The Unquiet Dead

From About Time Again
Jump to navigation Jump to search
X1.3 - “The Unquiet Dead”
Doctor Who Series 1, Episode 3, 9 April, 2005
Featuring the Ninth Doctor with Rose Tyler
Written by Mark Gatiss, directed by Euros Lyn, produced by Phil Collinson.
“The End of the World” << “The Unquiet Dead” >> “Aliens of London”

Which One is This?

The Doctor and Rose head back in time to Christmas Eve, 1869, and meet Simon Callow. I mean, Charles Dickens. There are also some gas beings masquerading as ghosts and using the recently deceased as meat puppets, and who try to lie their way into inhabiting the dead of Earth as asylum seekers from a war.

Firsts and Lasts

It's the first time the new Doctor travels into the past (at least on screen), and the first time the new-look TARDIS doesn't go exactly where he wants it to go. It's the first "celebrity historical" story, in which the Doctor meets a famous historical figure; from now on there'll be one of these each season: next year it's Queen Victoria in X2.2, Tooth and Claw, and in 2007 the Doctor finally meets Shakespeare in X3.2, The Shakespeare Code. It's also the first time Lawrence Miles goes completely batshit crazy about the new series; see The Lore. It's also the first - but sadly not the last - instance of the Doctor "solving the crisis" by blowing everything up, though technically it was Dickens and Gwyneth on this occasion, so it's also the first instance of the Doctor not solving things himself (and there'll be plenty of that, arguably, this series). We're also introduced to the Cardiff Rift, which returns in X1.11, Boomtown, and plays a major part in Torchwood.

Things to Notice About The Unquiet Dead

  1. The Gelth are an intriguing race; not only have they been transformed from normal corporeal beings into entities of living gas, but they are handily colour-coded, turning from blue to red as soon as they reveal they are truly evil.

The Continuity

The Doctor

He's a Dickens fan, and acts like a big ol' fanboy when he meets him, though he stops short of asking for an autograph.

Inventory

Ethics

The Doctor doesn't see any problem with using the bodies of deceased humans to house the bodiless Gelth, and grows quite angry with Rose when she finds the idea difficult to accept. He's also not worried about changing the Earth's history when Rose points out that Victorian England wasn't inhabited by alien corpse-thieves.

Background

The Doctor hasn't met Dickens before.

Rose

Rose's knowledge of history is spotty; she doesn't realise her current clothes would cause a stir in the 19th century, but is able to pick out an appropriate dress from the TARDIS wardrobe. She's disappointed to find out they're in Cardiff, and clearly doesn't think Wales is much chop as a holiday destination.

The TARDIS

Not as reliable as it seemed last trip; here it's nine years and thousands of miles off-target, and the Doctor doesn't know this until he exits. [Does the scanner show the wrong location, or does he just not check? His confidence in being able to pilot the Ship doesn't waver because of this mistake or subsequent ones, and no reason is given for the error.]

History

Charles Dickens is giving his usual Christmas Eve performance of "A Christmas Carol"; in 1869, he's in Cardiff. He finds himself embroiled in the Doctor's activities only because one of the Gelth takes its animated corpse to the performance, then escapes at a dramatic moment. We get our first indication that history isn't what it used to be when the Doctor tells Rose that history is in flux and nothing is safe.

The War

The Gelth claim to be casualties of the Time War, somehow losing their corporeal forms as a result of hostilities. They suggest they are innocents, and certainly don't name or claim to be allies of either side.

The Time Lords

Are all gone - but not forgotten, as Jabe from the Forest of Cheem knows of them, though she considers them extinct and that it is impossible one of them still exists. [That they are remembered perhaps indicates that the Time Lords were destroyed in a "conventional" way, rather than being erased from time. On the other hand, Jabe considers that the Doctor "should not exist", so either they were supposedly erased from history, becoming nothing but a story, or their destruction occurred so long ago that it is inconceivable that even a Time Lord would still be alive in the year 5 billion - though that would mean time travel is still considered mostly impossible. There's a lot on this, so see What really happened to the Time Lords?]

