The Empty Child
| X1.9 - “The Empty Child” (1) | ||||
| Doctor Who Series 1, Episode 9, May 21st, 2005 | ||||
| Featuring the Ninth Doctor with Rose Tyler and Jack Harkness | ||||
| Written by Steven Moffat, directed by James Hawes, produced by Phil Collinson. | ||||
| “Father's Day” | << | “The Empty Child” | >> | “The Doctor Dances” |
Which One is This?
"Are you my Mummy?" "No, but I had sex with your father." Yes, it's the one that had kids and adults wetting their pants, but for different reasons.
Firsts and Lasts
Welcome to Doctor Who, Steven Moffat style: seriously scary stuff, crackling dialogue, feisty young female protagonists and a fixation with bananas. Oh, and of course the walking id Captain Jack Harkness; we'll be seeing a lot of him from now on. This is also the first Doctor Who story to be set during the London Blitz, and only the second to take place during World War II (the first being The Curse of Fenric). Not counting Grace: 1999's "cloaking device", we also have the first direct reference to Star Trek.
Two Things to Notice About The Empty Child
- There is no mistaking this for the work of any man except Steven Moffat: indeed, for viewers of his other work, particularly Press Gang and Coupling, this seems oddly familiar, though in a good way. Nancy has the balls of Lynda Day, Jack makes cracks worthy of Spike Thompson and Rose and the Doctor exchange banter that wouldn't look out of place in the Coupling bar. Even Dr Constantine gets to sound cool, with lines of a standard usually employed only for the Doctor.
- .
The Continuity
The Doctor
Shows disdain for Rose's desire for "Spock", preferring to simply ask about the cylinder rather than "scan for alien tech". He is still surprised that his companions wander off when he tells them not to, which is supposedly the only thing that still surprises him after "900 years of phone box travel" [see also How Old Is He Now?], but is almost immediately surprised by the TARDIS's police box phone ringing. He feels comfortable around children. He's clearly impressed by Nancy, and also expresses admiration for the British people.
Inventory
He uses the psychic paper (as does Jack). The sonic screwdriver is able to provide medical information.
Ethics
Feels the need to chase the cylinder because it's marked mauve [the fact that it's going to hit London seems less important to him, as he only mentions it when Rose needs a reason to care]. He thinks Nancy's scheme of stealing food from houses abandoned during air raids is "brilliant" and is happy to join in the feast. [It's unclear if he's aware that she's stealing from someone who's clearly got more than his fair ration, but given the cleverness and anarchic nature of her plan he probably likes the idea regardless.]
Background
The Supporting Cast
Rose -
Jack - "Captain" Jack Harkness is an ex-Time Agent from the 51st century. He left the Agency when they erased some of his memories, and now travels through time in a stolen Chula timeship, conning money and possibly information out of real Time Agents. He has an American accent and is heavily sexually charged, making advances towards both Rose and an RAF pilot. Underneath this, however, he's all business, and it's not until he realises his con has caused the "disease" that he starts to show real concern. As well as his spaceship, which has a sexy computer voice, a tractor beam, "active camouflage" (it's invisible) and a supply of nanogenes, he also possesses Star Wars style electronic binoculars, a remote control device that can control Big Ben, psychic paper and his wrist band, which can teleport him [this is probably a function of the vortex manipulator]. His con is to send an anachronistic object (e.g. the cylinder) through the Vortex into history, hoping a Time Agent will notice it and show up to find it. He then claims it's something far more valuable than it really is (e.g. a Chula warship), and demands payment to reveal its location - which he does, but only just before its destroyed by an historical event (e.g. a German bombing raid or the eruption of Vesuvius). [This plan is, more or less, a Thing That Doesn't Make Sense.]
The TARDIS
The Non-Humans
Planet Notes
History
The Analysis
Where does this come from?
Enter Steven Moffat. Like you could have missed him.
More than any of his fellow writers, Steven Moffat's episodes mark one of the truly unmistakable moments where Doctor Who is noticeably authored, and this makes it impossible to talk about “The Empty Child” without acknowledging his previous work. We've touched on Coupling in the Critique section, and that's because it's probably the quintessential Moffat-ish work. Set in the milieu of thirtysomethings looking for love (but mostly sex), Coupling is an almost neurotically flirty series. In Moffat's world the war of the sexes is still very much a hot one, and each episode is like a dispatch from the front line. Thus, while there have been nods towards sex in new-skool Doctor Who, “The Empty Child” is comparatively drenched in subtle and not-so-subtle innuendo.
