part of the creative mulch in the back of Cornell's mind (it's almost impossible to imagine that elements of Back to the Future, Peggy-Sue Got Married and particularly Frequency didn't creep into the mix somewhere), alongside clear nods to shows like Sapphire and Steel (the Reapers perfectly embody the idea of time “breaking through” to menace ordinary people) and The Twilight Zone.
Lastly, the period setting of “Father's Day” is symptomatic of the ongoing retro-80s trend in film, music and television, arguably popularised by the Adam Sandler movie The Wedding Singer. The first half of 1990s pop culture had seen the pendulum swing sharply away from the trends of the previous decade. Grunge emerged to kill hair-metal bands like Poison and Motley Crue, the independent aesthetic began to colonise the Hollywood mainstream with films like Pulp Fiction, Fargo and Chasing Amy, and uncertainty began to replace the euphoria of the post-Cold War party. The 1970s used to be known as “the decade that fashion forgot”, but as the new young punks reappraised 70s culture and attitudes, this derisory tag began to stick more and more to the 1980s. The big hair, the bright pastels, the drum-machine-driven pop music... suddenly it all seemed so smug and tinny.
However by the mid-to-late 90s the wheel had turned again, and the scorn had begun to give way to a certain nostalgic affection. The Wedding Singer doesn't miss too many opportunities to remind us of how silly we all looked, but there's also a strong sense of celebration there. Like the 70s before it, the 80s had passed through “dated” and reached the Canaan of “retro”, and this is mostly how “Father's Day” approaches things. The fact that it features a wedding is probably coincidental, but when Rose gets her first look at Jackie's 80s hair it's obvious the production team are at the very least going to tell a lot of the same jokes. As in The Wedding Singer those jokes are about an iconic sort of 1980s that never really existed (well, not all at the same time anyway), but as with most Doctor Who historicals, why let the truth get in the way of a good story?
Oh, and we mustn't forget Donnie Darko. Well, obviously.
Things that Don’t Make Sense
Well, it's a temporal paradox. By it's nature it doesn't make any sense. But we need to get specific...
It makes sense that saving Pete causes a paradox, specifically an ontological paradox: if he'd never died, Rose would never want to come back and see him, and thus never saved him. Rose herself, however, is not drastically altered, so it seems the future isn't changed - it's just put in jeopardy of existing. The Reapers are said to be attracted to paradoxes, but if so, why don't they immediately appear at the site of the biggest paradox - Rose saving her father? Why show up at the church?
Despite fancy labels (Professor Blinovich, I'm looking at you), there's absolutely nothing paradoxical about Rose touching her younger self. [It's established in Doctor Who lore, though, that objects or creatures which come into contact with younger or older versions of themselves cause a release of energy. Why this should be isn't really explained - see 20.3, Mawdryn Undead" and the relevant essay - but presumably the Reapers feed on this energy and can use it to materialise.]
While we're at it, if the death of the Time Lords leaves vortex-dwelling creatures like the Reapers free to fly around and consume things, where are Kronos and the rest of the Chronovores? Surely a paradox must be like bread and butter to them as well?
The Reapers are inconsistent in their attitude to the age of objects. Older walls are a stronger defence against them, yet they prefer eating older things. They make it into the church only because Rose touches her baby self, yet they barely hesitate before eating the Doctor. [They're really flesh and blood creatures, even though they can exist in other dimensions and in the vortex, so they find greater nourishment in older living things, but have trouble passing through older inanimate matter.]
What happens to everyone's memories at the end of the episode? At first it seems everyone - even the restored to life Doctor - remembers only the new version of events, though that version of events is unclear at best. After all, Pete only made it to the church because he'd already been saved by Rose, so in the new timeline, why wasn't he hit by the car in the first place? And what about the driver? How was history altered to make him drive to the church? Presumably he wasn't a guest, or someone would have found out about the hit and run and it wouldn't remain a mystery forever.
Critique
Russell T Davies is on record as stating that one of the most attractive things about reviving Doctor Who was the chance to create "big pictures". Of course Davies' definition of bigness encompasses the obvious thousands-of-Daleks-converging-upon-our-heroes moments, but also the opportunity to explore how a moment like that might actually feel. Doctor Who was never a terribly demonstrative program at the best of times, and aside from the usual emotions found in adventure shows (fear, anger and so on) it's striking to realise just how reserved it usually was. The truth is that Doctor Who wasn't really about people so much as it was about adventure show archetypes, and children's adventure show archetypes at that. Despite occasional exceptions, these characters' greatest worries were always external menaces that could be disposed of in four episodes. We can only make vague guesses as to what someone like Jo Grant did between adventures for example, and certainly there's precious little indication that she ever had to cope with mundane things like weddings, shopping or paying the rent. In short, there's no real sense of an interior life in much of Doctor Who; no attention paid to the little things that make the universe worth saving in the first place.
