The End of the World
| X1.2 - “The End of the World” | ||||
| Doctor Who Series 1, Episode 2, 2 April, 2005 | ||||
| Featuring the Ninth Doctor with Rose Tyler | ||||
| Written by Russell T Davies, directed by Euros Lyn, produced by Phil Collinson. | ||||
| “Rose” | << | “The End of the World” | >> | “The Unquiet Dead” |
Which One is This?
A host of muppets, aliens and human trampolines watch as the sun expands and destroys the planet Earth once and for all.
Firsts and Lasts
We visit the year 5 billion for the first time, and thus have our first encounters with Lady Cassandra and the Face of Boe (both will return in X2.1, New Earth, and the Face again in X3.3, Gridlock). It's the first time in the new series the Doctor travels through time, and the first we hear of him being the last of the Time Lords. The psychic paper debuts here, as does Rose's "superphone". We also get the first mention of "Bad Wolf" - though as yet we don't know it's significant. And this is the point when Doctor Who becomes a little bit more like all the other high-budget drama shows, as we get our first pre-credits teaser sequence.
Things to Notice About The End of the World
- Eccleston really runs the gamut here: popping away to pop music, getting angrily impatient, shedding a deeply affecting tear and coldly allowing a villain to die. The silly clown from Rose is dead; long live the new Doctor. Oh, wait...he doesn't! Damn.
- Davies' claim that keeping things on or near Earth was partly a budget consideration seems pretty lame when this was the first series' most expensive episode, thanks to the CGI and the costumes. However, despite the opinion of some authors, the aliens here look pretty great, even if they are more Star Wars in look. If you feel uncertain, compare the Moxx, Face of Boe and the others with the similar menagerie of future alien movers and shakers from, say, The Curse of Peladon.
The Continuity
The Doctor
The Doctor knows a bit about the future history of the Earth, and doesn't feel the need to save it from what he considers its final end. It would appear the events of the war are still recent to him, as he sheds a tear when Jabe gives him her sympathy. [Alternatively, he may have been denying its reality for some time, and this is the first time he's been reminded of its personal consequences; the Nestene Consciousness didn't remind the Doctor that he was the last of his kind, after all.]
The Doctor is able to somehow walk between the blades of an enormous and rapidly rotating fan after a moment's concentration. [This is never explained. Since it seems impossible for him to have merely stepped between the blades like some kind of kung fu master, most fans posit that he must either speed up his own perception of time or even slow down the flow of time, both of which seem very Time Lordy abilities. The question of why he would risk Jabe's life holding down the lever when he's able to do this is an interesting one; it may be that he is either uncertain the trick will work, or is loathe to use it because it is somehow dangerous. We'll probably never know.]
Inventory
The sonic screwdriver is now truly an all-purpose device - as well as opening things, the Doctor uses it to hack into the computers of Platform One and deactivate Lady Cassandra's robot spiders. The Doctor also has a small wallet containing of piece of "slightly psychic" paper, which appears to contain the appropriate credentials to back up the Doctor's story. [Note that it works on denizens of the year 5 billion just as well as it does those in more recent timeframes, though as we'll see it doesn't always work as intended. See particularly X1.9 “The Empty Child”, X2.12 “Army of Ghosts” and, perhaps most significantly, X3.2 “The Shakespeare Code”.]
When Rose expresses a wish to contact her Mum, the Doctor supplies her with a device that replaces the battery in her phone, enabling her to call her home time from anywhere. [The signal is presumably relayed by the TARDIS, perhaps using a similar technology to the "space-time telegraph" given to the Brigadier allowing him to call on the Doctor for help in Terror of the Zygons.]
Ethics
Doesn't seem to have ever considered that the TARDIS' telepathic translation of alien languages is an invasion of his companion's heads.
Background
It's unclear whether the Doctor has been to this time period before, though he clearly knows about it. He doesn't speak to or recognise the Face of Boe, so this could be their first meeting [though see "What's the Deal with the Face of Boe?"]. He seems to know the Moxx of Balhoun by reputation, though not personally [it's not clear if this is a title or a name, so perhaps he's met a previous Moxx if it's the latter].
Rose
Rose is savvy enough to remember relevant details about the life cycle of the sun and continental drift when confronted with a familiar looking Earth 5 billion years in the future. She also asks how she is able to understand the aliens on Platform One, and doesn't take kindly to the idea of the TARDIS being inside her head. She doubts her decision of running off with the Doctor when asked about him, as she realises she knows next to nothing about him. [Compare with Martha's similar moment in X3.3 “Gridlock”.] In contrast to every companion before her, she tries to contact her family whilst travelling with the Doctor; he alters her phone to allow this.
