Aliens of London
| X1.4 - “Aliens of London” | ||||
| Doctor Who Series 1, Episode 4, 16 April, 2005 | ||||
| Featuring the Ninth Doctor with Rose Tyler | ||||
| Written by Russell T. Davies, directed by Keith Boak, produced by Phil Collinson. | ||||
| “The Unquiet Dead” | << | “Aliens of London” | >> | “World War Three” |
Which One is This?
The Doctor and Rose head back in time to Christmas Eve, 1869, and meet Simon Callow. I mean, Charles Dickens. There are also some gas beings masquerading as ghosts and using the recently deceased as meat puppets, and who try to lie their way into inhabiting the dead of Earth as asylum seekers from a war.
Firsts and Lasts
It's the first time the new Doctor travels into the past (at least on screen), and the first time the new-look TARDIS doesn't go exactly where he wants it to go. It's the first "celebrity historical" story, in which the Doctor meets a famous historical figure; from now on there'll be one of these each season: next year it's Queen Victoria in X2.2, Tooth and Claw, and in 2007 the Doctor finally meets Shakespeare in X3.2, The Shakespeare Code. It's also the first time Lawrence Miles goes completely batshit crazy about the new series; see The Lore. It's also the first - but sadly not the last - instance of the Doctor "solving the crisis" by blowing everything up, though technically it was Dickens and Gwyneth on this occasion, so it's also the first instance of the Doctor not solving things himself (and there'll be plenty of that, arguably, this series). We're also introduced to the Cardiff Rift, which returns in X1.11, Boomtown, and plays a major part in Torchwood.
Things to Notice About Aliens of London
- The Gelth are an intriguing race; not only have they been transformed from normal corporeal beings into entities of living gas, but they are handily colour-coded, turning from blue to red as soon as they reveal they are truly evil.
The Continuity
The Doctor
He's a Dickens fan, and acts like a big ol' fanboy when he meets him, though he stops short of asking for an autograph.
Inventory
Ethics
The Doctor doesn't see any problem with using the bodies of deceased humans to house the bodiless Gelth, and grows quite angry with Rose when she finds the idea difficult to accept. He's also not worried about changing the Earth's history when Rose points out that Victorian England wasn't inhabited by alien corpse-thieves.
Background
The Doctor hasn't met Dickens before.
Rose
Rose's knowledge of history is spotty; she doesn't realise her current clothes would cause a stir in the 19th century, but is able to pick out an appropriate dress from the TARDIS wardrobe. She's disappointed to find out they're in Cardiff, and clearly doesn't think Wales is much chop as a holiday destination.
The TARDIS
Not as reliable as it seemed last trip; here it's nine years and thousands of miles off-target, and the Doctor doesn't know this until he exits. [Does the scanner show the wrong location, or does he just not check? His confidence in being able to pilot the Ship doesn't waver because of this mistake or subsequent ones, and no reason is given for the error.]
History
Charles Dickens is giving his usual Christmas Eve performance of "A Christmas Carol"; in 1869, he's in Cardiff. He finds himself embroiled in the Doctor's activities only because one of the Gelth takes its animated corpse to the performance, then escapes at a dramatic moment. We get our first indication that history isn't what it used to be when the Doctor tells Rose that history is in flux and nothing is safe.
The War
The Gelth claim to be casualties of the Time War, somehow losing their corporeal forms as a result of hostilities. They suggest they are innocents, and certainly don't name or claim to be allies of either side.
The Time Lords
Are all gone - but not forgotten, as Jabe from the Forest of Cheem knows of them, though she considers them extinct and that it is impossible one of them still exists. [That they are remembered perhaps indicates that the Time Lords were destroyed in a "conventional" way, rather than being erased from time. On the other hand, Jabe considers that the Doctor "should not exist", so either they were supposedly erased from history, becoming nothing but a story, or their destruction occurred so long ago that it is inconceivable that even a Time Lord would still be alive in the year 5 billion - though that would mean time travel is still considered mostly impossible. There's a lot on this, so see What really happened to the Time Lords?]
The Arc Word
Bad Wolf: Gwynneth sees pictures that frighten her in Rose's mind, including the "Big Bad Wolf". It's the only time the traditional version of the phrase is used.
The Analysis
Where does this come from?
Doing a story in which aliens arrive in full view of the public is hardly new. Orson Welles set the popular template, and it’s no accident that his media rewrite of Wells’ novel is strongly echoed by Davies’ own reliance on TV bulletins to tell so much of his story. What is more notable is how the device recedes in “World War Three”, and that’s one of the reasons why the two episodes should be judged as separate entities: they’re linked, but they’re about subtly different things. At its heart, “Aliens of London” is about humanity’s reaction to world-changing events, and how those reactions are so mediated by TV.