Obviously a lot of this is down to the entrance of Captain Jack (like you could have missed him either). Jack, like Moffat, warps the very nature of the show around himself, and although initially sketched out by Davies, it's easy to see hints of earlier Moffat characters such as Jane in Coupling or even Spike (complete with a similarly brash American accent) from Press Gang in his unapologetic sexual voracity. In a similar vein, Moffat also has a predilection for bossy, no-nonsense women. “The Doctor Dances” reveals that Nancy is older than she looks, but her age, her tart command of the other kids and her self-possession can't help but remind one of Lynda Day. Indeed Press Gang casts a longer shadow over this story than we might reasonably expect. Although nominally a children's show, Press Gang tackled a lot of stuff (teen suicide, child abuse, journalistic ethics) that we don't expect to see in a late-afternoon timeslot. There were adult characters, but their overall low profile helped to create an atmosphere of kids being self-reliant, even in situations where they should be a long way out of their depth. Intriguingly, in Moffat's first draft Nancy does have adult help, but her secret is complicated by the fact that her husband is German. The absence of this character from the broadcast version strengthens the kids-are-doing-it-for-themselves vibe, and although you might argue the Doctor's presence compensates (many of his story beats were originally handled by Nancy's husband), his behaviour in the dinner-table scene makes it obvious that he's an honorary kid.
It's also no accident that Moffat's script cites The Singing Detective as an example of the tone it's going for. One of Potter's first descriptions of London in Detective's screenplay is that it should look “thriller-ish”, delineating the fantasy world of film noir from the more prosaic reality that dominates the bulk of the story. “The Empty Child” isn't attempting a similar kind of contrast, but it's obviously going for the same kind of generic historical evocation. Thus we're presented with the idea that it might be romatic to dance by the light of the Blitz, the urchins are explicitly compared to a West End musical, and there's an overall lack of gritty realism.
A further classy influence is Stephen Poliakoff's Perfect Strangers (no, not the series starring Bronson Pinchot—go and wash your mouth out). Also starring Michael Gambon and also picking obsessively at hidden pain, Perfect Strangers is set during a modern-day family reunion. Some of the comparisons are probably coincidental; both stories deal with a character being erased from an “official” family history for instance, but it's worth remembering that Moffat is basically writing a horror movie, and, from Jane Eyre to Ringu, the horror genre has always derived fuel from family secrets. However it is Poliakoff's inclusion of the strange-but-true fact that Blitz-era children sometimes formed survival gangs that is the true tell-tale. The emphasis is obviously different; “The Empty Child” is a resolutely urban story whereas the children in Perfect Strangers are making their way through the countryside. Nor is this storyline really at the core of Poliakoff's story (he also inexplicably fails to work in a time-active bisexual con-man), but it's this idea of dislocated children, adopted family groups and the attempts to exorcise those family members that have become undesirable (witness Nancy desperately insisting to Jamie that “he's dead”) that form the backbone of both stories.
However, like so many other stories of this year, it's hard not to be reminded of more contemporary wars. The key line is where Jamie follow up his usual “are you my mummy?” catchphrase with “I'm frightened of the bombs.” “The Empty Child” would have been written immediately after, or thereabouts, the invasion of Iraq. That's not to say that Moffat consciously intended to use the Blitz as some kind of crude allegory of what the citizens of Baghdad had to endure, but it's the use of bombs as a motif throughout this episode that make the connection hard to ignore. We aren't told explicitly in this episode, but it's the objects that fall from the sky that drive this story, and the empty child is a walking example of one of the Pentagon's favourite euphemisms: collateral damage. It may be a coincidence that Jack is an American airman and that it is his own “bombing” of London that creates the situation, but given that his Americanness does seem a little shoehorned in otherwise, at the very least it's an uncomfortable bit of serendipity.