Supporting Cast
The Face of Boe
The TARDIS
Still shares the Doctor's Time Lord gift of translation with his travelling companions, and also relays calls from Rose's "superphone" to Rose's home time. [It seems smart enough to know what Rose's current home time frame is, even when it skips 12 months ahead by accident on her next trip home.] Has a bike pump attached to the console. [This may just be for comic effect on the Doctor's part, though the console seems to have been cobbled together from scavenged technology now that Gallifreyan spare parts are definitely unavailable. We also see a handbrake in several later stories, and there's a mallet attached to the console by a bit of string, so how the console actually works now is anyone's guess.] The TARDIS does the translation of alien languages. [This was previously identified as a "Time Lord gift"; the general fan interpretation is that it's natural for Time Lords, but the TARDIS is required to constantly share the gift with other passengers. This certainly fits here. It's also worth noting that in Masque of the Mandragora, where this is first discussed, it's intimated that part of the sharing prevents the beneficiary from worrying about it; obviously that's not the case any more.]
Planet Notes
Platform One is a space station in Earth orbit, shielded from the immense heat of the expanding Sun. It seems to be mobile, having hasted other significant events, though it may also just be that the "classic Earth" and its swollen sun are considered a picturesque backdrop for important functions.
History
It's the year 5.5/Apple/26 - or 5 billion, by the Doctor's reckoning. By this time there are no humans left on the Earth, the human race having spread to the far reaches of the galaxy and changing in innumerable ways. The Lady Cassandra O'Brien Dot Delta Seventeen, now merely a face on a piece of skin supported by a nutrient frame and connected to her brain in a jar, claims to be the last "true" human [because she was the last born on Earth? More likely because she is the only one who can trace her ancestry all the way back to a human born on Earth].
The War
Both Gallifrey and the Time Lord race - save the Doctor - were also destroyed in the Time War. Other races in the year 5 billion are aware of the War, and its consequences, believing the Time Lords to be extinct.
The Time Lords
Are all gone - but not forgotten, as Jabe from the Forest of Cheem knows of them, though she considers them extinct and that it is impossible one of them still exists. [That they are remembered perhaps indicates that the Time Lords were destroyed in a "conventional" way, rather than being erased from time. On the other hand, Jabe considers that the Doctor "should not exist", so either they were supposedly erased from history, becoming nothing but a story, or their destruction occurred so long ago that it is inconceivable that even a Time Lord would still be alive in the year 5 billion - though that would mean time travel is still considered mostly impossible. There's a lot on this, so see "What really happened to the Time Lords?"]
The Arc Word
Bad Wolf: the Face of Boe can be overheard discussing a "possible Bad Wolf scenario" with the Moxx of Balhoun - though it seems unlikely Rose or the Doctor would have picked up on it.
The Analysis
Where does this come from?
There’s a strong seam of political comment running through series one, and The End of the World is where it really starts to get serious. Although there’s a skerrick of environmental awareness in the Doctor’s remarks about the Nestenes’ love of Earth’s plentiful toxins, oil and dioxins, it’s in episode two that our planet’s mortality is moved centre stage. The interesting thing is that Davies seems to be sending out some mixed political signals. The death of planet Earth is clearly meant to be affecting, and Rose’s reaction mirrors that of the environmental lobby. Thus, viewed through the lefty political prism, it’s not difficult to read the “great and good” on Platform One (whom the Doctor explicitly refers to as being basically “the rich”) as representing our current ruling classes. These are the people who have the power and wherewithal to save our planet, but in the final analysis are barely interested in it. Far more absorbed with their own petty concerns, they allow these to obfuscate larger issues and ultimately don’t even notice the planet’s death.
However, while most of the delegates are straightforward grotesques, there is an important exception. Jabe is a representative of a race of tree-people, and she speaks of her ancestors as being part of the Amazon rainforest. She is presented as a positive character, and sees her presence on Platform One as a mark of respect. Consequently, although she doesn’t harangue anyone about the death of the planet, her very presence can be read as a kind of silent rebuke. Jabe is a beautiful creature that gives away cuttings of her family as a valued gift, does her best to save the other guests, and ultimately perishes in the cause. In short, she’s the very definition of a positive depiction of ‘green issues’.
The other side of this coin is the Lady Cassandra. Where Jabe represents the Earth’s beauty, Cassandra is the apotheosis of selfish humanity. Aggressively identifying herself as human, it is fitting that she stands to gain the most from the Earth’s destruction, and if one wishes, the damage that she inflicts on the station can be read as representing current environmental issues. Naturally little robot spiders aren’t currently sabotaging the ecosphere, but the incineration of the Steward following the loss of his sun filter and the rise in temperature on Platform One as its shields are disabled undeniably echo the dissipating ozone layer and global warming.