In the modern age this is increasingly something that our world has to ponder. We see so many incredible things on TV that our reactions to them have subtly changed over the decades, particularly in regard to things that were previously horrifying. I remember reading an interview with someone who admitted that he’d originally thought the footage of the World Trade Centre attacks was Spielberg going one better than Welles, and this admission helps to illustrate just how numbed we have become to destructive spectacle. More pungently, films like Hotel Rwanda sketch out how numbing brutality can become, with our generation being quite capable of watching a massacre on CNN and then calmly turning over to watch a sports program. “Aliens” isn’t making quite such an extreme point (although the parties that greet the crashed alien spaceship do suggest the fecklessness that momentous televised events now inspire), but when even the Doctor is distanced from ground zero and has to keep up with the news via TV, you realise just how easily the medium can make the extraordinary seem banal.
However, the most obvious thing about “Aliens of London” is that it takes place in a post-September 11th world. When the spaceship takes out London’s most recognisable landmark and completely reshapes the world in the process, it’s impossible to imagine this image working in the same way on September 10th 2001 (it’s also instructive to think of how the consequences of Davies’ September 11th episode leads inevitably to his War on Iraq episode, but we’ll tease that out when we get to “World War Three”). Possibly the most telling note is that the whole world relives the crash through the media, and just as he does in The Second Coming, Davies expertly parodies the media’s constant scrabble for titbits to feed the public’s hunger for news.
Contrasted with this is Davies’ continuing desire to keep Doctor Who married to pop culture. Inspired by a Girls Aloud music video, “Aliens” mirrors “Rose’s” need to contain the old format in a defiantly modern idiom. Reinforced in no small measure by the fact that Keith Boak directs both episodes, there’s a constant feeling of rushing about, of zeitgeist surfing and an abject fear that the viewer at home will get bored. Moreover, with the farting aliens and generally broad tone being the most brazen grab for the under-ten vote so far, it is blatantly obvious that this is a show desperately trying to be the TV equivalent of Independence Day: spectacle, movement and simple concepts that anyone can plug into.
The last notable element is the strand of the story that deals with Rose’s disappearance. Part of this is a by-product of Davies’ desire to anchor the show in genuine dramatic territory rather than simple action-adventure, but it also has it’s roots in the soapier elements of the New Adventures, and before that the Vertigo comics that inspired them. The modernist movement of comics in the 80s moved into the mainstream with Alan Moore’s Watchmen, but its fascination with juxtaposing the fantastic with the mundane had been kicking around in edgier form at least since Moore’s own Miracleman (and Moore himself remarked that he was just doing a Mad Magazine parody with a straighter face than usual). What seemed daring in 1985 now feels slightly passé. Self-mocking genre exercises like Austin Powers or Buffy have colonised the mainstream media, providing a kind of Greatest Hits package of all the jokes people have been telling about genre clichés. It’s hardly the cleverest thing to do–essentially it’s just the old joke of pointing out that Superman’s underpants look silly when worn on the outside–but if deployed correctly it can make the familiar seem strange again. By subverting some of Doctor Who’s usual narrative standards (companions being genuinely missed, invasions taking place in broad daylight), and insisting on keeping their emotional lives part of the bigger picture (just as authors like Grant Morrison or Joss Whedon made sure that Animal Man or Buffy always come back to their families rather than a Batcave of some description) Davies gives us some of the best moments in the entire episode.
And finally, if we’re feeling unkind, we might also speculate about the influence of the Farrelly Brothers on any element to do with the Slitheen.
But it’s probably best to let that one slide.
Things that Don’t Make Sense
Filling the house with gas removes the Gelth from the corpses like "sucking poison from a wound". Er...why? The Gelth presumably have a density similar to that of the natural gas used to light the lamps, but equally they're presumably not flammable or they'd all be burned to death whenever someone lit a light in the house. This is contradicted, though, by the Gelth seen by Dickens to be sucked into a gas lamp, though it's by no means certain why or what happens to that Gelth.
The main problem is it's never made clear whether they are gaseous themselves, or whether they are merely consciousnesses which can control the natural gas, perhaps in a manner similar to the Nestene control of plastic. Even if that's true, there's no reason why flooding the house with gas would cause them to leave the bodies, and this explanation seems entirely extraneous to the real solution of the problem - blowing up the house full of gas, killing all the Gelth inside and somehow sealing the Rift, at least temporarily. How does an explosion heal a rift in spacetime? [Perhaps it's not the explosion itself, but the psychic shock caused by Gwyneth dying while she's holding it open. There's nothing to suggest this, though, beyond it being an excellent idea.]
Critique
The Prosecution (ish)
In a weird way, despite all it’s other innovations, “Aliens of London” feels a lot like watching old-school Doctor Who. One can’t seriously watch those original episodes now without being in a forgiving mood, and the filters that recognise the pearls amid the dross have been well honed over the years. Basically, despite some fans’ efforts to designate stories like “Pyramids of Mars” as genuinely classic television (usually the same sorts who think that the show’s main artistic rival was Star Trek), Doctor Who was always an exercise in trying to suppress frustration.