The Arc Word

Bad Wolf: Gwynneth sees pictures that frighten her in Rose's mind, including the "Big Bad Wolf". It's the only time the traditional version of the phrase is used.

The Analysis

Where does this come from?

Like most productions that Mark Gatiss is involved in, The Unquiet Dead has many fathers. Most of them are pretty easy to spot, but for those of you at the back, Gatiss is never happier than when he's riffing on old Hammer movies, Nigel Kneale's TV serials, and their eventual distillation in Letts/Hinchcliffe era Doctor Who. The often-unintentional camp of those productions has also been knowingly transplanted, and the result is a story that wouldn't be out of place in a League of Gentlemen Christmas Special. It's the blatant allusiveness that really gives this impression, and this is a product of the Rise of the Geek in 21st Century Media. Shaun of the Dead is another obvious example in which Generation X-ers lovingly take their childhood obsessions and replay them from a more modern point of view, and JJ Abrams' work on Alias does roughly the same thing to the spy genre.

As in so much media culture of the last fifteen years, it's Quentin Tarantino that fathered this school of postmodern remixing, setting the template in his first two movies Reservoir Dogs and (more overtly) Pulp Fiction. Although he obviously had antecedents, not least a certain Steven Spielberg, Tarantino was the first filmmaker to happily identify himself as a geek cineaste. Where the similarly voracious Scorsese would talk of films like Contempt or The Red Shoes influencing his work, Tarantino would talk about Joel Silver action movies or Italian zombie flicks. Based on his success, low culture was suddenly ripe territory for subversion and knowing references. It all ended in meaningless self-parody of course, but something as allusive and self-aware as The Unquiet Dead follows basically the same course that Tarantino pioneered with his tough guys talking about Madonna's big dick. Even the pop culture references that now seem so indelibly Tarantino-esque ("You'll cause a riot Barbarella") are present and correct.

And now for the controversial bit. Bearing in mind the original co-author of the About Time series, it's almost impossible not to look at the influence of politics on The Unquiet Dead. Lawrence Miles created a storm of protest when he pointed out the regressive attitudes towards asylum seekers that Gatiss seems to be proposing (see The Lore), but most of that storm really seemed to be driven by the fact that he called the latter a "thoughtless halfwit". Naturally many Doctor Who fans prefer to view their favourite show as above politics, and there's been a long-standing suspicion of writers like Miles who try to point out its influence. It doesn't mean it's not there of course (one would hardly be writing a section called "Where Does This Come From?" if it weren't), but it does mean that if you say that stories like The Happiness Patrol might be about more than a walking liquorice allsort then you'll have some kind of fight on your hands.

The problem for those who seek to deny the asylum-seeker subtext is that it isn't even a subtext at all: it's smack-you-between-your-apolitical-eyes text. The Gelth explicitly refer to themselves as asylum seekers from a war, and their (admittedly jokey) identification as "foreigners" cannot help but underline the influences on Gatiss' story. Asylum seekers (and more importantly to The Unquiet Dead, their ability to integrate into society) have always been an issue bubbling under the surface, particularly in a historically war-torn place like Europe, and even more particularly in a first world country like the UK. In the last ten years alone we've seen Blair's bombing of Kosovo to alleviate the plight of refugees, and more recently the Coalition of the Willing's attacks on Afghanistan and Iraq has only increased the number of people displaced by war. It's debatable whether Gatiss was really interested in making a political point (indeed he most probably latched onto Davies' Time War notion simply to facilitate another one of his ghost stories), but the textual evidence suggests that it wasn't entirely absent from his thinking.

Things that Don’t Make Sense

Filling the house with gas removes the Gelth from the corpses like "sucking poison from a wound". Er...why? The Gelth presumably have a density similar to that of the natural gas used to light the lamps, but equally they're presumably not flammable or they'd all be burned to death whenever someone lit a light in the house. This is contradicted, though, by the Gelth seen by Dickens to be sucked into a gas lamp, though it's by no means certain why or what happens to that Gelth.