Further, her overt criminality aside, Cassandra’s narcissism recalls the self-centredness that currently bedevils so much of the environmental debate. With leaders like Bush and Howard hand-waving past the reality of global warming while the public gorge themselves on celebrity culture (and Cassandra’s choice of music is particularly apt in this regard), there’s an undeniable streak of Cassandra-ish behaviour abroad in our society. Davies was inspired to create his villainess after watching award show footage of face-lifted celebrities, and Rose’s allusion to Michael Jackson confirms Cassandra’s role as the famous freak that distracts our attention from more important matters. Most Americans would have an opinion on the outcome of the Jackson trial for instance, but many of them would also drive an SUV, vote for a president obviously in thrall to Big Oil and eat at McDonalds. In a way then, Cassandra is all of us; the part that wants to worry about what’s in the mirror or on the TV instead of the doom and gloom right outside our window. She’s become monstrous in part because she’s so oblivious to the harm she has done to herself, too short sighted to realise what she’s lost in the process. Even her name suggests an ironic allusion to the classical prophetess cursed to have her apocalyptic visions ignored by the public at large.
Finally though, like most of series one, there is a strong dash of pragmatism about the speeches that Davies puts in the mouths of people like the Doctor. Just as he spruiks about seeing the bigger picture, Davies also says “enjoy them while they’re there–because one day they won’t be”. It’s an interesting statement precisely because it can be read so fatalistically. Everything may very well have its time to die, but this sentiment runs as a counterpoint to the never-say-die ethos the Doctor advocates elsewhere. Put simply, a hero that always used to find a solution now admits that there isn’t always one to find. Thus, like those wealthy Victorians that used Darwin’s evolutionary theories to justify their own self-interest, the Doctor’s acquiescence in the face of planetary collapse can be interpreted destructively. This inkling is only enhanced by the fact that the Doctor delivers his sage wisdom about making the most of your time on Earth and then proceeds to wander off with Rose to have chips. The ironic juxtaposition of doing something small after contemplating big issues does help to dodge the bullet of being preachy, but it also runs the risk of simply being a glib punchline.
Things that Don’t Make Sense
The guests on Platform One are supposed to be the "great and the good", i.e., the rich, powerful and/or famous, so how does Lady Cassandra manage to get the Adherents of the Repeated Meme in without anyone getting suspicious? For that matter, why does she need them at all? Why not just deliver the spheres herself? [Presumably she wants them as cover for the hostages so she can escape blame, but surely in the year 5 billion monetary transfers are all electronic and traceable?] Her decision to kill the guests once the Doctor finds her out is also confusing; she seems to believe she can "take control of their corporate holdings", though doing so would surely make her the sole survivor in any investigation.
On the other hand, it's not entirely clear who's running this show; while it's a funny gag to say that the Earth now belongs to the National Trust, it's either an analogy on the Doctor's part or terribly confusing. None of the guests seem to belong to anything like a traditional nation, and it seems unlikely any traditional Earth nations still exist.
This episode marks the beginning of RTD's obsession with the far, far future. Not content with skipping ahead thousands of years, the upper limit for most stories in the past, here we run straight to the year 5 billion, though this is justified somewhat by the plot point of the Earth's destruction due to natural causes. But we're asked to believe some truly staggering things, not least that humans still look basically the same (as evidenced by Cassandra's pre-op form in X2.1, New Earth) while Earth trees have evolved into people, and that artefacts from the twentieth century not only still exist, but still function.
Those things we can maybe stretch ourselves to believe; but that five billion years in the future, the ventilation system is powered by enormous fans positioned in front of an important switch, Galaxy Quest style? Come on.
Critique
The Prosecution
To be fair, the worst thing about The End of the World was how it looked in the “next week” teaser. It seems odd to think about it now, but the levels of silliness in Rose had been a real turnoff, and the glimpse of things like the Moxx of Balhoon seemed to promise that episode two would only get worse. Doctor Who has always been one step away from being ludicrous, and for the designers to be finally given a decent budget and then deliver this seemed to confirm that the new series was just going to be played for campy laughs.