And it’s that feeling of frustration that never quite evaporates when you’re watching “Aliens of London”. After something as determinedly old school as “The Unquiet Dead”, for twenty minutes “Aliens” looks like Davies has finally figured out how to do modern Doctor Who. The show has often paid lip service to the idea of companions being drawn from real life, but “Aliens’” examination of exactly what it means for a ‘real’ person to be kidnapped by the Doctor is masterful. Admittedly part of what makes it so successful is simply the shock of the new. A lot of conventions had settled into the bones of Doctor Who’s format, and watching someone gleefully upend them almost feels like what Watchmen did to comics. Among other things, Rose is actually missed! The invasion takes place in the most public way possible! The Doctor can’t get close enough for his usual sifting of the clues so he watches it on telly (and delightfully has to wrestle a kid for the remote control–possibly the most inspired story obstacle of all)! The people of Earth react with joy and wonder! The Doctor “quietly” lands the TARDIS in the middle of some squaddies! And best of all, the people who would usually investigate the menace are the aliens’ first target! Say what you like about the rest of the episode, but for just a little while Davies provides one of the best examples of Doctor Who written with the autopilot switched off.
The hassle is that he does so much that is really remarkable (on the show’s own terms at least) that it only makes his later artistic misjudgements seem all the more annoying. It’s become chic to lay all the blame at the feet of Keith Boak, but while there’s still a worrying… pinkness to the episode, I’m sure he didn’t write in all the fart gags himself. Far too many electrons have been murdered by fanboys bewailing this galumphing lurch into storytelling incompetence, and not a few more have died at the hands of apologists trying to justify how the farting could have worked if Boak weren’t such a hack. But no: Davies is to blame. It’s bad enough that the farting scenes are unfunny and unthreatening, but their inclusion pushes the show so irrevocably toward silliness that the episode never entirely recovers. Obviously you can’t take a story with farting aliens seriously, and this “fact” encourages Boak to root out more gags with a frighteningly misplaced enthusiasm. That explains Mickey’s cartoonish collision with a wall–it’s not very funny, but this is, after all, a story with farting aliens in it. It also explains the villains’ ludicrously OTT delivery of dialogue that reads fairly straight on the page. This isn’t meant to be funny either, but because they’re farting aliens, Boak lets them ham it up. Most damningly, the lumbering unzipping scenes are ruined by the nonsensical inclusion of big toothy zips on the actors’ foreheads. This could have been an indelibly scary moment, but because the scene is revealing farting aliens, Boak apparently seems to think this might rate a chuckle as well. And the script can’t take it. It’s witty and it’s playful, but there’s just not the room to make it turn on the infinitely small tonal penny that Davies and Boak have created.
Gallingly, elsewhere in the episode Davies tries a similarly risky idea, and this time it works perfectly. Although similarly reviled, the space pig is precisely the sort of loopy idea that could so easily have gone wrong… but instead, just for a moment, we glimpse the kind of scary/funny hybrid that “Aliens of London” should have been. Despite the faintly unconvincing animatronics and despite the scientist apparently having wandered in from a porno set, the scene manages to generate tension, pathos and, most importantly, further the plot. It’s moments like this that gave you hope for Doctor Who: 2005, and while Davies and Boak make far too many mistakes for “Aliens of London” to be called a success, it’s still a long, long way from being a failure. Four episodes in and there’s still a sense of adventurousness to what they’re trying to do, a refusal to settle into the spooky escapism that would have been so easy to serve up. It’s just a shame that the episode’s fatal flaw couldn’t have been just a little smaller. After all, if that was the case we could have just put on our old Doctor Who goggles and pretended that there was nothing wrong at all…
The Defence
The Facts
Written by Mark Gatiss. Directed by Euros Lyn. Peak of x million viewers, y% audience share.
Supporting cast: Simon Callow as Charles Dickens, Alan David as Gabriel Sneed, Huw Rhys as Redpath, Jennifer Hill as Mrs Peace, Eve Myles as Gwyneth, Wayne Cater as the Stage Manager, Meic Povey as the Driver, and Zoe Thorne as The Gelth.
Working Titles:
The Teaser: In the funeral parlour a young man named Redpath grieves over the open casket containing his dead grandmother. Closing his eyes in sorrow, he does not see a blue, glowing vapour wash over the corpse and enter it. The old woman's eyes snap open and she grabs Redpath by the throat, killing him. Gabriel Sneed, the undertaker, rushes in and tries to close the lid on the reanimated corpse but she knocks him unconscious to the floor before getting up and wandering out onto the street, wailing.
Cliffhangers: None.
The Lore
- Lawrence Miles hated this one on first viewing, and within an hour of broadcast posted a rant on his web site about the political subtext of the Gelth as asylum seekers who are not innocent but evil, out to exploit liberal generosity (in the form of the Doctor). He was particularly damning of Mark Gatiss, and the Internet community - or that section of it which was aware of him - rallied in Gatiss' defence. Miles edited the review soon after, removing the personal jibes and conceding that the subtext was probably unintentional, but he still felt it should have been detected and edited out of the script. The original review is no longer available; it was replaced with the words: "Go away. I'm thinking about it."