The main problem is it's never made clear whether they are gaseous themselves, or whether they are merely consciousnesses which can control the natural gas, perhaps in a manner similar to the Nestene control of plastic. Even if that's true, there's no reason why flooding the house with gas would cause them to leave the bodies, and this explanation seems entirely extraneous to the real solution of the problem - blowing up the house full of gas, killing all the Gelth inside and somehow sealing the Rift, at least temporarily. How does an explosion heal a rift in spacetime? [Perhaps it's not the explosion itself, but the psychic shock caused by Gwyneth dying while she's holding it open. There's nothing to suggest this, though, beyond it being an excellent idea.]

Critique

The Prosecution

There's a lot to like in The Unquiet Dead, and only a real curmudgeon would really say that there wasn't. The problem is that for all the competence that has gone into making this episode as good as it is, there's still something missing. Part of it is the problems that bedevil all the single episode stories of this season, but The Unquiet Dead stands apart in one respect: it doesn't have any ambition.

Well, that's not strictly true, I suppose. Mark Gatiss is quite open about his ambitions, and even if he wasn't, it's glaringly obvious from his work. Brought to fame by The League of Gentlemen, and also responsible for Doctor Who adventures like Invaders From Mars and Last of the Gadarene, Gatiss is one of those writers that would have died without pastiche. Virtually everything he does is touched by a pathological nostalgia, a yearning not to speak his own words but mimic someone else's. At the beginning of his career, with works like Nightshade this seemed clever. Gatiss seemed capable of that rare trick of using old tropes to tell new stories. It's the sort of thing that the best genre artists excel at--witness Alan Moore's transcendence of his comic book roots for instance, or David Cronenberg's ability to stimulate weird mutations in old horror movie ideas.

Gatiss however seems almost offended at the notion that he might even try. When Nightshade was compared to the works of Clive Barker he appeared to bridle, preferring to pledge allegiance to hoary old warhorses like Quatermass or Hinchcliffe-era Doctor Who. It was as if the notion of being part of a modern movement was anathema, and as his career progressed it became increasingly obvious that he was content to simply rehash old ideas. Consequently, although The League of Gentlemen had many flashes of genius, it was never more than the supreme example of pastiche run riot. More tellingly, the tiredness that set in after the first series seems almost inevitable when one considers Gatiss' career as a whole. Faced with an artist disinterested in generating his own ideas, League was always going to suffer when he ran out of other people's material to riff on.

With this in mind it's almost impossibly apt that The Unquiet Dead story should revolve around the reanimation of the dead. On record about what constitutes 'proper' Doctor Who, it comes as no surprise that Gatiss' story slavishly devotes itself to evoking that notional idea of what the show is supposed to be like. Thus we have the nineteenth century setting, the possession elements, the emphasis on 'spookiness' and scary monsters, not to mention the Doctor inspiring the works of a famous historical figure (well, sort of). It's the kind of story that any fan could do in their sleep, with even the little moments that usually betray an author's signature being swiped from better writers. The Doctor telling Rose that she needs to dress properly echoes Leela's identical beat in Talons, Gwyneth performs the same story function as Granny Tyler, Dickens' theatrical bluster recalls that of Henry Gordon Jago, and Dickens even name-checks Gatiss' Big Finish play Phantasmagoria. Photocopies only get fainter if you use them as your source, and when one realises that Gatiss is pastiching Robert Holmes' pastiche of Conan Doyle it's almost breathtaking to realise just how indistinct his authorial voice has become.