In a similar vein, Moffat's use of the imagery of the Blitz has a strong resemblances to the way Guillermo del Toro deploys the Spanish Civil War in The Devil's Backbone. Both stories begin with the dropping a bomb, and it's only after it has landed that we're introduced to the environment reshaped by the bomb's arrival. Both stories use their respective wars more as a backdrop rather than as clear and present dangers, but there's a constant tension that the frontlines could shift centre-stage at any moment. One of the ways del Toro achieves this tension is through the image of an unexploded bomb resting in the courtyard of the orphanage that is The Devil's Backbone's principal setting. No one thinks it necessary to remove this bomb, and while it never explodes during the story, it still looms over the narrative as both a plot point and a thematic metaphor. While less directly devastating than Jack's “bomb that isn't a bomb”, both stories extend outwards from their respective “blast areas”, and both are driven by the ghost of a wounded little boy. Most crucially, both stories are very much about what it's like to survive in a war zone when you're an orphaned child. The adult characters are still important to the narrative, but it's to the children that the ghosts created by the war seem most attracted, and it is they that seem to have the best handle on what's going on. The result of all this, particularly when taken alongside the genric period flavour that Moffat is seeking to evoke, is to create the atmosphere of a dark wartime fairy-tale. Neither del Toro's nor Moffat's ghost children are standard horror story monsters, and both of them are laid to rest when someone is smart enough to figure out who they are and what they want. The upshot is that we're not talking cardboard Daleks or slasher psychos here; this is something that feels different.
Right. Now for the geekier stuff. Once again Sapphire and Steel rears its head. As we've already touched upon, the imagery of children with power is a well-mined seam in horror fiction, but the distinctive look of this particular little boy lost and the general weirdness of the situation evokes a similar kind of surrealist atmosphere. More specific is the way Moffat manages to turn childish catchphrases into something naggingly creepy. Sapphire and Steel's first adventure is slightly atypical in that it features children in leading roles (it's clear in hindsight that the production team were a little unsure of exactly what age group they should be targeting), but the series continually used objects, games and phrases that children could identify with, and that first adventure's use of nursery rhymes feels like a direct precursor to “are you my mummy?”
It's also interesting to note how the introduction of Captain Jack tilts the regulars' characterisation into a very Sapphire and Steel-ish dynamic. Jack's mischievousness, his flirtiness with his female co-star, and most particularly his technical skills feel a lot like David Collings' portrayal of Silver. Moreover his arrival merely underlines just how like Steel Christopher Eccleston's Doctor can be. Throughout Sapphire and Steel there's a clear delineation between the leads, with the latter being considerably less human and more ruthless in achieving his objectives than the former. Eccleston generally gives a slightly warmer performance than did David McCallum, but there's a strong accent on his lack of humanity in this incarnation, and his War-damaged psyche lends him the rudeness and ruthlessness that now seems such a defining characteristic. Rose, by contrast, is a lot less aristocratic than Joanna Lumley's Sapphire, but it's still interesting that she has a lot of the same character beats. Clearly the good cop to Eccleston's bad, she's more patient, more caring, and often functions as the conscience he occasionally neglects.
Finally, and this is only going to get more frequent, we can't really get away without mentioning Doctor Who. More than any other episode of the new series, “The Empty Child” feels like a race memory of how Doctor Who is supposed to work (people basically mean Phillip Hinchcliffe's stuff when they discuss archetypal Doctor Who, and the cliched shorthand for Hinchcliffe was that he was always doing scary stuff set at night. The reality's obviously a lot more complex than that, but the myth is what we're talking about here). Perhaps the most recognisably Hinchcliffe-ian trope (aside from the fifty-first century Time Agent obviously) is the empty child himself. Hinchcliffe certainly wasn't averse to a bit of latex action, but it's notable that his era of series saw a move away from the man-in-a-rubber-mask default monster. Instead, from the Wirrn through to Li H'sen Chang, people in Hinchcliffe stories were repeatedly possessed by men-in-rubber-masks. The possession might involve a degree of physical change, but more often than not this was eschewed, creating the double whammy of an extremely cheap effect that was undeniably uncanny. It's a very surrealist idea to mix the extraordinary with the everyday, and in its concentration on a spooky little boy turned into a faceless monster by a simple mask, “The Empty Child” is learning from the lessons of “The Masque of Mandragora” and even the Kaled soldiers in “Genesis of the Daleks”.
