The Long Game
| X1.7 - “The Long Game” | ||||
| Doctor Who Series 1, Episode 7, 7 May, 2005 | ||||
| Featuring the Ninth Doctor with Rose Tyler and Adam Mitchell | ||||
| Written by Russell T. Davies, directed by Brian Grant, produced by Phil Collinson. | ||||
| “Dalek” | << | “The Long Game” | >> | “Father's Day” |
Which One is This?
Frankly, it's the one with Simon Pegg and Tamsin Greig in it.
Firsts and Lasts
It's the first time we visit Satellite 5, and the rather boring name seems fitting since it's the least interesting outing. It's the first time we're given a hint that the Face of Boe might be important, since he shows up in a brief cameo for the first time, and the first time anyone is kicked out of the TARDIS for bad behaviour (and only the second time someone is made to leave against their will, the other being Susan way back in The Dalek Invasion of Earth).
Things to Notice About The Long Game
- After showing us the year five billion is populated by muppets, trees and human trampolines, Mr. Davies now shows us the year 200,000 - which is populated by people who live down the street. Nothing here is particularly high tech even by today's standards, and compared to most cyberpunk, the "headport" computer interface seems ridiculously primitive, even given the "plot point" of it being so. The "Fourth Great and Bountiful Human Empire" is, therefore, something of a let-down.
- The Doctor continues his trend of not really doing anything to save the day himself by having a guest character do all the work. This week, it's Cathica, a choice presumably meant to surprise us since it's Suki, her fellow journalist, who turns out to be the secret freedom fighter. (She's also one of the billion characters by that name who exist in the works of Russell T. Davies.)
The Continuity
The Doctor
Inventory
Ethics
Background
Rose
The TARDIS
History
The War
The Time Lords
The Arc Word
Bad Wolf: One a bank of video screens, "BAD WOLF TV" features an interview with the Face of Boe, who is apparently pregnant with the "Baby Boemina". [Further complicating the question of who and what he is... see "The Many Faces of Dr. Boe".]
The Analysis
Where does this come from?
As with most Russell T Davies episodes, most of the SF influences are hovering somewhere in between "iconic" and "hideously clichéd". In particular, it's almost impossible to talk about "The Long Game" without mentioning Blade Runner, or indeed cyberpunk in general . Refining the "used space" aesthetic of Alien, Ridley Scott's android noir has become the default image of how we think of the future, most specifically in its devotion to clutter. Rejecting the usual white corridors and silver jumpsuits, Blade Runner is dirty, steamy, and its characters wear a hodgepodge of fashions from the past. "The Long Game" is admittedly a slightly cleaner version of this, but when comparing the Doctor's utopian prediction with the kronkburgers, the steam and the "stunted" people that bustle around Satellite 5, Scott's influence is undeniable.
More important though is cyberpunk's traditional obsession with the media. The obvious tropes are the ports in everyone's forehead, but the "punk" part of "cyberpunk" is arguably more significant. Put simply, there's often something wrong with the mass media in this particular subgenre, and cyberpunk's heroes are those that strive to tear down the virtual wall that hides The Truth. This Truth might be a corporate cover-up, evil military experiments or even the nature of reality itself, but bringing it to light inevitably brings the cyberpunks into conflict with The Man-- Big Media, Big Money or Big Government. Given this, it's interesting to note that cyberpunk really began to flower in the soil that had been turned over by late 1970s cinema. Paranoia became fashionable post-Watergate, with films like The Parallax View and All the President's Men depicting crusading journalists struggling to expose vast establishment conspiracies. Cyberpunk's heroes tended to be more marginalised (it’s hard to be a punk and work for the Washington Post after all), but it's no accident that "The Long Game" is about the Doctor reawakening the spirit of Woodward and Bernstein.
However, just as "World War Three" uses the trappings of Invasion of the Bodysnatchers to lampoon the Blair government, "The Long Game" uses cyberpunk to attack Rupert Murdoch. Admittedly some commentators have tried to read against the authorial grain of the story, suggesting that it is just as damning of the liberal media as it is Fox News. By these lights, the Jagrafess embodies The Media In General, or possibly even the nest of communists at the BBC. The problem is that this interpretation doesn't really match the story terribly well. Leaving aside the fact that Davies has already nailed his ideological colours to the mast, the atmosphere of Satellite 5 has unmistakable Murdochian overtones. Part of this impression comes from the little details. Cathica talks about immigration tightening up to keep out "aliens", something NewsCorp would certainly approve of, whether it's The Sun in the UK, The Herald-Sun in Australia or Fox News in the US. Similarly, the Editor's cry of "gotcha" when he identifies Suki echoes The Sun's xenophobic reaction to the sinking of the Argentinean cruiser General Belgrano.