And yet…the story still retains a certain charm. Conan Doyle and even Holmes' work has endured after all, and that means that Gatiss is at least stealing from the best. The problem is that Doctor Who at its best is not about paying homage for the sake of it, but to twist, subvert and, yes, transcend our expectations. Doctor Who was its own thing; a gloriously daft collision of multifarious elements that were renewed every week. It was a show that wasn't comfortable with stagnant storytelling, and remained voracious for the new, the unexplored, and the dangerous. The Talons of Weng Chiang wasn't traditional in 1977--it was at the creative cutting edge. Similarly when Ghost Light returned to similar turf in 1989 it wasn't because 'proper' Doctor Who had a fetish for Victoriana, it was because Marc Platt's story demanded it. Both stories are proudly allusive, but there's far more to them than simply a collection of references assembled for their own sake. Sadly, however, that's all Gatiss has learnt from them. His story has no personality of its own; there's no sense of the writer having anything to say beyond 'here is what Doctor Who should be like'. And frankly why waste your time saying something that inconsequential?

Annoyingly there are hints throughout that Gatiss is capable of better writing, and while cynics might suggest that this is Russell Davies' script doctoring, it's probably best to be charitable. Everything that's good about the episode can be summed up in Sneed's reaction to the marauding zombie-woman in the pre-credit teaser. Rather than run away screaming, his response is simply world-weary flippancy. It's precisely this kind of response that undercuts the musty horror imagery, and while this is hardly new territory for one of the creators of The League of Gentlemen, it does leaven the tediousness of "proper" Doctor Who. The Doctor's rant at Rose about different morality is similarly praiseworthy precisely because it kicks against the kind of attitude Doctor Who normally exhibits. Rather than just get down to exorcising the intruders straight away, the Doctor brings a pleasingly alien perspective to bear on the problem. It's this kind of thing that was all too rare in 'proper' Doctor Who, and when contrasted with the conservative storytelling elsewhere in this episode it stands out all the more.

It's a shame therefore that Gatiss then punks out in the most obvious way possible. It's hard to describe just how hideously pedestrian his imagery feels when the Gelth do the whole angelic-to-demonic thing, but it's easily one of the worst examples of lazy writing in the program's history. It pisses all over the very idea of taking the road less travelled, and even worse it makes the whole moral dilemma merely seem like an excuse to pad out the story. Other early episodes also wrestled with how much story could be crammed into forty-five minutes, but The Unquiet Dead feels particularly superficial precisely because it has nothing to offer beyond it's evocation of the Hinchcliffe era.

And to add insult to injury, the zombies somehow look even sillier than they did thirty years ago. There's progress for you…

The Defence

The Facts

Written by Mark Gatiss. Directed by Euros Lyn. Peak of 8.9 million viewers, y% audience share.

Supporting cast: Simon Callow as Charles Dickens, Alan David as Gabriel Sneed, Huw Rhys as Redpath, Jennifer Hill as Mrs Peace, Eve Myles as Gwyneth, Wayne Cater as the Stage Manager, Meic Povey as the Driver, and Zoe Thorne as The Gelth.

Working Titles:

The Teaser: In the funeral parlour a young man named Redpath grieves over the open casket containing his dead grandmother. Closing his eyes in sorrow, he does not see a blue, glowing vapour wash over the corpse and enter it. The old woman's eyes snap open and she grabs Redpath by the throat, killing him. Gabriel Sneed, the undertaker, rushes in and tries to close the lid on the reanimated corpse but she knocks him unconscious to the floor before getting up and wandering out onto the street, wailing.

Cliffhangers: None.

The Lore

  • Lawrence Miles hated this one on first viewing, and within an hour of broadcast posted a rant on his web site about the political subtext of the Gelth as asylum seekers who are not innocent but evil, out to exploit liberal generosity (in the form of the Doctor). He was particularly damning of Mark Gatiss, and the Internet community - or that section of it which was aware of him - rallied in Gatiss' defence. Miles edited the review soon after, removing the personal jibes and conceding that the subtext was probably unintentional, but he still felt it should have been detected and edited out of the script. The original review is no longer available; it was replaced with the words: "Go away. I'm thinking about it."


Doctor Who Series One Episodes

Rose · The End of the World · The Unquiet Dead · Aliens of London / World War Three · Dalek · The Long Game
Father's Day · The Empty Child / The Doctor Dances · Boomtown · Bad Wolf / The Parting of the Ways · Children in Need 2005