Things that Don’t Make Sense
Critique
By now “The Empty Child” has settled into being one of those Doctor Who stories with A Reputation. You probably know what I mean without even really thinking about it, but if you don't, it's best explained by saying that the quintessential story with A Reputation is “The Talons of Weng-Chiang”. Like that story, “The Empty Child” only seems to gain in stature as the years go by, and with the possible exception of “Blink”, it now feels like the pre-eminent example of what 21st Century Doctor Who does best. Upon refreshing our acquaintance with it, the reasons for its popularity are all fairly obvious. For a start, although it might sound a touch condescending, there's a lot of night shooting in this story, and this time Keith Boak isn't around to cock it up. The result is a stylishly dark atmosphere that feels a lot like the notional Doctor Who fans are pre-conditioned to appreciate. Add to this the “Talons”-style romanticisation of one of history's greatest hits, not to mention the new series' first genuinely iconic monster and the story's place in the firmament is assured. Even if it hadn't underlined it all by name-checking Time Agents, it's blatantly obvious that this episode is pure fan-nip.
What's really interesting though is how Steven Moffat writes something that could only be part of the reimagined Doctor Who and yet manages to beat Russell T. Davies at his own game. Davies was insistent on pushing the format beyond its usual boundaries, and one of his clearest legacies is the emphasis on the show being funny rather than merely witty. The program has often struggled to mix comedy and high melodrama, and it's telling that this emphasis on the funny was only attempted after Buffy the Vampire Slayer demonstrated to Davies how it could be done. When shows like this work they're usually the best thing on television. When they don't, the result is... well, “Aliens of London”. This is not to imply that there were no successful comedy-dramatic moments before Moffat arrived—the Doctor confronting the Slitheen in “World War Three” walks the line beautifully, for instance—but it's not until “The Empty Child” that the comedy was so laugh-out-loud funny and the scary bits so genuinely eerie. Obviously having a half-decent director helps enormously, and James Hawes' juggling of the script's varying tones is no small achievement. But at bottom the key to “The Empty Child's” success is the work of a gifted writer. Comedy and horror are the two hardest genres to pull off, and it is only when Moffat does it so effortlessly that we can see just how well Davies' vision can work.
Furthermore this is one of the first episodes to really to deliver truly widescreen Doctor Who. The show has a long tradition of telling us about astonishing images rather than simply showing us, and where this might once have been excused on the grounds of budget, it's surprising how often the new show falls back on the same tactic. We'd already seen Davies do the best version of his “oh the sights I've seen” speech (the Doctor's bit about feeling the turn of the Earth in “Rose”), and later attempts rarely defied the law of diminishing returns. In contrast, although it's been mentioned that Phil Collinson blanched when he read the sentence “Rose, hanging from a barrage balloon, faces the incoming Luftwaffe bombers over the London skyline”, “The Empty Child” still manages to deliver one of the series' few awe-inspiringly mental visuals. It may be that we'll look back at this in thirty years and the CGI will feel much the same as CSO does now, but often in special effects it's the image rather than the execution that really counts. For all its prominence in the series trailers, the spaceship smashing into Big Ben feels like a generic, post-Emmerich eye-candy, and likewise similar budget-straining setpieces like the Auton rampage or even the destruction of the Earth don't feel as unique as they should. Indeed it's telling that one of the series' few other sequences that challenge the audacity of this image arrives mere minutes later: she's saved by Captain Jack and then dances on an invisible spaceship tethered to Big Ben. And she does it by the light of the Blitz. You can't see scenes like this on Battlestar Galactica, and that's a brilliant advertisement for why “The Empty Child” is quintessential Doctor Who.
Better still, the episode manages to casually breeze over the program's usual potholes. Nancy's character is inextricably welded to the story's narrative, and although we won't realise it until the next episode, everything she does is furthering the story. Similarly it's astonishing how Eccleston's scene with Dr Constantine manages to rattle through so much exposition with such verve and yet still remain profoundly spooky. When viewed dispassionately, Constantine is one of Doctor Who's oldest standbys: the breathing information dispenser. However in less than five minutes we are fascinated, sympathetic and more than a little unsettled by this man, and both Eccleston and Richard Wilson pitch their performances perfectly. Of course it helps that the central concept powering Moffat's storyline is so intriguing. Few lines have the cherishable strangeness of Constantine's “Physical symptoms as plague”, and the final payoff when it comes effortlessly takes the story to another level. Not only do we have possibly the scariest moment in the show's history as Constantine succumbs to the gas mask disease, but we suddenly begin to put together so many apparently unrelated story threads.