But it's in the broad strokes that Davies' target truly reveals itself. Murdoch is comparatively unique because of the sheer size of his media empire, not to mention the fact that he has such Jagrafess-like direct control. An organisation like the BBC just doesn't have the global reach enjoyed by NewsCorp, and "The Long Game" explicitly states that it is Satellite 5's six hundred channels that have made it so powerful. Moreover, the Doctor berates Cathica for her failure to investigate the vague "threats" that have contributed to the "climate of fear" holding back Earth's development. Given that Murdoch's media outlets were enthusiastic fear-mongers before the invasion of Iraq, given that they were in ideological lockstep (every single one of his 175 newspapers ran pro-war editorials), and given that he is one of the few media magnates capable of promulgating this opinion to a global audience, the parallel becomes inescapable.
The Editor's boasting eradicates any shadow of a doubt, stating that, "the right word in the right broadcast repeated often enough can destabilise an economy, invent an enemy, change a vote". Now although it's possible to overstate Murdoch's influence , he's certainly been accused of all three distortions, and occasionally his minions brag openly about their bias (one of the most memorable being the "It Was The Sun Wot Won It" headline following the Tory's re-election in 1993). Furthermore, it's also fair to say that Murdoch is now the most famous media magnate, particularly magnates that are accused of deliberate political bias. Conservatives might grumble about the BBC or Ted Turner, but neither are as instantly recognisable as Murdoch, and nor are they famous enough to warrant entire documentaries such as Outfoxed: Rupert Murdoch's War on Journalism. The bottom line is that juss it's difficult to appreciate the look of "The Long Game" without citing Blade Runner, it's all but impossible to understand the themes of "The Long Game" without acknowledging Murdoch's shadow.
Right. Now we've got all the obvious stuff out of the way, it's worth getting around to mentioning Farscape. Davies might cite Buffy as his touchstone, but it scarcely needs pointing out that Doctor Who 2.0's overall tone and sense of design only rarely feels like Sunnydale. The clearest debt is the sheer creative giddiness that Farscape exemplified. Eschewing the beige-and-bumpy-heads school of SF design, the people and environments on Farscape were always a mix of the sublime and the ridiculous. Most obviously, both shows have their heroes travelling in a living ship, but where the TARDIS always used to look like something technological, these days its coral-like design bears a clear resemblance to the interior of Moya. Likewise the kronkburgers and fashions of "The Long Game" recalls the weirdly plebeian Farscape universe, and there is an echo of Pilot in both the Jagrafess' determinedly non-human design and the fact that it has been installed into a stationary position of command.
The real connection though is in the approach to generic material. Buffy was certainly an irreverent show, but it was also a program that was made for an audience of fifteen and over. By contrast, Farscape was pitched a lot closer to the juvenile end of the market, and although it became progressively darker, the show never lost its sense of child-like exuberance. John Crichton was just as willing to take the piss out of genre clichés as the Scooby Gang, and Farscape never forgot that alongside the opportunity to do space wars, science fiction also provides unique ways to do gross-out comedy. One can't see the Slitheen parping away without thinking of Rygel farting helium at moments of stress, and Cassandra's joy upon beaming into Rose's bouncy castle recalls Crichton's reaction when bodyswapped with Aeryn.
The interesting thing is that although neither the new series nor Farscape is strictly for children, it's this willingness to embrace the things that kids actually do laugh at that seems to revolutionise the Doctor Who format. Famously, this was a show in which no one went to the toilet, and similarly no one burped, farted or vomited. These days, all of these things are unabashedly on display, and it's doubtful that this would be the case without shows like Farscape and Buffy as forerunners . Previously if the show had shown someone like Adam being implanted with alien technology there's little doubt that it would have been played straight. Someone like Robert Holmes might have hinted at the comedy potential of a sound-activated implant in someone's forehead, and it's just about possible that he might have written the scene of finger-clicking comeuppance at story's end. But even Holmes would have never given us Adam's vomit-o-matic joke, and when considered alongside the farting Slitheen and spitting Moxx of Balhoon, it's clear that Buffy is not the only telefantasy series that Davies is willing to steal from.