Given this, it's easier to understand why Davies' approach to the show sometimes feels so different. For better or worse, Rose was a character that always remained rooted in the everyday. Far from simply being placed back in the toybox at the end of each story, she went home to see her mum, had her washing done and ate a lot of chips. Suddenly the show didn't seem embarrassed about the characters' interior lives, and in keeping with Davies' "big picture" approach, at times those lives could seem almost (soap) operatic. It was an approach that didn't always work--the Tyler family were an acquired taste, and when characters like these interact with a Doctor Who story it can't help seeming slightly incongruous. But when they got the balance right we got something new and refreshing, a celebration of how small things can have big consequences.
And perhaps that's why "Father's Day" is so refreshing--it's a Doctor Who story that goes out of its way to tap the dramatic potential of small things. For all the blather about the Reapers Sterilising the Whole World, the story is firmly anchored around the fate of one ordinary man. As the Who revival progressed there was a sense that big was better, with even the cheaper shows aspiring to become mini-epics. Episodes like "School Reunion" and "Fear Her" certainly should be like "Father's Day", but resort instead to meaningless spectacle. Exploding schools and Olympic ceremonies crowd out emotional honesty, and it is to Paul Cornell's credit that his episode finally triumphs because it keeps things simple.
That's not to say that the story is perfect, with the opening scenes feeling particularly awkward. Rose's desire to see her father basically comes from nowhere, and the Doctor's willingness to allow it seems even stranger. Adding insult to injury is the fact that he indulges her not once but twice. It's tempting, with our fan's knowledge of the series' production history, to wonder whether this lumpy beginning is a legacy of the many rewrites that Cornell had to perform. Indeed, when compared to stories like "Ghost Light" (in which the Doctor deliberately takes his companion into painful territory) or "Snakedance" (in which Tegan, under the influence of the Mara, steers the TARDIS herself), "Father's Day" can't help but seem inelegant. Stumbles like this, to say nothing of the unsubtle "ironic" dialogue (Jackie's "late to your own funeral" outburst and the father of the groom's "this day is cursed" routine), strand the story in second gear, and it's only when the Reapers finally appear that things perk up.
However once things are set up, the interesting thing is how the story seems so fresh. Time paradoxes have been done to death in the last fifty years, but because we see this one through Rose's eyes, suddenly it feels completely novel. It's here that Cornell's emphasis on the intimate really pays off. Unlike, say, Sarah Jane in "The Time Warrior", this particular threat to Earth's history is intensely personal to Rose. Better still is the fact that it can only be neutralised by paying an extremely high emotional price. The outcome may be predictable, and yes, fairly sentimental too, but what saves any great tragedy is passion. Cynics may sneer, but stories like Titanic, Armageddon and "City on the Edge of Forever" work for a mass audience precisely because they refuse to be ashamed of emotion. That's not to say that they can't be funny or ironic, but at their core these are stories determined to depict the sheer enormity of emotional loss. "Father's Day" works in precisely this fashion, and demonstrates just how well Davies' Doctor Who can work when everything pulls in the same direction. It's a trick that can't be pulled every week (the Cybermen stories of series two are obviously aiming for similar resonance but fail miserably), but this first time everyone's along for the ride. Piper and Eccleston are never better than here, and at times it's almost shocking to remember how angry the Doctor and Rose could be with each other. It's all about to change of course, but for now these are characters with real bruises, and frankly they're the better for it.
Of course there are still minor stumbles scattered throughout the episode, but when Paul Cornell allows his imagination to begin burrowing into the situation he ultimately comes up trumps. The Doctor's panicked discovery of his gutted TARDIS may not be the most rational image, but it's satisfyingly eerie and succinctly conveys the danger of the situation. Similarly the notion that old things slow the Reapers' progress is more lyrical than logical, but it is precisely this lyricism that makes it memorable. The story would still work if the church were simply protected by a bog-standard force field, but the imaginative thrust that propels the best Doctor Who would be lost. More importantly, in a show that will always have to address the consequences of time travel, concepts like the Reapers are far more memorable than dowdy technobabble. To a fan, "Father's Day" is simply the One Where Pete Tyler Dies. To the general viewer though, this is the episode that explains how an enormous chunk of Doctor Who works, and throughout its long history there are precious few episodes that do it so successfully and with such care. There are more graceful stories in this first year, and all of them exhibit a fierce determination to reassert the program's rightful place as part of mainstream television. But as an example of all the things that make Doctor Who distinctive, "Father's Day" is the one that emerges as the most necessary. And for such a satisfyingly small story that's no small achievement.
The Facts
Written by Paul Cornell. Directed by Joe Ahearne. Peak of 8.1 million viewers, y% audience share.
Supporting cast:
Working Titles:
The Teaser: A series of flashbacks show us Jackie Tyler telling a young Rose about her father, Rose persuading the Doctor to take her back in time to see him alive, and Rose and the Doctor attending her parents' wedding. They then materialise at the time and place of his death.
Cliffhangers: None.
The Lore