There is the occasional scratch on the paintwork. Moffat's authorial voice is so strong that every now and then it swamps the series, with Rose and Jack often sounding like they've wandered in from Coupling. Also, if we're honest, the wealth of quotable lines only makes the duff ones seem even clumsier by comparison. Jack's riff on “excellent bottoms” sounds oddly forced (it feels a bit like someone trying to find a novel way of saying “nice arse” and not quite getting there), and Rose's panicky outburst in the tractor beam doesn't ring true either. On a more serious level, the Doctor's hymn to the Blitz spirit sticks in the craw of anyone who knows more than the basics about World War 2. Yes, the Londoners' resilience during the Blitz was admirable, and yes the UK did manage to bring Hitler's blitzkrieg to a halt (Russia also stood up to a Nazi invasion in 1941, but presumably either the non-aggression pact with Hitler hasn't been broken by the time of “The Empty Child”, or more likely Moffat didn't want to be adding subclauses to the Doctor's channelling of Churchill). However to attribute Hitler's defeat to the plucky idiosyncrasies of “one damp little island's” inhabitants feels more than a little jingoistic. It's not as if most of the European countries that the Wehrmacht were “rolling up” didn't say “no” (indeed, to be precise about the dialogue, it was probably “no, no, no, NO AARRRGH!”), and they also had the misfortune to face Hitler's armies when they were a) fresh, b) not fighting a war on two fronts, and c) not behind the handy natural barrier most Londoners call “the English Channel”.
But this is really nitpicking. At his first time at bat, and following some very hard-hitting competition from the likes of Rob Shearman and Paul Cornell, Steven Moffat shows everyone how Doctor Who should be done. His jokes are funny, his monsters are scary, and he even manages to make the Doctor answer the phone inside the Police Box door for the very first time. This is the kind of episode that Doctor Who had always been capable of, but until now had so very rarely delivered.
And they've even moved the “Next Week” trailer so they don't cock up the cliffhanger. Icing on the cake.
The Facts
Written by Steven Moffat. Directed by James Hawes. 7.1 million viewers.
Supporting cast: Kate Harvey (Nightclub Singer), Albert Valentine (The Child Jamie), Florence Hoath (Nancy), Cheryl Fergison (Mrs Lloyd), Damian Samuels (Mr Lloyd), John Barrowman (Jack Harkness), Robert Hands (Algy), Joseph Tremain (Jim), Jordan Murphy (Ernie), Brandon Miller (Alf), Richard Wilson (Dr Constantine), Noah Johnson (Voice of the Empty Child), Dian Perry (Computer Voice)
Oh, Isn't That...?
- Richard Wilson has a long television career, including a role as a doctor in the sit-com Only When I Laugh, but he's most famous for his outstanding performance as frustrated curmudgeon Victor Meldrew in six series and change of One Foot in the Grave, rightly recognised as one of the best British sit-coms of all time (it came 10th in a BBC poll). These days he mostly directs for the stage, having founded a theatre company devoted to performing new works by young writers.
- John Barrowman wasn't really famous before this, though you may have glimpsed him in an uncredited role in The Untouchables or enjoyed his musical talents as Cole Porter's first shag in De-Lovely or the Aryan star of "Springtime for Hitler" in the movie of the musical of the movie The Producers. His first starring role was in the 2002 made-in-Belgium creature feature Shark Attack 3: Megalodon. And there need to be more sentences like that in the world.
Working Titles: "World War II"
The Teaser: Alarms blare as a cylindrical object hurtles through the Vortex, with the TARDIS in hot pursuit. The Doctor explains that it's an emergency because the object is mauve, which is the intergalactic colour for danger. Rose is still skeptical, but the Doctor announces they have to chase the cylinder: "It's mauve and dangerous! And about thirty seconds from the centre of London."
Cliffhanger: None.
The Lore
- The name of the alien race, "Chula", was taken from the name of a fusion restaurant where the series one writers often met to discuss ideas.