Things that Don’t Make Sense
Critique
The Prosecution
Fanboys will tell you there are all sorts of problems with "The Long Game", but the thing they always seem to miss is the fact that it doesn't really mean anything. In part, this is because most fanboys have an excellent grasp of how to criticise Doctor Who, but very few of them are able to criticise drama (as if to prove my point, as I type this there are fans arguing that even when Who is bad it's better than anything else on TV--there are intelligent, considered reactions to such a claim, but the most satisfying is simply "fuck off"). Thus when Russell T Davies dismisses much of the criticism of his work as fannish and asserts that his strengths include a commitment to 'proper drama', it is maddening that no one seems willing to fight him on the turf he stipulates. To the fans, "The Long Game" fails because it's dull. They might home in on some of the symptoms of dramatic laziness--the overuse of the sonic screwdriver for example--but that's because they're the sorts of viewers who care about the sonic screwdriver in the first place. But to anyone with a wider viewpoint, "The Long Game" fails for a far more serious reason. Ironically, it fails because it is conspicuously free of the 'proper drama' that Davies claims as his specialty.
Part of the reason for this can be attributed to simple imaginative fatigue. Doctor Who was always a show with an astonishing voracity for new ideas, but the modern version chews through them twice as fast. The result is that when Davies is forced to create so many new environments and dramatic situations, there is going to come a time when he simply runs out of ideas. "The Long Game" is his fifth (official) episode, and the first that could arguably be described as routine. By now, the originality he demonstrated in his earlier episodes has all but evaporated, and he begins settling for off-the-peg SF clichés. Thus "The Long Game" is all generic space stations and characters able to jack themselves into the media. It could be that the high concept ideas just aren't high enough this time, but after the sense of wonder that infused all the TARDIS' previous destinations, this one feels…unremarkable. Adam might faint, but then, he's not the viewer identification figure--Rose is, and like her, we've basically seen this all before. Satellite Five looks and sounds pretty much like Platform One, and although there might be less aliens and different modifications to the human characters, the only really new material is the jokey details.
Of course this wouldn't matter if Davies had some outré elements to contrast with the ordinary ones, but he doesn't. The real giveaway is Simon Pegg's performance as the Editor. A typical Doctor Who villain on paper with all his surveillance cameras and sadistic gloating, Pegg manages to salvage something simply by refusing to take the character seriously. He's looking for the most interesting reading of each line rather than playing them as they're intended, and while this doesn't always work, it's certainly unpredictable. Unfortunately however he can't really rewrite his character's Evil Plan, and so the clapped out old storyline of The Media Is Untrustworthy is wheeled out for another airing. It's a sobering thought to think that well over half a century has elapsed since the publication of Nineteen Eighty-Four, and although the idea of all-pervasive media organisations was given a shot in the arm by the cyberpunk movement, "The Long Game" merely steals imagery from both without retaining the resonance of either.
Even with all this to drag it down, the story still might have amounted to something if it was infused with any genuine passion. After all, "World War Three" is basically rehashing Invasion of the Bodysnatchers, but there was still a sense that Davies was making a deeply felt political point. By contrast, "The Long Game" makes all the predictable dystopian noises, but fails to give us anything to be terribly angry about. It tells us repeatedly that the manipulation of the media is a bad thing, but without any visceral examples to illustrate this thesis it's difficult to care. The Doctor worries about the stunting effect that Satellite Five has had on human history, but as it bears so little resemblance to our own we cannot really measure the impact of his claims. Likewise, Suki's confrontation with the Editor feels like a teaser rather than something meaningful, and the overall effect of his villainy is too abstract to really register on a gut level. Consequently, like the Jagrafess itself, the story makes a lot of noise but is never remotely dangerous.
Basically the worst thing about "The Long Game" is that it marks the point where Doctor Who stops being an event for both audience and showrunner, and settles into being something ordinary. It's an efficient enough package of all the bits that usually work, but while there are faint compensations (the design concept of the Jagrafess or the Suki double bluff for instance) it's just not special any more. By this stage there's no doubt that the show has been successfully relaunched, but this is also the first time we feel the chill of mortality. The showrunner demonstrates that his imagination has its limits, and we realise that for all the ratings success and critical plaudits, laziness can still bring Doctor Who undone. Whatever Russell T Davies might say, "The Long Game" is a story with no hero, no dramatic throughline, and most importantly no heart. And that certainly doesn't sound like proper drama to me.
The Defence
The Facts
Written by Russell T. Davies. Directed by Brian Grant. Peak of 8.0 million viewers, y% audience share.
Supporting cast:
Working Titles:
The Teaser: The Doctor and Rose emerge from the TARDIS to find themselves in a near future museum filled with alien curios - including a slitheen's arm, and the head of a Cyberman. The Doctor, full of nostalgia, touches a case and sets off an alarm - and they are immediately surrounded by a squad of heavily armed guards.
Cliffhangers: None.
The Lore
- The DVD commentary reveals that a more benign motivation for Adam - trying to find a future cure for a disease that afflicted his father - was cut from the episode.