The second worst thing about The End of the World is its plot. Rose, for all its faults, was a pretty good shakedown flight for the new format and it had the added burden of reintroducing the series. Most will forgive first night nerves, but when The End of the World is still grappling with how to tell thrilling adventures in 43 minutes, the misgivings begin to get louder. You start to notice that Cassandra’s plot feels like one of the early Star Trek: The Next Generation villains’. You begin to notice that random set pieces are being thrown at the crew until the perfunctory showdown, and you can’t help but notice that Cassandra’s motivation is almost an afterthought. She’s an instantly gettable character, true, but at the risk of stating the bleedin’ obvious, she’s also very two-dimensional. Her plan feels haphazard (she declares two goals–initially she’s trying to somehow instigate a hostage situation, and when that doesn’t work she’s happy just to kill everybody which will apparently be just as good), almost as if it’s simply there to ensure the thrilling moments rather than to achieve a genuine goal. Couple this with the fact that her conversation with Rose is the only moment we get of genuine insight, and it’s looking suspiciously like Davies is using the Marvel Comics method of villain characterisation: Cassandra is bad just because, but if she looks distinctive[1] she will still be memorable. In a show that only has 43 minutes to play with this is perhaps understandable, but a villain that is simply trading on her looks (and bluntly when those looks are a bit silly) is still a disappointment.
The worst thing about the traditional Doctor Who parts of the episode is that they just feel so uninspired. We’re served up the sinister little spiders that have somehow got off the set of Minority Report, the variation on Goldfinger’s Slow Moving Laser of Doom (always Slower for people that have their name in the opening credits, natch), and the Fans of Inexplicability, and all of them are pretty humdrum stuff. This might not be so bad if this was one of the later ‘business as usual’ kind of episodes, but given that it’s meant to fulfil the Doctor’s promise of mind-blowing adventures, they feel particularly threadbare. Like the design of the alien guests, the motivation behind them just doesn’t seem terribly well thought out, and in a way, it’s apt that the end of the world itself should be so anticlimactic. Blowing up planets just isn’t something that Davies is very good at.
No, it’s the little moments that really make The End of the World as good as it is, and when considered alongside the traditional Doctor Who adventure elements, the gap between Davies’ ambitions and his own strengths are glaring. All the things that old school Doctor Who tended to ignore are brought to the fore in this episode, and it’s this that makes the story seem so individual. Rose’s shocked reaction to the TARDIS’ ‘gift’ of language is a smart way to explain an old standard to a new audience, and her realisation of the dark possibilities that underlie the joys of travelling with the Doctor are brilliantly handled. Of course this sort of thing did used to happen in Doctor Who. Tegan is a good example of how an earlier production team took the time to emphasise the downsides of travel with the Doctor (both in her desire to go home and in her reaction to SF standards like possession), but by and large that notional idea of Doctor Who was a lot truer than it really should have been. Therefore when Rose realises that she doesn’t even know who the Doctor is it’s creepy precisely because we’re not expecting it to happen.
Elsewhere the tug of war between the sublime and the ridiculous is still going on. Davies’ writing is some of the most concertedly witty that Doctor Who has ever seen, and while some of his gags seem forced, moments like Eccleston grooving away to the iPod are the sort of thing that only this version of the show can do. Euros Lyn also deserves no small amount of credit for realising that a story so full of bonkers material needs to be played with a straight bat. After the massive exercise in missing the point that was Keith Boak’s direction of Rose, The End of the World emerges as far more tonally assured, and when it touches greatness you don’t get the impression that it’s by luck. In fairness to Boak, there’s also the impression that for this episode the pressure is off to a certain extent. Rose, as I’ve already stated, was faced with an almost impossible task. The End of the World, while flawed, is a show that quietly breaks new ground while still managing to zero in on the kind of show that Davies really wants to make. It’s by no means flawless, it’s a harbinger of later, more egregious pitfalls and it’s annoying that the things that should come naturally seem to cause so much heavy weather, but it’s a show that’s taken the time to really breathe.
And given all the importance placed on being modern and hip, that’s a valuable thing to do.
The Defence
The Facts
Written by Russell T Davies. Directed by Euros Lyn. Peak of 8.0 million viewers, y% audience share.
Supporting cast:
Working Titles:
The Teaser: The Doctor suggests various future eras for Rose's first TARDIS journey, stopping at each one then deciding to go further; finally, he lets her out into Platform One, where the swollen sun sits behind the Earth, and welcomes her to the End of the World.
Cliffhangers: None.
The Lore
- At the time this was supposedly the most expensive episode of Doctor Who ever, owing to the huge number of CGI effects shots - 203 of them, to be exact. Lady Cassandra and the spiders were entirely CGI, as of course were all the exterior shots....
- ...so it's no wonder they decided to reuse the Face of Boe. This was, though, supposedly planned all along - at least if you're swayed by the cryptic text in the first new series monster book, about the Face having a secret message which it would only impart to the lonely god with its dying breath. We all thought that might happen in X2.1, New Earth, but of course we were wrong. We then expected it to happen in X3.2, Gridlock, but of course...it did.
Notes
- ↑ Well, distinctive if you haven’t seen Brazil and Star Trek: Insurrection.